9 Steps to a Valuable Digital Marketing Competitive Analysis

You have to know exactly what what you’re up against if you want to get the edge on your competition. That’s why completing an online competitive analysis should be a top marketing priority. As a marketer, it’s not enough to have in-depth knowledge of your competitor’s products or services, you also need to know exactly how they are marketing these and what tactic’s they are employing.

You need to be able to get your product or service in front of the right people quicker and more effectively than your competitor’s. A well researched and carefully planned marketing strategy and plan is required in order to achieve this and your marketing strategy should be underpinned by a detailed competitive analysis.

Whether you are putting a marketing strategy together for the first time or reviewing an existing one, by starting with a competitive analysis it will help you to :

  • Benchmark your marketing efforts against your competitors
  • Identify opportunities to market your product or service better and faster than your competitors
  • Identify gaps in content required to support both the marketing and the sales teams
  • Differentiate yourself from competitors
  • Compare all of the tactics, content, social media activity etc. to see what gets the best results and also what’s not effective
  • Validate your marketing efforts by being able to show metrics relating to strategies that will have the best results.

Here are the most important 9 steps to an effective competitive analysis that will help you plan a much more effective strategy and game plan so that you can get ahead of your competition and grow your business.

1. Make a List of Top Competitors

Start by making a list of your top 5–10 competitors.

If you offer a number of different core products/services for which you may be competing with different companies for each, then make a list of competitors for each product/service.

Use Google to do a search for the product or service you are offering to help you identify competitors.

2. Review Their Content

The value you provide with your content should be a key factor for differentiating yourself from other companies. Knowing what content your competitor’s are publishing provides great insights and will help you work out a strategy to differentiate yourself. It will also help you figure out what their lead generation strategies are.

Take a look at the following

  • Blog: Do they have a blog? If so what type of content are they posting and how often?
  • Offers: Do they have offers like eBooks, Whitepapers, How to Guides, Checklists etc.? If they do why don’t you download them and see what they’re like.
  • Visual Content: Do they have any video content? Are they using infographics, good quality images? What are the topics being covered using these?
  • Podcast: Do they have a Podcast? If so what topics covered?
  • Events & Webinars: Do they run events and webinars — if so how often do they do this? Do they provide written content for these?
  • FAQ’s: Do they have a FAQs section? If so what type of content is on it?
  • News: Do they have a News section for Press Releases V’s Blog content?
  • Testimonials/Reviews: Do they have testimonials? If so what format — written, video etc? What are customers saying?
  • Client Case Studies: Are there case studies? What do these include? Any useful stats or info?
  • Social Integration: Do they have social media follow or share buttons on site pages? Are there opportunities to share content or landing pages?
  • Frequency: How often are they publishing content — Blog, New Offers etc

When going through their content be sure to review how high the quality is. Check if the are targeting specific personas and phases of the buyers journey? How long is the content? Is it structured well? Easy to read and consume? etc

From the results, identify areas where you have gaps and areas you need to improve. If it inspires any ideas for new campaign’s etc write them down! All of this information will help you craft a great content strategy.

3. Review Their Website

Your website should be at the core of your marketing strategy. So review your competitor’s websites by taking a look at the following:-

  • Navigation: Imagine you are a customer at different stages of the buyers journey. Can you find the information you want? Is it easier to find on their site than it is on your own website?
  • User Experience: How is the user experience on their website — is it easy to use? Is it intuitive?
  • Calls to Action: As a visitor, do you know what to do next on a page? Are Calls to Action (CTA’s) on every page? Do they stand out? Do they lead to landing pages? Are there additional CTA’s on ‘Thank You’ pages to take leads further down the funnel if they are ready?
  • Landing Pages: Are their specially designed pages that offer something in return for your information? Are they designed using best practices?
  • Sign-ups: How easy is it to sign up for newsletters or to download an eBook etc.?
  • Special Offers: Do they have special offers? If so what types?
  • Loading: Does the website load quickly?
  • Responsive: Is their website responsive? i.e. does it work well on mobile devices?

