IDLE OPINIONS : Tap Tap Dig — Idle Clicker Game Review
I am embarking on a new endeavor to catalog and make a record of my experience playing different incremental, idle, and clicker games. I’ve been playing these sorts of games for years, and have been itching to catalog my thoughts as I cycle through them. Welcome to…
IDLE OPINIONS
Put on some finger cots and get those tappers ready, because today we’re taking a look at a rather click-intensive game: Tap Tap Dig — Idle Clicker Game. This is developed by Bacon Bandit Games and published by Iron Horse Games, LLC. This game is relatively new, having entered open beta on Google Play around January of 2018 and the full release can now be found on either Android or iOS.
In Tap Tap Dig, you are a miner and you seem to have undertaken the rather inadvisable aspiration of digging to the center of the earth. In order to do so, you’ll dig through layer after layer of the Earth’s unsuspecting crust. In classic clicker style, you can either hire helpers which provide a static damage per second, or click madly with as many fingers as you can fit on the screen.

Although at first blush, the ad system felt very typical (watch ad to speed up cooldown, double idle gold, reroll prestige bonus options, or to get some IAP currency), there is another layer to the ad system that, despite myself, I found to be a successful gamification of ad watching: as you watch ads, they count towards a tally that allows permanent bonuses; once you’ve watched a total of three ads, you get 50% more idle damage. Five more ads gives you a permanent 50% boost to click damage, and so forth. Although I usually steer clear of ads and just pay for an IAP or two if I like a game, this system does make it feel more worth your time to watch the ads.
As an aside, you can also short cut the ad watching for the permanent boosts by paying 10 gems (the IAP currency) instead of watching an ad. By way of the IAP store’s conversion rate, this means that you are getting the equivalent of about $0.66 worth of IAP currency per ad watched (if you watch an ad rather than purchase the global buffs, you’d save yourself 10 gems per ad watched). I suspect the developer sees much less than that $0.66 per ad watched, so the developer seems to be putting a higher value on users watching the ads than typical.
Back to the game! The prestige cycle will earn you fossils that provide a global damage buff per fossil (this starts at a +5%, or a multiplier of +0.05x, per active fossil). Passive players might find they can prestige a few times a day (depending on how often the user checks back in). When I spent a couple prestiges clicking furiously with all 10 fingers, I was prestiging every 15 minutes or so (though the pace is not really sustainable. Get those ice packs ready!). Fossils are earned from obsidian layers, which take more damage to dig through, and seem to show up about every 50–100 layers.

Fossils can be spent on “Benefactors,” who provide some global boosts like increased critical taps, increased gold, decreased upgrade prices, increased fossils per obsidian layer, etc. While a couple of these will assist in prestige clear speed (for example, increased fossils per obsidian layer, decreased HP per obsidian layer, and increased global buff per active fossil), most of these benefactors do not seem to be worth the cost of active fossils you must expend to get them.
For example, your sixth benefactor will cost you 55 fossils. But those same fossils by themselves and unspent will give at least a 275% (or 2.75x) increase in damage. So for the most part, it seems to be rather beneficial to pick up the above mentioned cycle-speeding benefactors, and leave the others unpurchased in favor of the raw damage boost from the unspent fossils.

A player certainly could play Tap Tap Dig as an idle game, but the benefit from tapping, even somewhat slowly, seems to far outweigh the damage potential from idling: total idle damage per second and damage per click are usually about the same value if you upgrade them equally in costs. The difference comes in as a result of being able to click a LOT more than one time per second, because….
Although there is more clicking involved than I typically enjoy, Tap Tap Dig does something I really rather like to see in clicker games, and that I wish more developers would do: you are able to click simultaneously with seemingly as many fingers as you can fit on the screen. Many clicker games will allow you to click only once at a time, but in Tap Tap Dig, it seems to work fine using all 10 fingers to tap in unison, or staggered — as you prefer. I can’t help but wonder if there is a programmed limit to this, or if it really is “as many fingers as you can fit on the screen.” If it’s the latter, I can imagine some experiments that want doing where one plays on a larger tablet and rigs up a bundle of a few dozen capacitive stylus. But I digress…

