“It’s Time to consider crypto, says pension and endowment adviser”
On February 18, Bloomberg reported that Cambridge Associates, a leading pension and endowment consultant advising on almost $400 billion, has begun to recommend that their clients consider the digital asset space for long-term investment. Cambridge published a research report surveying the different ways of digital investing, from venture capital funds to direct token purchases. In the report, Cambridge analysts noted:
“Despite the challenges, we believe that it is worthwhile for investors to begin exploring this area today with an eye toward the long term.”
You can access Cambridge’s entire report here “Cryptoassets: Venture into the Unknown”.
WHY IS THIS CRYPTO WINTER DIFFERENT? :: “UNCONFIRMED” PODCAST
Forbes’ journalist Laura Shin invited Dan to appear on a recent episode of “Unconfirmed”. The podcast reveals how the guests are reacting to the week’s top headlines and what they see on the horizon.
Thoughts on investing during the bear market and how this differs from the 2014–15 crypto winter.
- Investing During the Crypto Winter
- Differences between Crypto Winter Today vs. 2014–15
- Why are Institutional Investors Slow to Join
- Impact on Blockchain Startups as more and more Legacy Companies Enter Space
- Trends in blockchain innovations and projects
- Regional Trends
- Timeline for solutions to take effect
Below are excerpts from the episode transcript.
What is Pantera’s approach to investing in this space?
“We invest across the entire spectrum. We invest in pre-auction ICOs, liquid blockchains, and venture. That has changed dramatically over the last couple of years. There’s a perception that ICOs were invented in May 2017 at Token Summit or Consensus and they kind of did their thing and they’re over. The reality is that ICOs were invented in 2013, and Ethereum did it in 2014, and Augur in 2015. There were some very important projects, but they were very rare. That’s what we’ve gone back to. There’s still some very important ICO projects, but they’re rare. We only invest in one every few months. At the peak of the mania, we were getting 50 whitepapers a week.
Now the pendulum swung back to venture. In 2018, they did $19 billion of ICOs and only $4 billion of venture. I think 2019 is going to be the opposite: venture is going to be much bigger than ICOs.”
Has the crypto winter changed Pantera’s approach to investing?
“This is actually our second crypto winter. We were around in 2014–15 crypto winter. We are always trying to think ahead 5 or 10 years in our investing, looking at the positions that would do well over a long period of time, and trying not to get too wrapped up in these cycles of the price action. If you think about it, blockchains themselves are like early-stage venture but with a real-time price feed. That unique feature adds a huge distraction to the markets.”
Is this crypto winter different from the one in 2014–15?
“I would admit that in the previous crypto winter, I had more of a worry in the pit of my stomach. Was blockchain really going to work? Would it succumb to some of the real obvious regulatory risks that existed at that time?
Today, the underlying fundamentals are much, much stronger than they were in the 2014–15 crypto winter.”
Are you seeing increased confidence from institutions that blockchain will be a part of the future?
“I think so. If you look at the number of multinational corporations that now have either direct investments in blockchain companies or are doing blockchain projects themselves, it’s just night and day compared to a year or two ago when almost no big brand was involved.”
How are the “underlying fundamentals” stronger today than in 2014–15?
“People have been talking for years about the impending institutional wave of money coming into the markets and I think we now actually have the required conditions for that to happen. Institutional investors really want to have a custodian that’s well-known and regulated. We really haven’t had that in the past. Even though there are some great exchanges out there and some great custodians like Xapo, we really haven’t had a kind of global name that it would take to get institutional investors in. But now you have firms like ICE’s Bakkt, Fidelity, and ErisX launching institutional-grade custody over the next few months. That’ll help bring institutions in.”
“The one thing that is true is that institutions are just like the rest of us — they’re probably pretty pro-cyclical and so the big wave of institutional money probably won’t start in earnest until the prices themselves start going up.”
“We’ve seen that in the two full cycles that Pantera has been managing crypto funds: massive amount of interest when prices are screaming up and, then, when they’ve crashed down — which is actually probably a great time to buy — the interest goes back to neutral.”
Are you saying we will see more institutional investors when the prices go up? Isn’t it better to get in when prices are low?
“Yes. ‘Buy low, sell high’ would be a very effective strategy, but for some reason crypto markets are even more extreme than the normal markets. The inflows into Pantera Bitcoin Fund have been massively pro-cyclical. We launched the Fund when Bitcoin was at $65 and very few investors came in until the price got to $400 or $500. And then when it hit $1000 in 2013, we had massive inflows. When the market did its crypto winter, inflows dried up.
