Image for post
Image for post

If You Love The Internet,

You Should Thank The DMCA

Michael Beckerman
Jun 22, 2016 · 4 min read

If you’ve been following the current conversation about the state of our country’s copyright system, you might be led to believe there is a brewing battle between the internet and some in the creative industry.

And while a few players are pushing a divisive narrative and attacking the laws that form the economic foundation of the internet, the reality is that we are all in this together. Both sides must work to make the copyright system a success.

Even in 1998, Congress understood the power of this symbiosis: the success of the internet and creators are intertwined. They knew a balanced system would grow the internet and protect rightsholders’ ability to thrive online.

At its most basic level, the DMCA allows rightsholders to identify infringing content and requires platforms to take down that content in a responsive manner. The bargain is simple: rightsholders have a mechanism to address infringement without engaging in a lengthy and expensive legal battle, and internet platforms that respond quickly to remove infringing content are held harmless for the actions of their users.

The law is working: The internet sector is now a global driver of the economy, reaching nearly $1 trillion — or 6 percent — of our GDP in 2014 alone. An era of previously unimagined cultural diversity is available globally at the touch of a finger. But the internet is not the only beneficiary of this arrangement.

In the U.S., the growth of the internet as a whole, and the growth of users connected to the internet, surpasses the growth of infringing activity on a percentage basis. In addition, the DMCA has ensured that legal platforms can scale: studies indicate that the introduction of lawful online video and music platforms is typically followed by reductions in online infringement by 50 percent and 80 percent, respectively.

The growth of legal content consumption has driven the entertainment industry to grow from $449 billion in 1998 to $745 billion just twelve years after the DMCA was enacted. Lower barriers to entry are available for millions of small and independent businesses and artists to access worldwide markets.

Despite the DMCA’s resounding success, there is a call by some to unwind the balance struck in the law and hold internet companies liable for policing every single piece of online content.

Congress gave rightsholders the job of identifying content for a reason: they are the only ones who can. Platforms don’t have access to constantly changing licensing information, nor are they the appropriate party to make legal judgments about whether content qualifies as fair use, a critical flexibility in copyright law that allows users legal access to content and encourages new forms of follow-on creativity. Instead, internet platforms would be responsible for the expeditious removal of infringing content and establishing policies to make sure rightsholders were valuable partners.

The assumption was that because the success of this paradigm would be mutually beneficial, both sides would do their best to contribute to the copyright enforcement process.

Perhaps the best example of the internet industry’s commitment to holding up our end of the bargain is the plethora of voluntary “DMCA-plus” programs in use today. Because the DMCA provides internet companies with a floor, not a ceiling, of action, platforms are encouraged to experiment with voluntary mechanisms. These “DMCA-plus” programs are often tailored to the unique scale and functions of a platform, and are dynamic processes that are reviewed and improved upon frequently, providing greater flexibility and effectiveness for rightsholders. Programs like ContentID on YouTube (which is used for 98 percent of rights management on YouTube), the “no-PIN” option on Pinterest, and Rights Manager on Facebook are all examples of how companies are using their individual experiences to work with creators.

The internet industry is leading by example and demonstrating our commitment to what should be a shared goal. Join us.

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch

Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore

Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store