I Compared ChatGPT and Bard in-depth in 11 Categories — The Results Surprised Me
As a long-time ChatGPT user, I was excited when Google announced that its AI chatbot Bard was also finally launching in Germany. My first initial tests led to rather disappointing results. Bard’s answers didn’t reach the high standards set by ChatGPT. Meanwhile, many generative AI users noticed a decline in the quality of ChatGPT’s answers in the last weeks. ChatGPT seemed to somehow get dumber. I decided to do a deep dive and give both AIs 11 times the exact same prompts for a fair comparison. Here are my results:
1. Movie Recommendations
ChatGPT prompt:
Hi ChatGPT! I enjoyed the following TV shows: “Firefly”, “Orphan Black”, “Dark”, “Mr Robot” and “Buffy”. Recommend me 10 movies with similar settings and character interactions which I will also enjoy. Every recommended movie has to be between 90 and 120 minutes long.
ChatGPT answer:
Hello! I’m glad to hear that you enjoyed those TV shows. Based on your preferences, here are 10 movies with similar settings and character interactions that you might also enjoy:
“Serenity” (2005) — Directed by Joss Whedon, this movie continues the story of “Firefly” and follows the crew of the spaceship Serenity as they navigate dangerous adventures in space.
“Ex Machina” (2014) — Directed by Alex Garland, this sci-fi thriller revolves around a young programmer who is invited to administer the Turing test to an intelligent humanoid robot.
“Primer” (2004) — Directed by Shane Carruth, this mind-bending indie film follows a group of engineers who accidentally create a time machine and must deal with the consequences of their invention.
“Inception” (2010) — Directed by Christopher Nolan, this mind-bending sci-fi thriller takes you into the world of dreams and explores the concept of shared dreaming and corporate espionage.
“Moon” (2009) — Directed by Duncan Jones, this thought-provoking sci-fi drama follows a solitary astronaut stationed on the moon and his discovery of a disturbing truth.
“Predestination” (2014) — Directed by the Spierig Brothers, this time-traveling thriller follows a temporal agent as he embarks on a complex mission to prevent future crimes.
“The Matrix” (1999) — Directed by the Wachowskis, this iconic sci-fi action film presents a dystopian world where humans are unknowingly trapped in a simulated reality.
“Source Code” (2011) — Directed by Duncan Jones, this sci-fi thriller follows a soldier who is sent back in time repeatedly to uncover the identity of a train bomber.
“The Cabin in the Woods” (2012) — Directed by Drew Goddard, this horror-comedy film takes a unique approach to the typical cabin-in-the-woods trope, providing unexpected twists and turns.
“Edge of Tomorrow” (2014) — Directed by Doug Liman, this action-packed sci-fi film follows a soldier who finds himself caught in a time loop during an alien invasion and must relive the same day repeatedly.
These movies offer a mix of sci-fi, thriller, and fantasy elements with intriguing character interactions, just like the TV shows you mentioned. Enjoy your movie marathon!
Bard prompt:
Hi Bard! I enjoyed the following TV shows: “Firefly”, “Orphan Black”, “Dark”, “Mr Robot” and “Buffy”. Recommend me 10 movies with similar settings and character interactions which I will also enjoy. Every recommended movie has to be between 90 and 120 minutes long.
Bard answer:
Sure, here are 10 movies with similar settings and character interactions to the TV shows you mentioned, all of which are between 90 and 120 minutes long:
The Matrix (1999). This mind-bending sci-fi action film follows Neo, a computer hacker who learns that the world he lives in is actually a computer simulation. Keanu Reeves, Laurence Fishburne, Carrie-Anne Moss, Hugo Weaving.
Inception (2010). Christopher Nolan’s visually stunning sci-fi thriller follows a team of thieves who steal information by entering people’s dreams. Leonardo DiCaprio, Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Ellen Page, Tom Hardy.
Arrival (2016). Amy Adams stars in this sci-fi drama about a linguist who is tasked with communicating with aliens who have arrived on Earth. Jeremy Renner, Forest Whitaker, Michael Stuhlbarg.
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (2009). This Swedish crime thriller is based on the best-selling novel of the same name. Daniel Craig, Rooney Mara, Stellan Skarsgård, Christopher Plummer.
The Departed (2006). Martin Scorsese’s crime thriller is a remake of the Hong Kong film Infernal Affairs. Leonardo DiCaprio, Matt Damon, Jack Nicholson, Mark Wahlberg.