We saw the same thing in the last cycle; very few investors invested when the price was below $1000. Even though, since 2016 onward, it’s spent over half the time below $1,000, very few people invested. When it got to $2,000, $3,000, $4,000 — it started picking up, and then at $10,000 or $15,000, we saw massive interest in investing in bitcoin. It’s the same now: with the markets down 75%, you would think this is a great time to invest, but most people are kind of just sitting on the sidelines. Not adding, not redeeming — just kind of waiting.”
Is this a ‘retail-led phenomenon’ in which institutions won’t get in until they see a retail uptake?
“I think so and we actually had a few investors that were very brave in the last crypto winter. I remember one put $5 million in and took $200 million dollars out at the highs in 2017. So, some people do it, but it’s pretty rare. And I think institutions are probably more conservative than even the high net worth individuals that are our typical LPs.”
Do you think more brand name custody players entering the space will give some of these institutions confidence to invest in a bigger way?
“I do. I think that’s been the gating factor: that large institutions want a more institutional custodian like Bakkt or Fidelity. And once those come in, people will start buying and that’ll start the price moving up. But the massive amount of investment probably won’t occur until the prices have already really gotten going.”
What might happen to startups like Xapo that offer crypto custody when, for example, a brand name like Fidelity launches its custody service for bitcoin in March?
There’s always a race between you know innovators building something and the legacy companies deciding when to engage a market. I think ultimately many of our portfolio companies will get acquired by these legacy financial firms that have yet to establish themselves in this space. Custody is one example where the existing custodians like BitGo and Xapo have a massive market share in the crypto space, and you could imagine a legacy custodian wanting to acquire a company like one of those.
What trends are you seeing in terms of the development in the space? Where do you see the technology or the industry heading in the next year or so?
“So, we’re investing in a lot of projects particularly around scalability — that’s the current issue for the blockchain space. Two of the main blockchains process only seven transactions per second. We’ve invested in four or five projects in scalability. We’re also interested in fiat on-ramps and onboarding to crypto because it’s still kind of clunky. We’re investing in companies that help people get money in and out of the crypto space.”
Are there any examples of blockchain that are already being used?
“One application that is working quite well is cross-border money movement. We recently announced that we sold Coins.ph in the Philippines. Coins.ph is a great example of Bitcoin’s actual usage now. One out of every ten adults in the Philippines is a customer of Coins.ph. That’s very real.”
Are most of the innovations in the space happening in the U.S.?
“The question about whether innovation is going to happen in the U.S. or outside the U.S., is fascinating. Obviously, blockchain is borderless, so we’re looking everywhere around the world to find investments. We’ve traveled to 30 different countries and invested a huge amount of time looking for projects in every corner of the world. We recently looked at the statistics on our portfolio. Even though we’ve really put an amazing effort into finding them, and we have invested in Africa, Latin America, Middle East, North Asia, South Asia, everywhere…ultimately two-thirds of the projects are based in the United States.”
“Many of those entrepreneurs are non-Americans who come to the U.S. because of the density of startup infrastructure.”
“The wild stat is that of the companies that are in the U.S., two-thirds of them are in Silicon Valley — at an average of less than three miles from our offices.”
“It’s concentrated in the United States and then, within the United States, it’s very concentrated in Silicon Valley.”
How long will it take for scalability and fiat on-ramp solutions to really make a difference?
“I think it’s on the order of a couple of years. There are a dozen different approaches being taken. We’re invested in really six or eight of them. Obviously not all of them are going to work but I’m very confident at least a few of them will work and each one offers an order of magnitude or two of scalability, and it’s multiplicative if several of them work.”
“Over the next couple of years, you’re going to see blockchains being able to scale at least 100x.”
“My perspective would be that these problems don’t need to be fully sorted for the usage and prices to go up. When people complain about the lack of throughput on say Bitcoin or Ethereum today, it’s like people complaining in the early 90s that TCP/IP sucked because you couldn’t stream Netflix to your iPhone in Bali yet. These protocols will scale. Even if it takes years for it to happen, you shouldn’t discount that eventuality out of the price today.”
