‘The potential application is huge’

Minnesota is watching as the Rice Creek Watershed District tests a new way to remove carp. Designed to improve water quality in Long Lake, the techniques used here could be applied throughout the state where carp migrate to spawn.

From left: Post-doctoral researcher Peter Hundt and University of Minnesota technician Kao Vang work with Emil Kukulski, director of Poland-based ProCom System’s hydro-ecological department, on April 30 in Rice Creek to reposition a chute through which carp will pass when they migrate upstream from Long Lake to spawn in the Lino Chain of Lakes. The Rice Lake Watershed District is testing a low-voltage electrical guidance system. Paired with a Whooshh System (AKA carp cannon), it is designed to remove about 75 percent of migrating carp. Carp removal is one part of RCWD’s $7.3 million plan to improve water quality in Long Lake. Photo Credits: Ann Wessel, BWSR

NEW BRIGHTON — An experimental carp removal system being tested this month on Rice Creek could change the way Minnesota deals with the invasive fish that degrade lakes’ water quality and habitat.

If it works, the system could be used where invasive common carp migrate to spawn.

“The potential application is huge, because carp show these spawning migrations in many, many different lake systems,” said lead project researcher Przemek Bajer of the Minnesota Aquatic Invasive Species Research Center. “If you could create a device that removes them from the stream without a lot of physical labor — that would basically revolutionize carp management. You could remove 50 to 80 percent of the population with one or two people with very little effort.”

The system combines technology used in Poland to keep fish out of hydroelectric plants with technology developed in the U.S. to pick fruit.

Carp removal is just one element of Rice Creek Watershed District’s four-part, $7.3 million Long Lake Targeted Watershed Demonstration Project, a comprehensive approach to improve water quality in nutrient-impaired Long Lake. A $3 million Targeted Watershed Demonstration Program grant from the Minnesota Board of Water and Soil Resources was awarded to assist that effort.

Matt Kocian, Rice Creek Watershed District’s lake and stream specialist, and Przemek Bajer of the Minnesota Aquatic Invasive Species Research Center discuss progress of the carp removal system being installed April 30 on Rice Creek in New Brighton. A second system would stop juvenile carp from migrating downstream from the Lino Chain of Lakes.

“Algae blooms are frequent; they can be intense,” said Matt Kocian, RCWD lake and stream specialist. “Common carp exacerbate that problem big time. We know in Long Lake and in some of our other lakes we’re not going to meet water-quality standards without addressing carp.”

Carp stir up the lake bottom in search of food, which increases turbidity and frees nutrients that feed algae growth.

To make a noticeable difference in Long Lake, the RCWD estimates the carp population must drop from 800 kilograms per hectare to 100 kg/ha. A single female can produce 1 million eggs a year.

Each spring, approximately 20,000 carp that over-winter in New Brighton’s Long Lake swim up Rice Creek to spawn in the shallow Lino Chain of Lakes.

The experimental system would remove about 75 percent of adult carp leaving Long Lake; a second installation would deter about 75 percent of juvenile carp leaving the Lino Chain of Lakes.

Emil Kukulski, director of Poland-based ProCom System’s hydro-ecological department, was on site for a week to test the electrical guidance system. It was developed to keep native fish out of hydroelectric plants’ water intake systems. In Michigan, it was adapted to control invasive sea lampreys.

On Day 5 of a seven-day site visit to test the electrical guidance system, Emil Kukulski stood waist-deep in Rice Creek. The hydro-ecological department director of Poland-based Procom System, Kukulski was reconfiguring the chute through which the carp will pass.

The system is designed like this: Lines of positive and negative electrodes produce a low-voltage current that carp will not pass. The electrodes are attached to buoys anchored to a track on the creek bottom. Angled across the creek, the electric guidance system funnels carp to a gate. The only upstream route, it leads to a fish ladder — “steps” built on a floating wood platform. When carp reach the metal chute at the top, they’ll drop into the so-called carp cannon.

