Get the ice cream scoop. Then if you have $20 more in your budget, make them a little ice cream sundae kit — two disgustingly cute coordinating bowls in a theme they like (sportsball team? NASCAR? Disney?) a couple fancy syrups and sprinkles and a little can of chopped nuts. It’s adorable, thoughtful, memorable, AND gets them something they actually asked for while not requiring a ton of permanent storage space. Or a rootbeer float kit. Or booze. Or all of the above?