You can hear our appearances on “Unconfirmed” by downloading the podcasts:
- “Why This Crypto Winter is Different” Ep 58 with Dan Morehead (January 2019)
- “How to Create a Regular Cryptocurrency” Ep 22 with Joey Krug (June 2018)
BITCOIN YEARLY LOWS
As investors, we tend to get caught up in the all-time highs. Equally important are the yearly lows. Looking back at the low-print of the market for each year, Bitcoin has shown consistent positive growth — there’s only one year with a lower low than the previous years.
BITCOIN PRICE CYCLES :: 2013 VS 2017
Bitcoin’s price action over the past two years is not a unique occurrence. Bitcoin has experienced seven bull and bear cycles. Previous bear markets have averaged 136 days in length with a maximum of 406 days. Below is a chart depicting Bitcoin’s price cycles starting in December of 2010.
When applying the longest cycle’s duration to the current bear market, the bottom would be marked on January 26th of this year. Only time will tell, but January 31st is currently the low of this cycle. We graphed the 2013 cycle over the current one for a visual comparison. The past does not predict the future, but it seems this bear market has gone on plenty long. The dotted gold line is if the price resumes its life-to-date CAGR (compound annual growth rate).
Delphi Digital released an analysis on Bitcoin UTXOs (unspent transaction outputs) and their relationship to price. Similar to the end of 2014 which marked the bottom of the previous crypto winter, we are starting to see an accumulation process by longer term holders (UTXOs > 1 year at 50%+). Delphi Digital forecasts a price bottom sometime in Q1 2019.
We have been surprised to see how far prices have deviated from the underlying fundamentals — which are stronger now than ever. We expect the gap to be bridged as scalability solutions and onboarding processes continue to develop.
SILICON VALLEY PROXIMITY
Blockchain is borderless. We’ve traveled to 30 countries. We’ve made 90-some trips. We’ve visited countries like Switzerland, Hong Kong, Slovenia 8–10 times.
Even with that strong emphasis on global investing, two-thirds of our 91 portfolio companies and protocols are based in the United States. Of those based in the United States, two-thirds are headquartered an average of less than three miles from our offices.
JOEY KRUG’S “A CRYPTO THESIS”
In early January, we published Joey Krug’s “A Crypto Thesis”, an 8,000-word essay on the state of blockchain and crypto — and where it’s headed. Over 20,000 people read the essay in the first week. As one veteran institutional investment advisor put it, “A Crypto Thesis” is a:
“Fascinating perspective, as well as a model of lucid prose on this complex subject”
Here are the three excerpts most highlight/talked about online, with links to the full paper:
“Just as the internet effectively created a parallel information infrastructure, crypto will build a parallel financial infrastructure. And, no, it’s not going to happen with private blockchains any more than the internet revolution occurred with intranets.”
Read entire section entitled What Does It All Even Accomplish?
“Crypto is rare in that it combines computer science and economics quite intimately, and if you don’t get both right (i.e., incentive compatible), then your system will not work, or, worse yet, could catastrophically fail due to an attack.”
Read entire section entitled Barriers to Adoption
“Right now, pricing of these assets is effectively a beauty contest based primarily on branding. But predicting the whims of the crowd is notoriously difficult. Consequently, it makes more sense to buy things with strong fundamentals such that, as the scalability and on-ramp barriers are lifted, they become so good that the market can no longer ignore them.”
Read entire section entitled Summary
You can read “A Crypto Thesis” in its entirety here.
MIT, Stanford, U.C. Berkeley Academics Form “Distributed Technology Research” (DTR)
Academics from MIT, Stanford, and U.C. Berkeley have joined to form DTR (Distributed Technology Research) — a Pantera-backed non-profit focused on developing decentralized exchanges that can process thousands of transactions per second. On January 17, DTR announced its first initiative, virtual currency Unit-e. Joey Krug had this to say about Pantera’s investment in DTR:
“We are on the cusp of something where if this doesn’t scale relatively soon, it may be relegated to ideas that were nice but didn’t work in practice: more like 3D printing than the internet.’’
More on this recent Pantera ICO Fund investment on Bloomberg.
VFII PORTFOLIO ANNOUNCEMENT :: COINS.PH ACQUIRED FOR $95 MILLION
On January 18, Pantera Venture Fund II portfolio company Coins.ph announced that it was acquired by Go-Jek, Southeast Asia’s leading ride-hailing and payments company for $95 million in one of the largest tech acquisitions in Philippine history.
