Part 2: How To Be An Adult -Kegan’s Theory of Adult Development

Credit: Unsplash

In Part 1 I introduced a new way of viewing adulthood, based on Dr. Kegan’s Theory of Adult Development.

According to Kegan, becoming an adult isn’t only about gaining new skills, status or money.

It’s about becoming someone who doesn’t need others to tell them what to do, is self-directed, can navigate across seemingly competing ideas and perspectives without subsuming their own and can develop authentic, mature relations with others.

It means operating at Kegan’s higher stages of development: Stage 4 — Self Authoring and Stage 5 — Self Transforming. If you didn’t read Part 1, I suggest you do now (it provides a general overview of Kegan’s theory).

In Part 2, I focus on how to transition to Stage 4. Part 3 will focus on transitioning from Stage 4 to Stage 5.

It’s important to note that the path to higher stages is not linear, it’s complex and involves a lot of back and forth. Moreover, each stage describes an ideal outcome — no individual fits all aspects of these descriptions. Rather these stages serve as a road map, as a way for us to orient ourselves about how we currently experience reality.

What is Self-Authorship?

Self Authorship is about defining and reshaping (authoring) what you believe (epistemology), your sense of self (intrapersonal), and your relationships with others (interpersonal), rather than uncritically accepting them from other people.

All three dimensions are critical for the construction of a self-authored system.

  • How/what do I know? (Beliefs) — Generating and coordinating one’s own beliefs, values and internal loyalties, rather than depending on external influences for shaping one’s thoughts.
  • Who am I? (Intrapersonal) — Being concerned with personal integrity - aligning actions with values.
  • How do I want to construct relationships with others? (Interpersonal) — Thinking about feelings and relationships instead of being subject to them.

The key is to view your ‘self’ as object — i.e. something that can be evaluated, analyzed and understood.

How to Get There — The 3 Phases of the Journey to Self Authorship

Building on Kegan’s theory, Marcia B. Baxter Magolda discovered three key elements of self authorship (*the following reflects my thoughts, based on Magolda’s and others’ work).

1. Moving towards self-authorship — cultivating the internal voice

We listen to and cultivate our internal voice by shifting our energy from worrying about what other people think (about us and everything else), to clearly determining what we think.

The problem is that we’ve been mixing up our thoughts with other people’s thoughts for most of our adult lives.

What we need is clarity. Clarity about who we are, what we think, what we want and why.

How do we do this? By practicing curiosity, critical reflection and openness.

We know what it’s like to be curious about other people and things.

Yet, we’re rarely as curious about ourselves. We take ourselves for granted, as though we’ve got ourselves figured out and need to move on to something more interesting.

That’s bullshit.

The only way to start operating from Stage 4 — Self Authorship, is to practice being curious about ourselves.

So how do you practice curiosity? By asking yourself questions.

Question #1: What do I think?

The first aspect of Self Authorship is epistemological — i.e. your beliefs, thoughts and values.

Most of us don’t really know what we believe, think and value.

We repeat what we hear or experience — from our parents, our friends, our communities, society, etc. — without taking the time to explore and analyze our thoughts. Moreover, conversations rarely get deep enough (unless you’re in therapy, a workshop, etc.) to really challenge us to think about what we think.

Simple exercise: What do you think about the phrase “love means never having to say you’re sorry.”

We’ve all heard this before, and often accepted it as truth. But what does it mean to you?

Do you agree or disagree and why? State your opinion in a full sentence.

That means more than a ‘yes’ or ‘no’ answer. It means stating an opinion and then supporting it with your beliefs and values.

Practice this throughout your day. Pay attention to what you see and hear around you. Stop for a second and be curious about what you think and ask: What do I actually think about this and why?

They key is to state your thoughts in a coherent sentence (in your mind or out loud, whatever you want).

We don’t spend enough time stating and explaining our beliefs and thoughts. I believe that doing so can bring us more in touch with who we are.

Here are more examples:

  • What do I think a relationship should look like and why?
  • How do I know that someone is a good friend?
  • What’s my policy on honesty and why?

Question #2: What do I want?

This relates to the intrapersonal and interpersonal dimensions of Self Authorship.

Operating from Self Authorship means defining what we want and clearly communicating those wants to the people we care about.

Most of us spend too much time managing and reacting to other people’s wants (partner, kids, co-workers, boss, parents, etc.), and not enough time clarifying what we want.

The result is that we’ve gotten into the habit of doing things because we feel guilty or ‘bad’ instead of doing them because they align with the person we want to be.

In order to reach Self Authorship, we need to practice operating from the place of “what do I want” versus “what do other people want from me”.

For example, a few months ago I was part of a camp where everyone is expected to help out. For the first few days I felt guilty for not helping out enough and started worrying about how the other camp members were perceiving me. While I started helping out more, it was because I felt guilty and didn’t want the other camp members judging me. These feelings persisted the entire time I was there.

I could have avoided all these negative feelings by simply asking “what do I want?” Do I want to be a contributing camp member? Or do I want to bail on my responsibilities? Either way, I decide what I want and I deal with the consequences of my decision. It doesn’t matter what other people think of me. What matters is the kind of person I want to be.