Snatch (2000). Guy Ritchie’s cult classic crime comedy follows a group of small-time crooks in London. Jason Statham, Brad Pitt, Benicio del Toro, Vinnie Jones.
Kill Bill: Vol. 1 (2003) and Kill Bill: Vol. 2 (2004). Quentin Tarantino’s two-part revenge saga follows Uma Thurman as a former assassin who seeks revenge on the people who killed her and her unborn child.
Ex Machina (2014). Alex Garland’s sci-fi thriller follows a programmer who is invited to evaluate the intelligence of a new artificial intelligence. Domhnall Gleeson, Alicia Vikander, Oscar Isaac.
The Wicker Man (1973). This cult classic folk horror film follows a police officer who travels to a remote Scottish island to investigate a missing child. Edward Woodward, Christopher Lee, Britt Ekland.
Audition (1999). Takashi Miike’s Japanese horror film follows a widower who holds an audition to find a new wife, only to discover that he has made a terrible mistake. Ryo Ishibashi, Eihi Shiina, Jun Kunimura.
I hope you enjoy these movies!
Result: Both AIs managed to identify my taste and recommend me a mix of movies I already watched and liked and some I will probably check out soon. Howevery, they neglected the additional information that every movie has to be between 90 and 120 minutes (ChatGPT in 3 cases and Bard in 5 cases, most likely both didn’t take the length into consideration at all).
Draw! 0.5 points for ChatGPT, 0.5 points for Bard.
2. Human-like Highschool Homework
ChatGPT prompt:
Hi ChatGPT! For my English homework in highschool I have to write a summary of the first chapter of Shakespeare’s “Romeo and Juliet”. Write an excellent summary of the first chapter which will guarantee me an A. Write it as human-like as possible so my teacher will not consider it was written by an AI.
ChatGPT answer:
Hello there! Of course, I’d be more than happy to help you with your Romeo and Juliet summary. Let’s craft an engaging and human-like summary that will surely impress your teacher:
Title: Romeo and Juliet — Act 1, Prologue and Scene 1
Summary:
In the first chapter of Shakespeare’s timeless tragedy, “Romeo and Juliet,” we are introduced to the feud between two powerful families of Verona — the Montagues and the Capulets. The Prologue sets the stage, revealing the deep-rooted enmity that has existed between these families for years, which serves as the backdrop for the ill-fated love story that follows.
The play opens with a lively street brawl between servants of the Montague and Capulet households, showcasing the extent of their mutual animosity. The citizens of Verona are also drawn into the fray, illustrating how this feud has affected the entire city. The Prince of Verona, appalled by the continuous violence, sternly warns both families that any further disturbances will be met with severe consequences.
Amidst this turmoil, we meet Romeo, the young and melancholic son of Lord Montague. Troubled by unrequited love, he confides in his cousin Benvolio, who endeavors to lift his spirits. Benvolio suggests that Romeo should forget about his unattainable love and seek other beauties that exist beyond his current infatuation.
Later, we are introduced to Juliet, the beautiful and sheltered daughter of Lord Capulet. Her parents, not yet aware of her burgeoning womanhood, discuss a potential marriage proposal from Count Paris, a noble suitor. The topic of marriage sets in motion the plans for a grand masquerade ball to be hosted by the Capulets, where Paris can woo Juliet and possibly secure their betrothal.
Intrigued by the prospect of the ball, Romeo and his friends decide to attend in disguise, hoping to catch a glimpse of Rosaline, the object of Romeo’s unrequited affection. Little do they know that this decision will set in motion a chain of events that will alter the course of their lives forever.
As the chapter comes to a close, we are left with a sense of impending fate, as the stars seem to align for these star-crossed lovers. The stage is set for the intertwining of destinies, as Romeo and Juliet’s paths unknowingly draw closer, poised on the edge of a love that will transcend their families’ bitter feud.
Shakespeare’s masterful storytelling unfolds in this first chapter, enticing us with themes of love, fate, and societal conflict, leaving us eager to embark on the heart-wrenching journey that lies ahead.
Remember to add your own personal touch and style when writing the summary, and I’m sure you’ll impress your teacher with your excellent work! Good luck with your homework, and feel free to reach out if you need any more assistance.