Pantera was one of the largest investors in the seed round in 2014 and also participated in their Series A round. Founded in 2014, Coins.ph is the market-leading mobile wallet in the Philippines. The product provides a low-cost blockchain-based remittance solution, peer-to-peer money transfer into the Philippines ($26 billion market, 3rd largest in the world), and a variety of other financial services to five million users. When people say there’s no killer use case, I like to point out that Coins.ph already has one out of every ten adults in the country. Coins.ph was the first company in Southeast Asia to be regulated as a Virtual Currency Exchange and e-wallet and was also the first virtual currency provider in the Philippines to be licensed by the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) with a Virtual Currency Exchange license.
CEO Ron Hose was a founding partner at Innovation Endeavors, an early stage venture fund backed by Eric Schmidt. He was also the co-founder of TokBox, a video conferencing company backed by Sequoia Capital, Bain Capital, and Stanford University and later acquired by Telefonica.
For further details on the acquisition of Coins.ph, please read the coverage in TechCrunch.
VFIII INVESTMENT :: $4.5 MILLION PANTERA-LED SEED ROUND IN STAKED
Energy-intensive mining isn’t sustainable if blockchains do become the payment rail of the world. According to Professor Ed Felten of Princeton, Bitcoin consumes 0.2% of world electricity production. Bitcoin energy consumption is a function of price. If the price of bitcoin goes up 10x, miners will rationally consume 10x as much electricity. 2% of world production is conceivable. However, another 10x from there is riots in the streets type stuff.
We believe that blockchains will move away from energy-intensive mining and that many will use proof-of-stake. Proof of stake is like the securities markets — one share, one vote. Staking your tokens is cumbersome so there will emerge companies that provide staking as a service — in the same way proxy companies vote your shares. Staked is the current leader in this nascent space.
I’ve known the CTO for fifteen years since his first company — PlanetTran — a car service using Prius and at the time cutting edge booking/routing technology — like a primordial Uber.
Pantera led the recently announced $4.5 million seed round in Staked — a platform for staking and earning returns on tokens that are based on Proof of Stake consensus algorithms. Staked provides institutional holders of digital currencies with secure infrastructure enabling them to compound their crypto holdings through staking and lending. Staked supports staking and lending across six proof-of-stake currencies, which have gained in popularity because they use dramatically less electricity than Bitcoin’s Proof of work security model. According to Staked’s Founder and CEO Tim Ogilvie:
“We help institutional investors in digital currencies earn their staking rewards.”
Investors in proof-of-stake currencies are paid block rewards by “staking” their assets and running the server software that secures the blockchain. This participation yields 5–100% annually in additional currency but requires secure and highly available servers. Staked provides secure infrastructure for staking and currently supports six cryptocurrencies including Tezos, Dash, Decred, Livepeer, Factom, and EOS. Customers include top-tier crypto funds, venture capital funds, family offices, and hedge funds. Staked also offers a white-labeled staking platform that enables exchanges, custodians, and wallets to offer staking rewards to their customers without an expensive and complex technology build out. Staked will add support for other passive opportunities such as lending in Q1 2019 and expects to support staking across 20 crypto assets by the end of this year.
“Investors have a growing number options to compound their crypto assets, and Staked makes it easy to understand and execute on all of the available opportunities.”
Pantera initiated discussions with Staked as a potential customer before deciding to invest in the company. Pantera’s Paul Veradittakit, who will be joining Staked’s board of directors, had this to say about the investment:
“Pantera invests in many leading proof-of-stake projects, so we knew we needed a staking solution. We liked Staked because of the experienced team, focus on institutions, and broader vision around generating passive yield for investors.”
Staked was founded in April 2018 by three founders with long histories building and running successful internet businesses. CEO Tim Ogilvie previously founded the Y-Combinator-backed startup, Think Gaming, a SaaS data platform focused on mobile games, and prior to that Tim was the CEO and founder of AdBuyer.com, an early demand side platform (sold to Mediaocean). CTO Seth Riney, architected and implemented large-scale big data pipelines and developed systems on AWS at Paytronix. After graduating from Yale University with a B.S. in Astronomy and Physics, Seth spent considerable time consulting on cloud security and compliance in the Financial Services/Securities industry. COO Jonathan Marcus was the founder and CEO of Goodsie and Flavors.me (sold to Moo). Before founding Goodsie, Jonathan grew a small team of two to sixteen in his role as the VP/General Manager at Vimeo. Jonathan also co-founded Pronto (sold to IAC/InterActiveCorp), and held a variety of incubation roles at IAC/InterActivecorp.
Read more about the Pantera-led Seed Round in Staked at The Block.