Suffice to say that clicking seems to be something like 25–50 times more potent than idling (depending on how speedy of a multi-finger-clicker you are). If you’re a more passive-type player, I’d recommend starting the first handful of runs manually tapping. This will allow you to build up some global damage buffs from your fossils, at which point it’s more viable to switch to idling (though clicking always seems to be much more potent; the gap does not appear to close over time).
Achievements will provide another source of multiplicative global damage buffs. As you complete things like total damage dealt, number of clicks, layers destroyed, etc, you will get a buff to damage for each milestone. These buffs start at 1% (for clicking using 10 active skills, for example), and I have seen them go up to 10% per milestone, and maybe more (I’ve only gotten about halfway up the milestones thus far).
The target audience for this game are players who don’t mind, or enjoy tapping their phone a bunch. Although I prefer games more heavily weighted towards idling, I will grant that there’s a certain dynamic peacefulness in turning your brain off for a few minutes and just mashing your phone.
On average, I’d suspect a typical idle/clicker/incremental player to spend perhaps a 3–10 hours on this game, though it will heavily depend on whether you’re a fan of prodigious amounts of tapping. If you’re a Tap Fan™ with calloused and hardened fingertips, the multi-finger tap capability sets Tap Tap Dig apart from and above many other clickers that only allow one click at a time. That and the fact that your ad views count towards both an immediate reward but also larger, longer-term rewards seem to be a main hook for the game. You’ll have to decide if those sound satisfying or not to you.
The graphics are neither poor, nor impressive — they serve the purpose. The setting itself is somewhat prosaic to me, but gives a framework to why you’re doing all this tapping. The music is on a bit of a short loop, but it’s not particularly intrusive or grating. I will say that the sound effect from clicking does provide a satisfying little TWACK.
All told, I’d probably put Tap Tap Dig above most other click-centric games, though my personal preference would steer me towards a more idle-focused game generally speaking. I’d probably place it in the upper quartile of clicker games, but closer to the 50% mark for the overall genre of clicker, idle, and incremental games.
Ratings — From 1 (Troll) to 10 (Magnificent)
3/10 Idle/AFK mechanics — This game is meant to be a clicker much more so than an idle game, and as advertised: Tap Tap Dig — Idle Clicker Game. It’s got “tapping” in the title three times more than it has “idle” so I suppose truth in advertising?
8/10 Incremental — there are lots of sources of multiplicative global boosts (achievements, fossils, cumulative ad rewards, benefactors), so you can actually get a pretty notable global damage multiplier going relatively quickly.
6/10 Balance — pricing seems to scale fairly well so that you’re not waiting for a terribly long time. The balance between tapping and idling is much further askew (towards clicking).
7/10 Prestige — It seems to be the case that relatively short prestiges multiple times is better than less and longer prestiges. I think the rate of accruing prestige benefits from fossils feels good, though I also feel obliged to knock off a few points for the fact that most benefactors aren’t seemingly worth their fossil cost.
6/10 Gameplay — Repetitive as are many clicker titles. If you don’t mind the clicking, the play cycle is fairly fun, if a bit brainless. I would like to see a bit more variation in the mid- to late-game; as it is right now, you get most all the game mechanics in the first couple hours, and then it’s just more and bigger of the same (unless I’m missing something).
5/10 Graphics — nothing great nor poor here.
4/10 Style, Setting, Music — The setting of “dig deeper” doesn’t feel particularly fresh. The way it is implemented is at least somewhat appealing (in terms of visual layout). I wasn’t “wowed” by any particular part of the UI, but neither did I find any bugs. I found it somewhat lacking in music, and generally found myself playing with the sound turned off after having heard the short-ish music loop for a couple hours.
Idle Opinion: I’d call Tap Tap Dig better than average as a clicker, but fairly middling as an incremental. A Tap Fan™ or those that find the cumulative ad rewards to be satisfying will probably find it more enjoyable, and those averse to clicking will likely tire of the game pretty quickly.
If you enjoyed this article, or any of my garrulous creations, you can support me in making more things by buying me a coffee, or by subscribing to my YouTube channel!
Additionally, if you’ve your own YouTube channel, or want to have one, I’ve created an 80 page pay-what-you-want guide to help you make your YouTube channel better.
