Human vs AI: Who Can Write the Best

Will AI replace writers?

(source)

I was recently inspired to write this article by Manish Dangi👻 from his article:

I Wrote a Full Article with AI — Here is What I Found

As I was reading it, I realized how close AI is to taking my hobby of writing. I knew AI was skilled, but I didn’t think it was this skilled. So, I have created a little competition: whoever gets more reads on their article wins.

After some quick research, I have even created an intriguing title for both me and the AI writers to use (with a bit of help from ChatGPT):

Digital Resurrection: We can use AI to talk to the dead?!

I have also found 3 AI writers to put to the test:

1. ChatGPT 4.0 (the classic)
2. AI-Writer
3. SEO Writer

So, let the games begin.

My article

If you want to read my article, here it is:

Digital Resurrection: We can use AI to talk to the dead?!

ChatGPT 4.0’s article

Our first AI contestant is good old ChatGPT. ChatGPT is the generalist, the master at none, and the one of the most popular AI out there. I just added ChatGPT for fun.

So, here’s ChatGPT’s article:

Echoes of the Past: Harnessing AI to Connect with Departed Loved Ones

AI-Writer’s article

I just searched up “ai writer” and it was one of the first results.

AI-Writer essentially generates articles using AI. It has a variety of features including content creation, fact-checking, and SEO optimization.

Here’s AI-Writer’s article:

Unlocking The Afterlife: Exploring The Possibility Of Conversing With The Deceased Using Ai

SEO Writer’s article

This AI tool was what I was excited about most. After all, SEO Writer was featured in that article Manish Dangi👻 wrote.

And here it is:

Conversing Beyond: Using AI to Talk to the Dead

When can I see it?

I will release all articles at 6:52 am on Wednesday so the results can be fair.

So I will see you in a week.

The Results

I got to say, I was pretty shocked about the results.

I’ll just show you the results:

The views (on the left) and the reads (on the right)

The winner for round 1 is me with two reads.

Second place, surprisingly, was AI-Writer.

All of the rest (ChatGPT and SEO-Writer) had no views.

Why Didn’t ChatGPT and SEO-Writer Get Any Views?

In the first week, I didn’t expect to get any views. After all, it took months for Manish Dangi to get his article to skyrocket in views, so I have to say I was not expecting views at all.

But the fact that AI-Writer‘s article got more views than any other AI tool was shocking. Why it is surprising is that you have to pay to use SEO-Writer (I used the free trial). I expected SEO-Writer to at least be the AI that gets the most views.

There’s More?

Yes, there’s more.

Remember when I said:

The winner for round 1 is me with two reads.

I was talking about the three rounds I have created:

1. Round one is for a week
2. Round two is for a month
3. Round three is for three months

I have created these rounds because I want to see the long-term effect of using AI.

Conclusion

In the short term, your article may not receive many views. However, I am confident it will gain more views in the upcoming weeks or months.

As I have said many times, AI is a tool and not a replacement.

I’m only doing this experiment to show you how AI-generated content can affect your article. I don’t write articles using AI. Like I said, a tool and not a replacement.

In conclusion, AI will become more capable with more human-like speech. But for now, we will need to see the strengths and weaknesses of AI to utilize them to their full potential.