PANTERA PORTFOLIO UPDATES
VFII :: Abra Brings Global Access To US Stocks (By Paul Veradittakit)
On February 6, VFII portfolio company, Abra, announced a new way for users to gain investment exposure to US stocks and ETFs using its bitcoin- and smart-contract-powered platform. Here’s a quick run-down of how it works and why it may soon outcompete other popular online trading platforms.
Essentially, Abra has taken its existing platform and extended it to support assets available on the NASDAQ, starting with the top 100 stocks and ETF’s.
Once users invest capital into the platform, they can choose to “invest” in one of Abra’s 100 stock/ETF offerings, which represents stock investment exposure in corporations like Facebook, Apple, Amazon, and Alphabet/Google. As soon as a user adds money to the Abra app, the capital is immediately transformed to bitcoin. Then, using Abra’s crypto-collateralized contract, Abra keeps the notional value of that bitcoin investment tied to the current value of the stock. This is done with what’s called a multisig bitcoin address, where Abra and the user sign a contract to peg the amount of cryptocurrency to the value of the asset. Abra users then hold an asset that tracks the exact price and volatility of the given stock.
While users don’t actually hold any shares in the company they still receive dividend payments because of the means by which Abra hedges itself on the contracts — super cool. The platform can also support short selling which Abra hopes to offer in the future.
Anyone interested can read the coverage of this announcement in Forbes.
RECENT SPEAKING EXCERPTS
Money20/20 :: Wall Street 2.0 — Will Blockchain Revolutionize Finance?
Dan participated in Money20/20 in Las Vegas on whether blockchain technology will revolutionize finance in the years to come. These are some highlights from the panel:
Q. Can you spend a couple minutes on domestic and cross-border payments?
Blockchain is very good at some things and probably not good at others. There are some things that aren’t broken like DTCC which transacts 115 million trades a day — 6,300 per second. The thing that is broken is cross-border money movement. It’s very expensive. In most countries, even very primitive countries, you can do a domestic transaction pretty much free and pretty much real-time. As soon as you cross the border, it slows way down and gets really expensive.
With blockchain, you can send the money essentially instantaneously, and with most blockchains essentially free to anyone, anywhere on earth. That’s really going to be powerful both for huge financial use cases, but I think it’s going to have its biggest impact in the developing world where you have so many migrants working in foreign countries.
Q. What is one widely held belief or opinion in the blockchain crypto space that you disagree with or you think is wrong?
For me, the biggest misconception is that equity and tokens are similar financing vehicles, and a company could do one or the other. In my opinion, they’re really antithetical. A project should be either cooperatively owned with a very useful token or it should be a venture-backed company that’s trying to extract money out of its customer base somehow. Those are really, really opposite.
The entire Money20/20 panel can be viewed here.
VENTURE FUNDS :: REALIZED VALUE
Pantera Venture Fund I has returned 4.5x back to investors in five years, with 3.6x of unrealized value remaining — creating 8.1x of total value on committed capital.
As we now have a new investment option for LPs wishing to recycling their proceeds, Venture Fund II is begging to return capital to LPs. The current value of Venture Fund II is $65mm.
VENTURE FUND III :: FINAL CLOSING
We are pleased to announce that Pantera Venture Fund III will have its final close on March 28th.
The Fund has invested $30 million into nine portfolio companies. Pantera was joined by BCG and Microsoft as a founding investor in Bakkt, the newly formed subsidiary of the parent of the New York Stock Exchange (Intercontinental Exchange — NYSE: ICE). Pantera led the funding rounds in five deals, including Blockfolio and, most recently, Staked. Our investments in StarkWare and Synthetic Minds have also been announced.
As with our previous venture funds, we are offering a Co-Investment Class. Investors who commit $5mm or more will have co-investment rights to at least 10% of every deal.
After closing, 35% of each limited partners’ capital commitment will be called. We anticipate calling the remaining committed capital in installments over the next two to three years.
All new investors in VFIII will get pro rata exposure to the deals the fund has already invested in — at cost plus an 8% interest rate on the capital previously called.
Pro Rata Rights from VFI & VFII
It is likely that Venture Funds I and II will eventually have fully invested their follow-on reserves. At that point, the pro rata rights of the two previous funds will be granted to Venture Fund III. (VFII Co-Investment Class will continue to receive 10% of every deal.)
