Rethinking drag and drop
Drag and drop is an intuitive way of moving and rearranging things. We at Atlassian have recently released
react-beautiful-dnd which makes drag and drop for lists on the web more beautiful, natural and accessible.
The core design idea of
react-beautiful-dnd is physicality: we want users to feel like they are moving physical objects around. This is best illustrated through contrast — so let’s explore some standard drag and drop behaviour and how we have tried to do better.
This example uses the amazing
jquery-sortable. It’s drag and drop mechanism is fairly standard and serves as a good reference point.
When dragging items around, other items disappear and reappear as needed. Also, when you drop an item it appears in its new home position immediately.
For a more natural drag we animate the movement of items as they need to move out of the way while dragging to more clearly show a drags effect. We also animate the drop of an item so that it animates into its new home position. At no point is an item instantly moved anywhere — regardless of whether it is dragging or not.
Knowing when to move
It is quite common for drag and drop interactions to be based on the position that user started the drag from
In this example the user is grabbing the top right corner of the first item. The user needs to drag a fair way down before the second item moves to its new position. This is because the calculations are based on the initial selection position of the user.
react-beautiful-dnd a dragging items impact is based on its centre of gravity — regardless of where a user grabs an item from. A dragging items impact follows similar rules to a set of scales ⚖️. Here are some rules that are followed to allow for a natural drag experience even with items of flexible height:
- A list is dragged over when the centre position of a dragging item goes over one of the boundaries of the list
- A resting drag item will move out of the way of a dragging item when the centre position of the dragging item goes over the edge of the resting item. Put another way: once the centre position of an item (A) goes over the edge of another item (B), B moves out of the way.
Traditionally drag and drop interactions have been exclusively a mouse or touch interaction.
react-beautiful-dnd ships with support for drag and drop interactions using only a keyboard. This enables power users to drive their experience entirely from the keyboard. As well as opening up these experiences to users who would have been excluded previously.
Respecting the browser
In addition to supporting keyboard, we have also audited how the keyboard shortcuts interact with standard browser keyboard interactions. When the user is not dragging they can use their keyboard as they normally would. While dragging we override and disable certain browser shortcuts (such as
tab) to ensure a fluid experience for the user.
Carefully designed animations
With things moving a lot it would be easy for the user to become distracted by the animations or for them to get in the way. We have tweaked the various animations to ensure the right balance of guidance, performance and interactivity.
react-beautiful-dnd works really hard to avoid as many periods of non-interactivity as possible. The user should feel like they are in control of the interface and not waiting for an animation to finish before they can continue to interact with the interface.
When you drop a dragging item its movement is based on physics (thanks
react-motion). This results in the drop feeling more weighted and physical.
Moving out of the way
Items that are moving out of the way of a dragging item do so with a CSS transition rather than physics. This is to maximise performance by allowing the GPU to handle the movement. The CSS animation curve has been designed to communicate getting out of the way.
How it is composed:
- A warm up period to mimic a natural response time
- A small phase to quickly move out of the way
- A long tail so that people can read any text that is being animated in the second half of the animation
Plays well with others
We have done a lot of work to ensure that things work intuitively while providing flexibility.
Sloppy clicks and click blocking
When a user presses the mouse down on an element, we cannot determine if the user was clicking or dragging. Also, sometimes when a user clicks they can move the cursor slightly — a sloppy click. So we only start a drag once the user has moved beyond a certain distance with the mouse down (the drag threshold) — more than they would move the mouse if they where just making a sloppy click. If the drag threshold is not exceeded then the user interaction behaves just like a regular click. If the drag threshold is exceeded then the interaction will be classified as a drag and the standard click action will not occur.
This allows consumers to wrap interactive elements such as an anchor and have it be both a standard anchor as well as a draggable item.
react-beautiful-dnd works hard to ensure that it does not impact the usual tab flow of a document. For example, if you are wrapping an anchor tag then the user will still be able to tab to the anchor directly and not an element surrounding the anchor. We add a
tab-index to draggable items to ensure that even you are not wrapping something that is usually interactive (such as a
div) then the user will still be able to access it with their keyboard to drag it.
Not for everyone
There are a lot of libraries out there that allow for drag and drop interactions within React. Most notable of these is the amazing
react-dnd. It does an incredible job at providing a great set of drag and drop primitives which work especially well with the wildly inconsistent html5 drag and drop feature.
react-beautiful-dnd is a higher level abstraction specifically built for vertical and horizontal lists. Within that subset of functionality
react-beautiful-dnd offers a powerful, natural and beautiful drag and drop experience. However, it does not provide the breadth of functionality offered by
react-dnd. So this library might not be for you depending on what your use case is.
Clean, powerful API
Before this library was released a lot of time an attention was given to crafting a declarative, clean and powerful api. It should feel really easy to get started with and provide the right level of control over the whole drag experience. It is based off a lot of research into other libraries as well as collective experience in building drag and drop products. I won’t go into all the details of the api here — but you can find a comprehensive guide repo
react-beautiful-dnd is designed to be extremely performant — it is part of its DNA. It builds on prior investigations into React performance that you can read about here and here. It is designed to perform the minimum number of renders required for each task.
- Using connected-components with memoization to ensure the only components that render are the ones that need to — thanks
- All drag movements are throttled with
- Memoization is used all over the place — thanks
- Conditionally disabling
pointer-eventson all draggable items while dragging to prevent the browser needing to do redundant work — you can read more about the technique here
- Non primary animations are done on the GPU
react-beautiful-dnd uses a number of different testing strategies including unit, performance and integration tests. Testing various aspects of the system helps to promote its quality and stability.
While code coverage is not a guarantee of code health, it is a good indicator. This code base currently sits at ~95% coverage.
This codebase is typed with
flowtype to promote greater internal consistency and more resilient code. It also provides for a greater developer documentation story as the whole api is typed.
A huge thank you to everyone at Atlassian who made this possible