Jesus fokken christ, you know this is not really easy to compare? Here, i’ve used diff.pics http://diff.pics/aq7bdW5S3Dx4/1 and pictures you used to present it better (sure, making orig-bad, bad-old, orig-old orig-new and old-new would be perfect, but I don’t have THAT much of the autism and you can download them from my diff or from here and make it if you want.)

Also, pictures are not even the same size and looks like they were cut (they are offset a little bit due of that). Can’t you just use screenshot feature in your player and compress it with png level 9?