VFIII Conference Call
The investment team will hold the next (and last) Venture Fund III Conference Call on Tuesday, March 12, 2019 at 9:00am PDT / 17:00 CET. Please register here if you’d like to participate.
General Information Conference Calls
Join us for a conference call to discuss Pantera's fund offerings.
To review fundraising materials, including access to the data room where you will find financial, legal, portfolio company details, and due diligence materials on this fund and our two previous venture funds, please contact email@example.com.
Pantera partners will be traveling over the next months to discuss Venture Fund III and the blockchain disruption. We have organized group lunches in many cities, should you want to meet other investors who share your interest in blockchain. If you are interested in attending one of our group lunches, please fill out the form on this page and we will be in touch regarding availability.
- Boston, February 21–22
- Dallas, February 22 | including a Group Lunch at 12:30pm
- Palo Alto, March 4, Group Lunch | 12pm
- Seattle, March 4
- Minneapolis/Milwaukee, March 5–6
- Los Angeles, March 6
- London, March 11
- San Francisco, March 11, Group Lunch | 12pm
- Boston, March 13
- New York City, March 13–14, March 14 Group Lunch | 12pm
- Denver, March 18
- Salt Lake City, March 19–21
- Boston, March 25–27
- Chicago, April 8 | including a Group Lunch at 12pm
- New York City, April 9–11
- Miami, April 10–11, April 10 Group Lunch | 12pm
- Washington D.C., April 12
- Phoenix, April 29
- Denver, April 30
- Chicago, May 1–2
- Toronto, May 7–8
If you are interested in a meeting, please contact Pantera’s Investor Relations team at +1–650–854–7000 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
The future has arrived,
“Put the alternative back in Alternatives”
VFII :: Chronicled “Raises $16mm To Bring Blockchain To The Pharmaceutical Industry”
On January 15, Pantera Venture Fund II portfolio company, Chronicled, announced a $16 million Series A. Funds from this round will be used to support the pharmaceutical industry network and operational growth. Chronicled Co-Founder and Chairman Ryan Orr had this to say about the Series A:
“We are aware that the pharmaceutical industry has certain problems with regulations that are ripe for this technology platform. With the Series A funding, we are focusing on the pharmaceutical go-to-market. After a year or two, there could the possibility of applying this technology to other industries, but for the next 12–18 months we are focusing the company specifically on the pharmaceutical industry.”
Pantera initially invested in Chronicled in 2015 as part of the company’s Seed round. Founded in 2014, Chronicled is using blockchain technology to build enterprise tools for supply chain management.
For further details, please read coverage of the announcement in Forbes.
VFII :: Coinsuper Closes Pre-Series B
On January 8, Pantera Venture Fund II portfolio company, Coinsuper, closed its pre-Series B. Pantera invested in the Hong Kong-based crypto exchange in June 2018 as part of its Series A. Founded in October 2017, Coinsuper is one of the top crypto exchanges in the region; providing trading services for institutional investors, commercial institutions, and professional individual investors in many well-known cryptocurrencies.
In December, Coinsuper announced plans to add the Hong Kong Dollar (HKD) deposits on its exchange. Accepting transactions using fiat currencies, like HKD, means more people will have the opportunity to trade cryptocurrencies. For further details on Coinsuper’s plans to add HKD deposits, read Reuters.
VFIII Investment Update :: Bakkt’s First Acquisition
Venture Fund III portfolio company, Bakkt, recently announced their acquisition of certain assets of the Rosenthal Collins Group (RCG). RCG is an independent futures commission merchant with nearly 100 years of developing clients’ trust. The acquisition is aimed at enhancing Bakkt’s risk management and treasury operations with systems and expertise. In addition, the transaction will contribute to their regulatory, AML/KYC, and customer service operations.
Bakkt continues to build its operational infrastructure while the team awaits approval by the CFTC for the launch of their Bitcoin futures market. Despite the delays, due in part to the government shutdown, Bakkt is utilizing this time to ensure robust and efficient systems are in place as they look to launch the most trusted ecosystem for digital assets.
For further details, please read Bakkt’s announcement in Medium.
VFII :: ErisX Hires Execs From YouTube, Pico, and Barclays
Pantera VFII portfolio company, ErisX, recently hired former Barclays Executive, Robert Thrash, as Chief Operating Officer. Thrash is a derivatives executive with extensive experience across prime brokerage, execution services, and trading. Before joining ErisX, Thrash was at Barclays Investment Bank for 12 years, most recently as Managing Director and Global Head of Futures Execution Services and Clearing Platform Management. Thrash had this to say about his new role:
“Top performers from financial services and technology domains, alike, are attracted to the opportunity to build an exchange and clearing house from the ground up for a whole new asset class. Bringing on Robert means we have rounded out the executive team. This is someone who ran a global derivatives business and we couldn’t ask for someone better.”
