What numbers do you have to demonstrate that Tidal is not doing well? Are there any public numbers available on any of these services aside from what Spotify has said about their numbers? As for your Tidal critiques, that can be launched at every streaming service. I agree with most of what you said, but that’s asking an awful lot. They already promote new artists better than the other services. Tidal discovery artists are currently being put on the big stages at Made in America.