Supporting All Learners with Complex Texts
By Carey Swanson
Does this sound familiar? You design an exciting lesson to tackle rich and engaging complex texts with your students, then a voice in your head stops you in your tracks. The voice asks “but what about ____________?”
You can fill in the blank with any of your struggling students. Perhaps it’s a 6th grader reading at a 3rd grade level, who refuses to read aloud the texts in the sixth grade curriculum due to her frustrations with her reading fluency. Perhaps it’s a group of English Language Learners without the vocabulary exposure and knowledge needed to make sense of the topic-specific unit you are about to launch. Or perhaps it’s three of your IEP students who were traditionally pulled out of whole class instruction for leveled reading work during your full-class reading instruction.
The temptation may be to dismiss this nagging voice that is getting you down: to tell it to be quiet and accuse it of having low expectations; to push forward and just hand the passage out or to hand out an easier text. Don’t! Putting texts that are too hard in front of students with individualized needs, with no scaffolds or supports, will not miraculously make these students great readers. Instead, consider how support might enable them to engage more fully with a new rich text. What actions might make the text more accessible? Below is a partial list of adaptable scaffolding ideas to support all students:
Provide student-friendly glossaries and/or re-format the text to include visual cues for key academic vocabulary that may prevent students from understanding what they are reading. This can be done as a full-class support for students, but also on a more individualized level for students for whom vocabulary deficits may be the missing piece of the puzzle. Picture cues can also be used to support text-dependent questions students are answering during subsequent re-reads.
Use Deliberate Annotation:
Number the lines of the text whenever possible to help students navigate the text when searching for evidence. Consider when to pre-annotate texts with a defined purpose for reading. Pre-annotating is especially helpful in blended texts when two or more genres are combined. While reading, support students in annotating for key ideas, which may involve providing structured overviews. After reading once for meaning, chunk the text into sections when re-reading and allow time for students to annotate the sections or discuss with their peers.
Use Questions as Planned Scaffolds:
A strong series of questions supports all students and focuses reading comprehension for higher-needs students. Pre-plan questions systematically, so that they build from basic comprehension to a more abstract or inferential interpretation. Providing “hint cards” to direct students to specific portions of the text to answer questions can help them learn to use the text and re-read for meaning. Building questions that use paragraph or line numbers, section headings, and other cues to support use of the text in the wording of the question itself can further support this work.
Allow Time for Reflection and Discussion:
Balance the group discussion time by giving students time to write quietly to prepare for oral discussion or provide time to talk things out with their peers to prepare for writing. Ensure that all students are participating by providing time for partners or small groups to talk and write together.
Want more ideas? The Strategies for Supporting Struggling Readers handout includes the suggestions above and more concrete teacher moves that can support all learners in your classroom.