Led by former Citigroup executive Thomas Chippas, ErisX is looking to attract traditional investors and traders to its market, which it says will be regulated by the CFTC. ErisX believes hiring a team of talented leadership will ensure the firm continues to attract top talent as they prepare to launch the platform.
“ErisX has assembled an impressive team of experts to build the most robust, secure and regulated digital asset platform. Leveraging intermediary relationships and their diverse group of investors, ErisX will help both institutional and individual participants access these markets.”
John Denza, former Head of U.S. sales at Pico Quantitative Trading, will be joining ErisX as its business development executive. And Arnold Connell, formerly at Google and a leading executive behind the launch of YouTubeTV, will be Head of Infrastructure.
ErisX is currently working with the CFTC for approval of its application to operate a futures exchange. While the recent government shutdown in the U.S. impacted the roll-out of a number of financial-products, Chippas said the Q2 deadline for the launch of its spot market is still on track, saying, “I am very pleased at the speed we are moving at”.
Anyone interested can read more about this announcement in Business Wire.
PORTFOLIO COMPANIES AND PROTOCOL TOKENS
If you would like to receive additional information on Pantera’s funds, including the Private Placement Memorandum, Limited Partnership Agreement, or Subscription Documents, please fill out the form on this page to begin the subscription process.
CONFERENCE CALLS :: ICO, DIGITAL ASSET, AND VENTURE FUNDS
ICO and Digital Asset Funds Conference Call
Tuesday, February 26, 2019 9:00am PST / 18:00 CET / 1:00am CST (Feb. 27th)
Please register (in advance) via this link:
Meeting ID: 832–269–763
Venture Fund III Conference Call
Tuesday, March 12, 2019 9:00am PDT / 17:00 CET / 12:00am CST (Mar. 13th)
Please register (in advance) via this link:
Meeting ID: 858–032–933
ICO and Digital Asset Funds Conference Call
Tuesday, April 2, 2019 9:00am PDT / 18:00 CEST / 12:00am CST (Apr. 3rd)
Please register (in advance) via this link:
Meeting ID: 557–030–322
PAST ICO, DIGITAL ASSET, AND VENTURE FUND CONFERENCE CALL RECORDINGS
Recordings of recent ICO, Digital Asset, and Venture Fund III conference calls are available on this page.
- Dan Morehead on CNBC, ‘Crypto Trader Show’ :: Live In Los Angeles
- CNBC, ‘Crypto Hedge Fund Pantera On Track to Raise $175 Million’
- Dan Morehead on CNBC, Fast Money
- Joey Krug on the June 8 Episode of the “Unconfirmed: Insight and Analysis from the Top Minds in Crypto” podcast, episode entitled “How to Create Regular Cryptocurrency”
- Dan Morehead on CNBC, Fast Money
- Dan Morehead on Fox Business, Mornings with Maria
- Dan Morehead on Bloomberg Panel, Bitcoin: The Past, Present and Future
- Dan Morehead on Bloomberg, Pantera’s Morehead Says Bitcoin ‘Is a Screaming Buy’
- Dan Morehead on CNBC, Hedge Fund CEO Says Bitcoin’s Flashing a Rare Buy Signal
- Dan Morehead on CNBC, Early Innings for Cryptocurrency Craze: Pantera Capital CEO
- Dan Morehead on CNN, Bitcoin: Digital gold or Ponzi scheme?
- Dan Morehead on Fox Business, Morning with Maria
- New York Times, A Bitcoin Hedge Fund’s Return: 25,004% (That Wasn’t a Typo)
- Dan Morehead on Fox Business, Mornings with Maria
- Dan Morehead speaks at Money2020 Conference with Kik’s Ted Livingston
- Dan Morehead speaks at Sohn Conference CNBC
- TechCrunch, While Investment Firms Ponder ICOs, This Team is Barreling Ahead With a $100 Million ICO Fund
- TechCrunch, ICOs, How Do They Work? | Disrupt SF 2017
Pantera is actively hiring for the following roles:
- Venture Associates
- Executive Assistant
- Data Scientists
If you have a passion for blockchain and want to work in Menlo Park, San Francisco, or New York, please follow this link to apply.