It’s a small shift but it can go a long way. The important thing is to put yourself in the driver’s seat of your emotions and behaviors. To clarify what you want and then be willing to accept the consequences.

Remember, what we’re after here is clarity.

A good exercise for clarifying your wants is to get very very specific.

We often use ‘big’ words to describe what we want — i.e. “I want you to care more”, “I want more responsibility”, “I want more alone time”, etc.

The problem is that no one (including yourself) knows what you really mean — which causes conflict and misunderstandings.

Instead, do the work and first figure out exactly what you want. For example, you can say: “I want you to check in with me once a day”, “I want you to take the lead on Project X” or “I want one hour a week to work on my own”.

The clearer you are about what you want, the easier you make it for yourself and other people to make decisions.

For example, by stating specifically “I want you to check in with me once a day”, you do three things: 1. You clarify what you want to yourself, 2. You clarify what you want to the other person (now they can decide if they can give you this or not) and 3. You decide what you’re willing to live with.

If the other person can’t give you what you want, you then need to decide what to do next. The point is that now the conversation has moved to real, tangible things — not abstract concepts and misunderstandings.

It’s important to practice articulating your wants to the people you care about. In general, people are not good at doing this. However, the more you practice this the more authentic your relationships can be.

Question #3: What are my motivations?

In order to get real about what you want, you need to understand your motivations.

We all have higher and lower motivations. Or, as James Altucher writes, good reasons and real reasons.

  • Higher motivations (good reason) come from our ‘higher’ selves — the person we want to be, or imagine ourselves to be
  • Lower motivations (real reason) come from our ‘lower’ selves — driven by guilt, desire, ego, uncertainty, etc.

For example, take criticizing a colleague. Your higher motivation may be to help them improve their performance. Your lower motivation may be to make them feel bad, or make yourself feel better.

We all have these different motivations. The main question is which ones are driving you more and why?

And more importantly: Which ones do you want to drive you more and why? What kind of a person do you want to be?

The point is not to get rid of the lower motivations (that’s impossible), it’s to manage them (instead of letting them manage you).

Remember Kegan’s subject/object? It’s about taking these low motivations and making them object. Things you can explore, analyze and and manage.

The point is to get to know them. To be curious about them.

This is also where we begin to practice openness. That means (among other things) being open to see yourself as you really are.

2. Building a self-authored system — honoring internal commitments

The previous step focused on building an a self-authored system (identifying what you think, believe and want, and why).

Now it’s time to live according to this system — to lets this internal foundation guide your actions. This is done by honoring your internal commitments.

How do we honor internal commitments?

By making decisions that are aligned with our wants and values (which you clarified above).

Every decision we make is an opportunity to get us closer to what we want. To bring us closer to expressing our authentic selves.

However, most of us experience a dissonance — a gap between what we say we value and how we actually behave. This is most obvious in dating. People say they want a serious committed relationship, but will date people who are unavailable.

This is because it’s not easy to align our actions with our values. It takes a lot of damn work. It’s easier to follow the path of least resistance. But this path usually keep you where you are, or heading in the ‘wrong’ direction.

The path to what you want is paved with small decisions.

But the best way to get better at knowing what we want is, like everything, to practice.

For example, this really hit home for me when I first read Brene Brown’s work.

I’ve always said that I value and want open and honest relationships. But I never invested a lot of time and effort into my relationships. The result is that I was stuck — there was a dissonance between what I say I want and how I actually behave. And, as we all know, experiencing dissonance can be soul sucking.

And then I read Brene Brown’s books and realized that in order to have deep relationships I need to give of myself (i.e. share more, invest time in, etc.).

In short, I need to align my want (for deeper relationships) with my actions (practicing vulnerability).

It sounds trivial, but it wasn’t for me. It was hard and it took work. It meant that I needed to start opening up, sharing my feelings and being honest about what’s going on with me (something that doesn’t come naturally to me). It would have been much easier to talk about the weather.

So that’s what I started doing — I began practicing vulnerability with the people closest to me. And this has profoundly changed my life, from deepening my relationships to laying the foundation for my relationship with my now-husband.

Think about the last time you made a decision about the person you want to be, and followed through with concrete actions. Feels good doesn’t it?

The reason is because when we honor our internal commitments, we gain confidence. The more you do it, the more confident you become.

Pay attention to the decisions you make every day, how many of them are reactions to external circumstances? How many of them are made with a deliberate intention to align your behaviors with your values?

The same is true for Kegan’s theory. If you want to reach higher stages of development then you need to make an internal commitment to change your behavior.

Now what?

I encourage you to be curious about what you think and believe and why. And start paying attention to the small decisions you make every day.

The goal is — as always — to raise awareness and live more intentionally.

In Part 3 I’ll focus on Moving Beyond Self-Authorship to Self Transformation.

Want more?

I started a monthly(ish) newsletter where I share more thoughts/ideas plus meaningful bits and pieces from the web. If you’re interested in receiving it, you can subscribe here.

Thanks so much for reading!