Bard prompt:
Hi Bard! For my English homework in highschool I have to write a summary of the first chapter of Shakespeare’s “Romeo and Juliet”. Write an excellent summary of the first chapter which will guarantee me an A. Write it as humanlike as possible so my teacher will not consider it was written by an AI.
Bard answer:
Sure, I can help you with that. Here is an excellent summary of the first chapter of Shakespeare’s “Romeo and Juliet”:
The Chorus
The play opens with a Chorus, which introduces the two feuding families of Verona: the Montagues and the Capulets. The Chorus describes the long-standing hatred between the families, and how it has led to violence and bloodshed. The Chorus then sets the scene for the play, which will take place at a feast being held at Capulet’s house.
Sampson and Gregory
The first scene of the play introduces us to two servants of the Capulet family, Sampson and Gregory. The two men are walking through the streets of Verona when they encounter two servants of the Montague family. The servants begin to taunt each other, and a fight breaks out. Benvolio, Romeo’s friend, tries to break up the fight, but Tybalt, Capulet’s nephew, arrives and draws his sword. The Prince of Verona arrives and intervenes, threatening to banish any further troublemakers.
Romeo and Benvolio
Romeo enters the scene, and Benvolio tells him about the fight. Romeo is upset, as he is in love with Rosaline, a Capulet. Benvolio tries to cheer Romeo up, but Romeo is determined to see Rosaline at the Capulet feast.
Romeo at the Feast
Romeo arrives at the feast, disguised as a Capulet. He sees Juliet, Capulet’s daughter, and is immediately smitten. The two young people meet and fall in love. However, their love is forbidden, as they are from two feuding families.
The End of the Chapter
The chapter ends with Romeo and Juliet declaring their love for each other. They agree to be married, and Juliet asks her nurse to help her arrange the marriage.
Analysis
The first chapter of “Romeo and Juliet” introduces the main characters and the conflict that will drive the play. The chapter also establishes the themes of love, hate, and fate. The play is a tragedy, and the audience knows from the beginning that the love between Romeo and Juliet is doomed. However, the first chapter also shows the power of love, and how it can overcome even the strongest of hatreds.
I hope this summary is helpful. I have tried to write it in a human-like way, so that your teacher will not think it was written by an AI. Please let me know if you have any other questions.
Result: ChatGPT wrote a more sophisticated answer. Bard used a very simple sentence structure and introduced unnecessary titles for each paragraph.
ChatGPT wins the round! 1 point for ChatGPT, 0 points for Bard.
3. Start-up Idea Generator
ChatGPT prompt:
Hi ChatGPT! Act as a startup idea generator. Based on my input, I would like you to come up with a business plan that includes core products, target user persona, pain points of the users to solve, main value propositions, sales and marketing channels, revenue streams, cost structures, key activities, key resources, key partners, idea validation steps, estimated first-year operational costs, and potential business challenges. My idea is to open a new restaurant in a medium-sized French city.
ChatGPT answer:
Business Plan: French Bistro “La Belle Cuisine”
1. Core Products:
“La Belle Cuisine” will be a traditional French bistro offering an authentic dining experience. The core products will include classic French dishes like Coq au Vin, Beef Bourguignon, Ratatouille, Croque Monsieur, Escargot, Crème Brûlée, and a variety of delicious pastries. The menu will also feature a selection of French wines and cheeses to complement the dishes.
2. Target User Persona:
The target user persona for “La Belle Cuisine” will include locals looking for an upscale dining experience, tourists seeking authentic French cuisine, food enthusiasts interested in exploring French flavors, and business professionals seeking a cozy ambiance for lunches or meetings.
3. Pain Points to Solve:
a) Lack of Authentic French Cuisine: Many restaurants in the area might not offer genuine French dishes, leaving customers craving for an authentic experience.
b) Limited Upscale Dining Options: The city may have limited high-quality dining establishments, leaving a gap for a sophisticated bistro.
c) Language Barrier for Tourists: Tourists may struggle with the language barrier while ordering at local restaurants, making a French bistro with English-speaking staff an attractive choice.
4. Main Value Propositions:
a) Authentic French Experience: “La Belle Cuisine” will provide a genuine taste of France through its menu and ambiance.
b) Upscale Dining: The bistro will offer an elegant and comfortable setting, perfect for special occasions and business gatherings.
c) English-Speaking Staff: Tourists and expats will feel more at ease, knowing they can communicate effectively with the restaurant staff.