The Whooshh System, which was developed to pick fruit, and then modified to safely move salmon over dams, will pneumatically propel carp through a plastic tube and into a holding bin on shore.

On April 30 the carp were migrating. The electric barrier was working. But the fish refused to enter the gate.

A similar project worked on invasive sea lampreys in Michigan. The electrical guidance system keeps native fish out of hydroelectric plants’ water intakes at 20 sites in Poland, Switzerland and Brazil.

This is the first time it’s being tried in Minnesota.

Kukulski — along with post-doctoral student Peter Hundt and University of Minnesota technicians Kao Vang and Cameron Swanson — pounded black PVC pipes into a collar that will hold the repositioned chute in place.

MAISRC adapted the electric barrier and pneumatic removal technologies with funds from RCWD, the BWSR Clean Water Fund grant and the Environment and Natural Resources Trust Fund.

RCWD will lease and test the ProCom equipment for two years (at a cost of $120,000) before deciding whether to purchase for an additional $30,000. RCWD will pay $80,000, part of the cost to lease the Whooshh System for two years; the University of Minnesota will pay the balance.

If the fish don’t cooperate soon, Bajer said experiments would resume in the summer when carp migrate in lesser numbers. The average spring migration runs 10 to 14 days.

“There are fish trying to cross the barrier every day. They have been really trying aggressively to cross it,” Bajer said two days after the reconfiguration. “However, they do not want to swim through our fish ladder. So we keep adjusting, changing one thing at a time trying to figure out what they don’t like about our design.”

Przemek Bajer of the Minnesota Aquatic Invasive Species Research Center, the lead project researcher, was on site April 30 to help make adjustments to the carp removal system in Rice Creek.

The crew tried enlarging the entrance, positioning the fish ladder deeper in the water, adding branches to naturalize the approach, increasing water flow with a second pump. Next, Bajer planned to disconnect everything but the entrance.

Once the carp do move, they’ll be tracked.

Employees of Bajer’s company, Carp Solutions, tagged about 1,000 carp last year. They installed five antennae — near the approach, at the gate, at the start and exit of the fish ladder, and about a mile upstream — to monitor carp movements. Data will help determine the best management strategy.

Five antennae will monitor the movements of about 1,000 carp tagged last year.

“We’re learning how sensitive they are to structures that we’re putting in the stream,” Bajer said. “They seem to be very cautious. The fish ladder is a good example. Even though they could easily cross it, they just don’t want to.”

Watershed districts throughout the state are paying attention. Two Minnehaha Creek Watershed District employees were on site recently to see the testing.

“If it works, it’s a big deal. It could be a game-changer for how we manage carp,” Kocian said. “What we’re testing here absolutely could be modified and implemented in other locations.”

The Minnesota Board of Water and Soil Resources’ mission is to improve and protect Minnesota’s water and soil resources by working in partnership with local organizations and private landowners. Website: www.bwsr.state.mn.us.


A remeandered stretch of Rice Creek, at left, will be more apparent when the water levels recede. The creek project is one part of Rice Lake Watershed District’s plan to improve water quality in Long Lake.

Four-part Long Lake plan

Rice Creek Watershed District’s Long Lake Targeted Watershed Demonstration Project addresses phosphorus- and nutrient-loading from the 100,000 acres that flow into Long Lake. The project has four elements:

· Hansen Park stormwater retrofits in New Brighton, where a $4 million iron-enhanced filter is slated to go online this summer;

· Mirror Lake stormwater retrofits in Saint Anthony Village;

· Middle Rice Creek restoration, where a remeandering added a half-mile in creek length and will help to reduce erosion and sediment-loading;

· Invasive common carp management.

Who’s involved

Rice Creek Watershed District’s project partners include the Minnesota Aquatic Invasive Species Research Center, the Environment and Natural Resources Trust Fund, the Clean Water Land & Legacy Amendment, Minnesota Board of Water and Soil Resources, Ramsey and Anoka county parks.