Buckhead

The Best Burgers in Atlanta

Reid Gan
Reid Gan
Jun 1, 2019 · 5 min read

uckhead, Atlanta is one of the most beautiful, modern, and chic areas in the country. Home to the governor’s mansion, several financial and legal headquarters, and extremely wealthy residential neighborhoods, it’s an experience just to drive around it. Renowned for its stylish, upscale malls and shopping districts, fashion-forward lifestyle, lavish restaurants, various nightclubs, and fantastic bar scene —Buckhead is quite the party.

Actually, imagine everyone stopped attending Gatsby’s parties, moved south, started laying out by the pool, and built an architectural masterpiece of a downtown city center and there you have it.

As far as 50BurgersATL is concerned, this was a difficult area to limit to five burgers. There are so many wonderful chefs and extravagant restaurants that I probably could have tried 20 burger stacks and still missed a couple. I’ve consolidated this list of five burgers to include some upscale dining spots and some “burger joints” for diversity’s sake. But what better place to start than the most famous Atlanta burger…

Holeman & Finch Public House: H&F Burger

The acclaimed Holeman & Finch Burger. Easily one of the most popular “best burgers” of Atlanta, and for good reason. First of all, it was famously limited to 24 burgers per night, and eventually, people were lining up for several hours just to have a chance at it. Secondly, it’s actually just delicious. It’s one of those burgers that’s just flat out good. The perfectly seasoned, cheesy double stack delivers the appropriate crunch from a nicely seared bun, and it’s complemented by the house-made bread and butter pickles and diced red onion. Nothing on it is overpowering, but everything works well together. A classic comparison in the “A” is between the H&F Burger and the Bocado Burger Stack, featured in the West Midtown section. Regardless, the H&F Burger is without a doubt a must-try Atlanta burger, and you won’t be disappointed. Enjoy one with a little more ease, but a little less flare at either Ponce City Market or the SunTrust Park locations.

“We serve 24 [burgers] a night. The grill is only big enough to fit 48 patties, so we serve 24 at brunch, 24 at lunch, 24 at dinner…” — Hostess

Big Al’s Gourmet Butter Made Burgers: The Butter Made Cheeseburger

This particular burger was actually recommended to me by an Uber driver. I’ve tried to not just use other top ten lists as my only source of intel for 50BurgersATL and this is a testament as to why. I didn’t see this burger on anyone’s list, but it definitely deserves to be on all of them. Big Al’s Gourmet Butter Made Burgers boasts hand churned butter and fresh, never frozen angus beef, and it’s much appreciated. I kept things simple with the double butter made burger, and it was everything I needed. This is the perfect Buckhead spot for a quick, affordable double stack. Even Buckhead needs “burger joints.”

“I mean, you gotta get the double Butter Made…” — Cashier

Bone’s: Bones Burger with Buttermilk Onion Rings

I can’t believe the first time I went to Bone’s was for a burger, but it was so scrumptious that it actually makes sense in retrospect. By now, ya’ll know that I prefer a double-stack smash burger, but this half-pound patty practically changed my mind. The Bones Burger comes with Bibb lettuce, tomato, onion and pickles, and you pick your cheese — and with the class of a staple steakhouse, they serve ketchup, mustard, and mayo on the side in ramekins. You may not think of Bone’s as a work-week lunchtime spot, at least on a regular human salary, but the burger was served pretty quickly and wasn’t over-priced, despite its prime quality of meat. It’s pretty easy to see why this burger ranked so high in Atlanta Magazine’s 20 Best Burgers.

“The pecan pie here — I’ll tell ya what… in 10 years you’ll think it’s better than sex…” — Bartender

US Cafe: Double US Angus Burger

The Double US Burger from US Cafe delivered on all fronts. Fast, casual, affordable, and tasty. Again, I think it’s pretty easy to get caught up in the fine dining of Buckhead and you get used to putting a white linen napkin on your slacks — but sometimes, you just want a quick, cheap pile of deliciousness. A day may come when I’m too wealthy to be seen holding the likes of a lunch tray with a paper liner, but not as long as US cafe keeps serving up double stacks like this bad boy. So place your order at the register, listen for your number, and enjoy the toasted sesame seed bun, angus beef, melted cheese and the freshest ingredients of your choice.

“Was it good? I’ve wanted to eat there so many times, but never have!” — the girl next door (to the restaurant)

American Cut: Cut Burger

As one of the better, more exciting fine dining spots in Buckhead, American Cut never ceases to impress. My old fashioned glass was placed on a torched and smoked hickory wood slab while my server concocted my favorite cocktail. We were pampered from start to finish. This was another restaurant where I just wanted to order everything, and was almost sad that I was there for a burger, but then I was brought to life when I took my first bite. The beer cheese is made with Miller High Life and melted to an almost-liquid state. The caramelized onions are fried with a little Jack Daniels and are prevalent but not overpowering. The Cut Burger works perfectly after a fancy night out when you’re looking to wind down and come back to earth but still give your tastebuds a treat.

“Obviously the steaks are great, but you can’t go wrong with that burger…” — Server

Believe it or not, this not only wraps up the Buckhead burger scene, but also ALL 50 of the best burgers in Atlanta! This is the last blog of 50BurgersATL — I plan on doing one more to summarize and get them all in one place. My hope is to eventually be available to anyone who googles “best burgers in Atlanta” or “best burgers in [some area that I’ve covered].”

Thank you all for reading and putting up with my social network sabotage. Keep reading, eating, and exploring.

50BurgersATL

Wading in cholesterol; trying 50 of the best burgers in…

Reid Gan

Written by

Reid Gan

Copywriter at Bearpaw Partners, which is how I afford my dog’s apartment.

50BurgersATL

Wading in cholesterol; trying 50 of the best burgers in Atlanta, Georgia.

Reid Gan

Written by

Reid Gan

Copywriter at Bearpaw Partners, which is how I afford my dog’s apartment.

50BurgersATL

Wading in cholesterol; trying 50 of the best burgers in Atlanta, Georgia.

Medium is an open platform where 170 million readers come to find insightful and dynamic thinking. Here, expert and undiscovered voices alike dive into the heart of any topic and bring new ideas to the surface. Learn more

Follow the writers, publications, and topics that matter to you, and you’ll see them on your homepage and in your inbox. Explore

If you have a story to tell, knowledge to share, or a perspective to offer — welcome home. It’s easy and free to post your thinking on any topic. Write on Medium

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store