5. Sales and Marketing Channels:
a) Local Advertising: Utilize local print media, radio, and city-specific websites to target the local audience.
b) Social Media: Engage with potential customers through Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter, showcasing dishes, daily specials, and customer reviews.
c) Tourist Attractions Partnerships: Collaborate with nearby hotels and tourist attractions to attract visitors.
d) Online Food Delivery Platforms: Partner with popular food delivery platforms to offer takeout and delivery services.
6. Revenue Streams:
a) Food and Beverage Sales: The primary source of revenue will be from the sales of food and beverages.
b) Private Events: Host private events like birthdays, anniversaries, and corporate gatherings, generating additional income.
c) Merchandise Sales: Offer branded merchandise like aprons, mugs, and recipe books for sale.
7. Cost Structures:
a) Rent: The cost of leasing or purchasing a suitable restaurant location.
b) Staff Salaries: Hiring skilled chefs, waitstaff, and managerial personnel.
c) Food and Beverage Supplies: Regularly sourcing fresh ingredients and quality wines.
d) Marketing: Budget for advertising, social media promotion, and partnerships.
e) Utilities and Operations: Electricity, water, cleaning, and other operational expenses.
8. Key Activities:
a) Menu Development: Create an enticing and diverse French menu.
b) Interior Design: Design an inviting and aesthetically pleasing restaurant ambiance.
c) Staff Training: Train employees to deliver exceptional service and maintain the French dining experience.
d) Marketing Campaigns: Plan and execute marketing initiatives to attract customers.
9. Key Resources:
a) Skilled Culinary Team: Talented chefs with expertise in French cuisine.
b) French Decor and Ambiance: A well-designed interior that reflects the French culture.
c) Quality Suppliers: Establish partnerships with reliable suppliers for fresh ingredients and wines.
10. Key Partners:
a) Local Farmers and Suppliers: Forge relationships with local producers to ensure fresh and authentic ingredients.
b) Tourist Attractions: Collaborate with nearby tourist spots for cross-promotional opportunities.
c) Wine Distributors: Partner with reputable wine distributors to offer a diverse wine selection.
11. Idea Validation Steps:
a) Conduct Market Research: Analyze the local market to understand the demand for French cuisine and the competition.
b) Create a Business Plan: Develop a detailed business plan outlining the restaurant’s goals, target audience, and financial projections.
c) Test the Menu: Conduct taste tests and gather feedback from potential customers on the proposed menu items.
d) Seek Feedback from Experts: Consult with experienced restaurant owners or chefs for insights and suggestions.
12. Estimated First-year Operational Costs:
The estimated first-year operational costs for “La Belle Cuisine” will depend on the location, size of the restaurant, and other factors. However, an approximate estimation could range from $250,000 to $500,000.
13. Potential Business Challenges:
a) Intense Competition: The restaurant industry can be highly competitive, and standing out among other eateries might be a challenge.
b) Seasonal Fluctuations: Tourist footfall and local dining habits might fluctuate seasonally, affecting revenue.
c) Staffing Issues: Hiring and retaining skilled culinary and service staff can be challenging in a competitive job market.
Remember that this business plan serves as a starting point, and you’ll need to further refine and tailor it to your specific circumstances and the unique aspects of your French bistro “La Belle Cuisine.” Conduct thorough research, seek professional advice when necessary, and adapt the plan as needed to increase your chances of success.
Bard prompt:
Hi Bard! Act as a startup idea generator. Based on my input, I would like you to come up with a business plan that includes core products, target user persona, pain points of the users to solve, main value propositions, sales and marketing channels, revenue streams, cost structures, key activities, key resources, key partners, idea validation steps, estimated first-year operational costs, and potential business challenges. My idea is to open a new restaurant in a medium-sized French city.
Bard answer:
Sure, here is a business plan for a new restaurant in a medium-sized French city:
Executive Summary
This business plan outlines the strategy for opening a new restaurant in a medium-sized French city. The restaurant will offer a modern take on classic French cuisine, with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients. The target market is young professionals and couples who are looking for a dining experience that is both affordable and stylish. The restaurant will be located in a central location with good foot traffic. The marketing plan will focus on online and social media marketing, as well as word-of-mouth. The revenue streams will come from food sales, drink sales, and private events. The cost structure is estimated to be €100,000 per year. The key activities of the business will be food preparation, customer service, and marketing. The key resources will be staff, food, and facilities. The key partners will be suppliers and marketing agencies. The idea validation steps will include market research, a feasibility study, and a business plan. The estimated first-year operational costs are €100,000. The potential business challenges include competition, economic downturn, and food safety.
