Dave’s reaction to my blog post.

Dave Ramsey’s Investing Advice Is Both Bad and Wrong.

The Matadore
3 min readOct 25, 2023

--

Math doesn’t lie.

If you have ever listened to Dave Ramsey you likely know he regularly recommends investing money in the stock market across 4 types of mutual funds, in equal 25% allocations.

Here is an example of what I am referencing.

https://www.youtube.com/embed/wxvwt4UshH4?si=Tby1txJAFb5Rlbjy

The 4 types are “Growth, growth and income, aggressive growth, and International”, all with a “10+ year track record”.

Dave usually goes on to encourage time in the market vs. timing the market, which I generally agree with. He also advises avoiding single-stock investing for most people, which is also an idea I can embrace.

There are some glaring issues however with his mutual fund allocation recommendations that I want to examine.

As it is widely reported, over 10 years, only 8.59% of actively managed funds outperformed the S&P 500.

Not only is that a very small amount of funds for the average investor to be hunting down and tracking annually, but his mix is highly subject to above-average volatility, likely holding a lot of the same companies in every fund, and “International Funds” are always a loser.

--

--

The Matadore

Come here for musings on things like money, personal finance, life, relationships. Questions or (non-professional) advice: thematadorefinance@gmail.com