4. Look at Their SEO

It’s not just enough to look at their content and what message they are trying to communicate, you need to look at their SEO too to see if their are possibilities or opportunities to outrank them. This sounds complicated but it’s relatively easy to get a good idea of what keyword’s they are targeting.

Look at the main pages (at the very least) and check the following for clues. Keywords they are targeting, if done properly will at least be in the following:-

  • The URL
  • The Page title
  • H1 Tags
  • Image Alt text
  • Actual Content — keyword density, internal linking etc

Figure out what keywords they are targeting and add those to your own keyword list if you want to be found for these words too and get ahead of them on SERP’s.

Look at metrics like their

  • Moz rank
  • Traffic rank
  • Number of indexed pages
  • Backlinks (look at where these are coming from and whether they are authoritative sites)

5. Email Marketing

Believe it or not email marketing is still one of the top marketing tactic’s that you could be employing.

To get real insights into your competitors email marketing subscribe to their blog and download their offers. (You might want to use an alias though!). Then review things like…

  • Email Frequency: How often are they sending emails?
  • Email Times: Are they emailing at specific times?
  • Newsletters: How often are these going out and whats the content like?
  • Content: Are these lead nurturing ones or are they sales pitches? Are they trying to move you through the funnel?
  • Device Optimisation: Are their emails well formatted on mobile and desktop devices?

6. Reviews

Reviews are really important and they can make or break a sale. If you were researching a potential purchase from a company wouldn’t you want to know what people think? It’s easy for business owners to put their best testimonials and reviews on their website because it’s an asset they have full control over.

Look outside of their websites. For example, search for the company name on Google and in most cases to the right you will see Google reviews in their business listing. Businesses can’t control what customers write here. If someone wants to add a bad review about the business the business itself has no control over that. Look at other sites too like Yelp etc.

7. Social Media

You can learn a lot about your competitors from social media. Go through all of the key ones like LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, YouTube etc and check the following:

  • Profile: How is their profile?
  • Fans & Followers: How many fans and followers they have?
  • Posting Frequency: How often they post to that platform?
  • Engagement: How engaged are their fans? Review comments and no of shares etc
  • Effectiveness: How their actual content is doing — retweets, shares etc
  • What are their reasons for posting ? Direct to their blog or specific landing pages?
  • Content Curation: Are they sharing curated content? if so from where?
  • Interaction: How they are interacting with their followers and fans — how are they responding to comments, retweets etc
  • Purpose: What they are using social media for? Is it just marketing or are they using it for things like customer service or support too?

If you have buyer personas in place you should already know what social media platforms your ideal clients are using but this can give additional insight.

If you notice any spikes in dips in social media performance on one channel or all channels be sure to try and figure out what caused them.

8. Paid Advertising

What your competitors are doing on paid advertising can tell you a lot, so see if they are running paid ad campaigns and if so look at things like

  • What content is being promoted?
  • How it is being promoted?
  • Does the content lead to special landing pages?
  • What keywords are they targeting?
  • Who are they targeting?
  • What channels are they using paid advertising on?

Remember, not every company will run paid advertising campaigns. Some businesses rely on blogging regularly with well written, useful, optimised blog posts (for SEO) that are targeting the right audience.

9. Take Action Based on the Results

Now you have all your research information, remember that ‘knowledge is power’. Use it as an input to planning a rock solid digital marketing strategy and putting a plan in place to implement.

Remember though…that you are not your competitor! Some of your competitors may have higher marketing budget’s available to them and as such may be able to allocate more resources to their digital marketing efforts. Be realistic. Put a solid process and plan in place that has SMART goals and priorities to address quick wins up front. Monitor and measure results regularly and tweak based on insights.

Our next post this week will cover some of the best free and paid tools to use when conducting a digital competitive analysis so be sure to keep an eye out for it!

In the meantime, if you need any advice on completing a competitive analysis please feel free to contact me at sinead@webjourney.ie or book a Free Inbound Marketing Assessment by clicking here where we can help you assess your current marketing efforts, gaps and make recommendations for improvements.

Topics: Digital Marketing, Competitive Analysis


Originally published at blog.webjourney.ie.