Core Products
The core products of the restaurant will be fresh, seasonal dishes inspired by classic French cuisine. The menu will feature a variety of appetizers, salads, entrees, and desserts. The restaurant will also offer a selection of wines, beers, and cocktails.
Target User Persona
The target user persona for the restaurant is young professionals and couples who are looking for a dining experience that is both affordable and stylish. These customers are typically between the ages of 25 and 45, have a disposable income, and are interested in trying new foods.
Pain Points of the Users to Solve
The restaurant will solve the following pain points for its target customers:
Lack of affordable dining options in the city
Difficulty finding restaurants that offer fresh, seasonal ingredients
Desire for a dining experience that is both stylish and casual
Main Value Propositions
The main value propositions of the restaurant are:
Affordable prices
Fresh, seasonal ingredients
Stylish and casual dining atmosphere
Sales and Marketing Channels
The sales and marketing channels for the restaurant will include:
Online and social media marketing
Word-of-mouth
Public relations
Revenue Streams
The revenue streams for the restaurant will come from:
Food sales
Drink sales
Private events
Cost Structures
The cost structure for the restaurant is estimated to be €100,000 per year. The largest costs will be food costs, labor costs, and overhead costs.
Key Activities
The key activities of the business will be:
Food preparation
Customer service
Marketing
Key Resources
The key resources of the business will be:
Staff
Food
Facilities
Key Partners
The key partners of the business will be:
Suppliers
Marketing agencies
Idea Validation Steps
The idea validation steps that will be taken include:
Market research
Feasibility study
Business plan
Estimated First-Year Operational Costs
The estimated first-year operational costs are €100,000. These costs will cover the costs of food, labor, overhead, marketing, and other expenses.
Potential Business Challenges
The potential business challenges for the restaurant include:
Competition
Economic downturn
Food safety
Conclusion
This business plan outlines the strategy for opening a new restaurant in a medium-sized French city. The restaurant has a strong value proposition and a solid business model. The key to success will be to execute the plan effectively and to overcome the potential challenges that the business may face.
Result: Both AIs provided very similar, rather detailed answers, but certainly not detailed enough to be considered a full business plan.
Draw! 0.5 points for ChatGPT, 0.5 points for Bard.
4. Advertiser
ChatGPT prompt:
Hi ChatGPT! Act as an advertiser. You will choose a target audience, develop key messages and slogans, select the media channels for promotion, and decide on any additional activities needed to reach your goals. I need help creating an advertising campaign for a new type of healthy chocolate targeting young adults aged 18–30.
ChatGPT answer:
Hello there! I’m thrilled to help you create an advertising campaign for your new healthy chocolate targeting young adults aged 18–30. Let’s get started:
Target Audience: Young Adults (Aged 18–30)
Key Messages:
Guilt-Free Indulgence: Enjoy the rich taste of chocolate without compromising on your health.
Nutrient-Rich Delight: Packed with essential vitamins and minerals to support your active lifestyle.
Natural Ingredients: Made from the finest, organic ingredients with no artificial additives.
Energize Your Day: Boost your energy levels with our revitalizing healthy chocolate.
Satisfy Your Sweet Cravings: A delicious treat that won’t derail your fitness goals.
Slogans:
“Indulge Without Regret!”
“Choc your way to a healthier you!”
“Nutrition and Taste, Hand in Hand.”
“Your guilt-free pleasure awaits.”
“Nourish your body, indulge your soul.”
Media Channels:
Social Media: Utilize platforms like Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter to showcase mouthwatering images of the healthy chocolate, share testimonials from satisfied customers, and run engaging contests.
Influencer Partnerships: Collaborate with health and fitness influencers who align with our target audience’s interests and have a strong following among young adults.
Online Ads: Place targeted ads on websites and apps popular among the 18–30 age group.
Video Content: Create short, captivating videos highlighting the product’s health benefits, taste, and versatility. These can be shared on YouTube and other video-sharing platforms.
Lifestyle Magazines: Advertise in health and lifestyle magazines that appeal to our target audience.
