Why Hawaii doesn’t get James Beard Awards

Yesterday, the James Beard Foundation released the list of semifinalists for its annual Restaurant and Chef awards that will be held in Chicago on May 1.

Two Hawaii restaurants, Vino for “Best Wine Program”, and Senia for “Best New Restaurant”, made it on to the list this year. However, based on history, the odds are not in either of their favor.

Hawaii chefs rarely make it onto the finalist list, and the last Hawaii based chef to bring home one of the coveted awards was in 2003.

Why has Hawaii had such a long drought (going on 14 years) without a chef or restaurant making it to the finals? I sought out Hawaii’s three James Beard Award (JBA) winning chefs, Roy Yamaguchi, Alan Wong, and George Mavrothalassitis (Mavro) to find out.

All agree that the main obstacle for Hawaii chefs is geography.

“The further away you get from the major cities, the more difficult it is to get the attention of writers,” says Yamaguchi, who became the first Hawaii chef to win a JBA in 1993. “Someone has to be doing something really fantastic to get noticed outside of the major food hubs of New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Chicago. Unfortunately, it comes down to out of sight, out of mind.”

The writers he refers to are from food publications like Wine Spectator, Food & Wine, Bon Appétite, and Restaurant News to name a few.

The voting body for the JBA is made up of food writers from around the country along with past winners. The year that Yamaguchi won his award, Roy’s Restaurant was named Restaurant of the Year in Restaurant News, and he was featured on the cover of Bon Appétite magazine. Being featured in a major publication can bring the attention of JBA voters.

Chef George Mavrothalassitis after winning his James Beard Award in 2003.

Chef Mavro, who won his JBA in 2003, points out how Hawaii’s geography problem is compounded because it is grouped in the Western region with California. “It isn’t that chefs in California are more talented than those in Hawaii,” says Mavro, “California gets more exposure because the publications have bases there.”

As a result of this lack of exposure, there is a misunderstanding of what constitutes Hawaii cuisine. Chef Wong who won the JBA in 1996 says that there is still a misconception that if you put pineapple on a burger or pizza that makes it Hawaiian, or cooking fish means that it has to have macadamia nuts.

“Slowly people are starting to recognize Hawaii as a food destination,” says Wong, “however, it is no where near the status of New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Chicago.”

Geography also comes into play with the balloting rules given to the voters. According to Mary Blanton Ogushwitz, media relations for the JBA, the ballot states that judges should, “only vote for a chef whose food you have eaten in the past year,” and “only vote for a restaurant you have dined in within the past year.”

This stipulation means that getting a lot of attention from the media is only part of equation. Its not just a popularity contest, voters have to come in and dine. This is easy in Los Angeles and San Francisco, whereas Western region voters would have to take a five-hour flight to dine at Senia, Vino, or any of the other Hawaii restaurants that make it onto the ballot.

Founders of the Hawaii Food & Wine Festival, Chef Alan Wong, Denise Yamaguchi, and Chef Roy Yamaguchi

Wong believes that the Hawaii Food & Wine Festival (HFWF) is one way to overcome Hawaii’s geographic isolation from the rest of the JBA Western region.

“The HFWF will feature over 100 chefs this year, and the media follows,” says Wong, “The festival brings attention to Hawaii, and offers a venue to showcase our chefs and our cuisine.”

Chef Mavro feels that the Hawaii Visitors & Convention Bureau could do more by bringing the right people from major food publications. It comes down to publicizing in a targeted way that translates into JBA votes for Hawaii chefs. Mavro also believes that a targeted approach like this could also lead to the famed Michelin guide finally coming to Hawaii.

Currently, a majority of advertising for Hawaii is as a vacation destination, which is great for the tourism industry as a whole, however, it perpetuates the old ideas of luaus, pineapples, and macadamia nuts. It does not adequately reflect Hawaii’s current food culture.

Admittedly, this is difficult to do especially because of the way food is so ingrained in Hawaii’s culture. “People like food that has a soul,” says Wong. “It must have a story behind it. Those are powerful things. People need to hear the story about Hawaii’s culinary history.”

Wong points to Chef Ed Kenney’s show, “Family Ingredients,” which does a great job of giving Hawaii’s food culture a sense of place.

Each episode, illustrates how Hawaii’s cuisine borrows from different ethnicities — a result of the mixing of cultures during the plantation era.

“Family Ingredients” is aired nation wide on PBS, and has great potential to expose JBA voters to Hawaii’s unique food culture. As such, Kenney and “Family Ingredients” could be recognized by the JBA when the Media, Journalism, and Book nominations are announced with the Chef and Restaurant finalists on March 15.

What can chefs, not just in Hawaii, but anywhere in the United States do to raise their profile and be noticed by the JBA?

The first thing to note is that Yamaguchi, Wong, and Mavro were not actively trying to gain the attention of the JBA.

“At the end of the day, who knows why certain chefs win, but they are all talented deserving chefs,” says Yamaguchi who recalls working the line at his restaurant the night he won the JBA medal.

All three were focused on achieving excellence in their restaurants, putting out good food, and servicing their customers to the best of their abilities. As a result, the JBA chose to recognize them. However, that doesn’t mean that they don’t have advice for the next generation of Beard laureates.

Yamaguchi believes in using failures as learning opportunities. “I don’t base things on what everyone else does. I can only base my life on what I have done. What has worked for me and what hasn’t worked for me. There are those who succeed, yet don’t know how they succeeded. That is dangerous, because when things start to go wrong, they don’t know how to fix it. Failing enables, you to learn what works and what doesn’t work.”

“You are going to gain attention when you take a risk on the plate,” is Wong’s advice. “It doesn’t mean cooking with confusion, or focusing on what the plate looks like. Even though people today seem to eat more with their iPhones, in the end, I’d rather eat something that tastes great, but looks looks a little ugly.”

“Do what you do, and let your craziness be on the plate,” advises Mavro. “There are no categories for luxury. A pizza place has just as much chance of winning a JBA as a fine dining restaurant. It’s all about what’s on the plate.”

The consensus between the three chefs is that Chris Kajioka and Anthony Rush, co-owners of Senia, have the best chance to be the next Hawaii chefs to receive a JBA medal.

Even before it opened, Senia had a write up in the New York Times, and has since been featured in Food & Wine, Eater, and various national and international travel publications.

JBA voting is currently underway, so we will see if Vino or Senia get an invite to the awards ceremony in Chicago.

Regardless of who brings home a JBA medal this year, Yamaguchi sums it up best, “continually work on your craft, and make exciting food. The recognition will take care of itself.”

Hawaii based chef, Ed Morita has been blogging in one form or another since 2005. The Culinary Mind serves as an outlet where he focuses on various food issues.