I wouldn’t focus on Ashkenazi otherwise u r saying Jews are an ethnicity.
Tony Greenstein

It’s very interesting, how definitions differ and how they are changed; almost every week another definitions. :-)

Ashkenazi means “German Jews” and is a term used for Jews living formerly in Europe/EastEurope; mainly in “Staettele”; mainly speaking “jiddish”. Those jews who left Europe (alija, beginning ~1880) from Russia, Ukraine, Poland, … Long before Hitler 1933.

Ethnically they are not Semites. Israeli Jews immigrated from Europe/Easteurope to Palestine/Israel or USA/Canada are the ashkenazi-part.

Semites = children of “Sem” includes Arabs and jewish Arabs and oriental jews; mizrachim and sephardim are the semite-/oriental-part; its an ethnical group with different religions, including jewish religion.

— — -
Can an atheist be a Jew? If jewish is a religion ==> no. 
If a Jew converts to Catholic-religion or converts to Islam, can he/she stay a Jew? If jewish is a religion, answer should be “no”.

I know, for political propaganda reasons (#ZionHasbara), the definition of “jewish” (religion or ethnic-group) is important and is changed regurarly, depending of political goals.

Ben Gurion made a sort of “pregnant vergine”: he claimed zionism is secular, but he used/abused lots of arguments, stories, legends from the Bible.

This is the reason, why President Truman made a correction: https://www.screencast.com/t/riZ9j9nDL9l

Shlomo Sand (see amazon) describes this in two books in detail.

One clap, two clap, three clap, forty?

By clapping more or less, you can signal to us which stories really stand out.