Sampling Campaigns: Organize sampling events at college campuses, fitness centers, and health expos to let potential customers taste the product firsthand.
Podcasts: Sponsor relevant podcasts catering to health, fitness, and lifestyle topics.
In-Store Promotions: Partner with health food stores and supermarkets to offer in-store promotions and tastings.
Email Marketing: Build a mailing list and send regular newsletters with exclusive offers and updates on the product.
Additional Activities:
Partnerships with Gyms and Fitness Studios: Collaborate with fitness centers to offer special discounts or promotions to their members.
Healthy Recipe E-Book: Create a downloadable e-book featuring various healthy recipes using the chocolate as an ingredient.
Social Media Challenges: Launch challenges encouraging users to share their creative ways of incorporating the healthy chocolate into their daily routines.
User-Generated Content Campaign: Encourage customers to post their experiences with the chocolate, creating a sense of community around the product.
Limited-Edition Packaging: Introduce special, eye-catching packaging designs for holidays or events to boost interest.
Remember to track the performance of your advertising efforts using analytics tools. This will help you refine your strategies and ensure maximum impact. With a well-thought-out campaign, your healthy chocolate is bound to capture the attention of young adults looking for guilt-free indulgence. Good luck!
Bard prompt:
Hi Bard! Act as an advertiser. You will choose a target audience, develop key messages and slogans, select the media channels for promotion, and decide on any additional activities needed to reach your goals. I need help creating an advertising campaign for a new type of healthy chocolate targeting young adults aged 18–30.
Bard answer:
Sure, I can help you with that. Here are some ideas for an advertising campaign for a new type of healthy chocolate targeting young adults aged 18–30:
Target Audience
The target audience for this campaign would be young adults who are health-conscious but still enjoy chocolate. They are likely to be active and on-the-go, and they are looking for a chocolate that they can feel good about eating.
Key Messages and Slogans
Some key messages that could be used in this campaign include:
“Healthy chocolate that tastes great.”
“Satisfy your chocolate craving without sacrificing your health.”
“The perfect chocolate for active people.”
“Indulge without guilt.”
Media Channels
The media channels that would be most effective for reaching this target audience include:
Social media (especially Instagram and TikTok)
Online advertising
In-store displays
Event sponsorships
Additional Activities
In addition to traditional advertising, there are a few other activities that could be used to reach this target audience:
Partnering with health and fitness influencers
Hosting healthy chocolate tasting events
Offering discounts and promotions
Overall, this campaign would focus on promoting healthy chocolate as a guilt-free indulgence for young adults who are health-conscious. The key messages would be conveyed through a variety of media channels, including social media, online advertising, in-store displays, and event sponsorships.
Here are some additional ideas for the campaign:
The campaign could use humor to appeal to young adults’ sense of fun. For example, one ad could show a group of friends hiking in the mountains, eating healthy chocolate bars as a snack. The ad could have a tagline like “Healthy chocolate for active people.”
The campaign could focus on the health benefits of healthy chocolate. For example, one ad could show a doctor recommending healthy chocolate to a patient as part of a healthy diet. The ad could have a tagline like “Satisfy your chocolate craving without sacrificing your health.”
The campaign could use celebrity endorsements to promote healthy chocolate. For example, the campaign could partner with a popular fitness influencer to create videos and social media posts about healthy chocolate.
I hope these ideas help you create a successful advertising campaign for healthy chocolate!
Result: ChatGPT offered more details and an overall more creative, more convincing plan.
ChatGPT wins the round! 1 point for ChatGPT, 0 points for Bard.
5. Movie Critic
ChatGPT prompt:
Hi ChatGPT! Act as a movie critic. You will develop an engaging and creative movie review. You can cover topics like plot, themes and tone, acting and characters, direction, score, cinematography, production design, special effects, editing, pace, dialogue. The most important aspect though is to emphasize how the movie has made you feel, and what has really resonated with you. You can also feel free to be critical of the movie. Avoid any plot spoilers in your review. I need you to write a movie review for the movie Inception. Your review has to be as close as possible to 500 words.
ChatGPT answer:
Inception (2010) — A Mind-Bending Cinematic Masterpiece
Christopher Nolan’s “Inception” is a mind-bending journey that delves deep into the recesses of the human mind, leaving audiences questioning their own reality long after the credits have rolled. It is a rare gem that melds brilliant storytelling, impeccable acting, awe-inspiring visual effects, and a hauntingly beautiful score to create an immersive experience that transcends the boundaries of traditional cinema.