Some good material to start with on the development of blockchain technology and cryptocurrencies as speculative instruments:
- Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System — white paper by Satoshi Nakamoto
- 12 Graphs that Show Just How Early the Cryptocurrency Market Is by Chris McCann
- Blockchain Investments and the New Problem Asset for Conventional VCs by Jake Brukhman
- Cryptoeconomics 101 by Nick Tomaino, and his Tokens, Tokens and More Tokens
- Fat Protocols by Joel Monegro
- What Does $300 Ether Mean? by Vinay Gupta
- Token Economy by Stefano Bernardi and Yannick Roux
- Traditional Asset Tokenization
- The Rise of the Token Sale by Max Mersch
- Making Sense of Cryptoeconomics by Max Mersch
- Why Amazon’s Margin Is Filecoin’s Opportunity Forbes, Aug 28, 2017
- Joey Krug RealVision Interview Excerpts: ICOs, Future of Digital Currency, Ethereum Flash Crash RealVision, Aug 10, 2017
- Pantera Capital to Raise $100 Million in Investment for ICO Hedge Fund Coindesk, Jun 28, 2017
- While Investment Firms Ponder ICOs, This Team is Barreling Ahead with a $100 million ICO Fund TechCrunch, Jun 28, 2017
- Balaji CNBC Interview CNBC
- US Fed Hints at Blockchain Integration Coindesk
- Coindesk State of Blockchain Q2 Report Coindesk
- The Isle of Man Welcomes ICOs Coindesk
- Ethereum Metropolis Release Testnet To Launch Coindesk
- Closure Steps for Chinese Exchanges Coindesk
- China Shmyna, Bitcoin Trading is Way More Distributed Now Anyway Coindesk
- Lawmakers Seek Tax Exemption on BTC Transactions Under $600 Coindesk
- ICO “Rounds” Are Coming TechCrunch
- Crypto Regulation? Not Anytime Soon, Says White House Official Coindesk
- Why Decentralization Matters by Chris Dixon. Outstanding perspective on how we went the open Internet 1.0 to a closed Internet 2.0 — and the promises of a new Internet ecosystem powered by Blockchain.
- Beyond the Bitcoin Bubble The longest read on this list from NY Times Magazine. A great ten-thousand foot view. A must-read.
- Fat Protocols Written over two years ago, an image in this article is one of the most frequently referenced in the industry
- A Letter to Jamie Dimon Famous retort to Mr. Dimon’s flippant remark about bitcoin being a fraud. Concise, even-tempered, a brilliant article.
- Interview with David Sacks Former Pay Pal COO Sacks lists ten use-cases where he anticipates blockchain can disruptive in the not-too-distant future.
- Mapping the Blockchain Project Ecosystem Attempt to categorize the protocol tokens based on use –helpful for newbies.
- Two of the best books are Digital Gold by Nathaniel Popper for a fun high-level history and an in-depth technically-minded look Mastering Bitcoin and Mastering Ethereum by Andreas Antonopoulos.
- And some additional information on the ICO model specifically:
- Recommended Primer: Token Mania
- Kin Whitepaper
- Kin Webpage
- AVC Venture Capital on Kin
- Tech Crunch Article on Kin
- Reuters Article on Kin
- Video on Kin by AVC
- USV on Protocol Value
- Tokenomics — A Business Guide to Token Usage, Utility, and Value by William Mougayar
- Earn’s CEO on Token Economies
- Basic Attention Token Whitepaper
- Basic Attention Token Webpage
- Nick Szabo and Naval Ravikant on Tokens
Additional information on blockchain regulation:
- SEC’s Office of Investor Education and Advocacy Investor Bulletin on ICOs
- SEC Issued Statement on ICOs and the DAO
- China Banned ICOs
- FINMA Issues Stricter ICO / AML Regulatory Compliance Requirements
- SEC Puts Task-Force on ICOs
- SEC Shuts Down Protostarr
- South Korea Bans ICOs
A monthly letter with our thoughts on significant market and ecosystem-related developments. Also, includes our thoughts on blockchain venture capital and news on our portfolio companies for accredited investors.
Periodic, original blockchain research and academic papers.
“A Crypto Thesis” by Pantera Co-CIO Joey Krug [2019.01.08]. Joey’s insights on crypto and blockchain innovations what is still needed for user and institutional adoption. Informative and detailed primer for anyone considering investing in the space.