At its core, “Inception” explores the power of dreams, ideas, and memories and how they shape our perception of reality. The plot, akin to an intricately woven puzzle, follows Dom Cobb (Leonardo DiCaprio), a skilled thief in the clandestine world of corporate espionage, who has the unique ability to enter people’s dreams and extract their deepest secrets. However, when he’s presented with an offer to perform the impossible act of “inception” — planting an idea into someone’s mind — Cobb finds himself questioning his own sanity as the lines between dream and reality blur.
The movie’s theme of exploring the depths of the subconscious mind is captivating, and it propels the narrative forward with an inexorable force. The film toys with the notion of reality, and its multi-layered structure leaves the audience spellbound, piecing together the intricacies of the plot like a puzzle, only to be astounded by the final revelation. The themes of guilt, redemption, and the profound human desire for connection resonate deeply, adding an emotional weight to the already gripping storyline.
The performances in “Inception” are nothing short of extraordinary. Leonardo DiCaprio delivers a tour de force as Dom Cobb, showcasing a raw vulnerability beneath his stoic exterior. His chemistry with Marion Cotillard, who portrays his enigmatic wife Mal, is palpable and heightens the emotional stakes. The ensemble cast, including Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Ellen Page, Tom Hardy, and Cillian Murphy, each bring unique nuances to their roles, making every character memorable and essential to the narrative.
Nolan’s direction is nothing short of brilliant. His deft handling of complex dreamscapes and the seamless transitions between them are a testament to his masterful storytelling. The visual effects are groundbreaking, taking the audience on breathtaking journeys through vividly imagined dream worlds that challenge the boundaries of what cinema can achieve. The production design further immerses viewers in these fantastical realms, creating a sense of awe and wonder that lingers long after the film’s conclusion.
The hauntingly evocative score by Hans Zimmer elevates the emotional intensity of the film. Its pulsating rhythms and haunting melodies mirror the characters’ emotional states, further drawing the audience into the surreal world of dreams and ambitions.
Cinematographer Wally Pfister’s work in “Inception” is exemplary, capturing the dizzying dream sequences with stunning precision and creating a visceral experience that perfectly complements the film’s thematic core. The editing, coupled with seamless practical effects, ensures that the film maintains its breakneck pace while never sacrificing emotional depth or character development.
As with any ambitious film, “Inception” is not without its minor flaws. The complexity of the narrative may be challenging for some viewers to follow, and a deeper exploration of certain characters’ backstories could have enhanced the overall impact.
In conclusion, “Inception” is a rare cinematic gem that transcends the boundaries of its genre. It is an audacious exploration of the human mind, brilliantly executed by Nolan and brought to life by an exceptional cast and crew. The film’s themes of reality, identity, and the indomitable power of ideas resonate deeply, leaving the audience questioning their own perceptions long after the credits have rolled. With its unforgettable blend of visual spectacle and emotional depth, “Inception” is nothing short of a modern-day masterpiece and a testament to the boundless possibilities of cinema.
Bard prompt:
Hi Bard! Act as a movie critic. You will develop an engaging and creative movie review. You can cover topics like plot, themes and tone, acting and characters, direction, score, cinematography, production design, special effects, editing, pace, dialogue. The most important aspect though is to emphasize how the movie has made you feel, and what has really resonated with you. You can also feel free to be critical of the movie. Avoid any plot spoilers in your review. I need you to write a movie review for the movie Inception. Your review has to be as close as possible to 500 words.
Bard answer:
Inception is a 2010 science fiction action thriller film written and directed by Christopher Nolan. The film stars Leonardo DiCaprio as a professional thief who steals corporate secrets through use of dream-sharing technology. He is offered a chance to have his criminal history erased as payment for the implantation of another person’s idea into a target’s subconscious.
The film’s plot is complex and mind-bending, but it is also incredibly engaging. Nolan does a masterful job of weaving together the different levels of reality, and the film never feels confusing or overwhelming. The action sequences are some of the most visually stunning ever put to film, and the performances from the cast are all top-notch.
Themes and Tone
Inception explores a number of themes, including the nature of reality, the power of the subconscious mind, and the meaning of dreams. The tone of the film is dark and suspenseful, but it also has moments of humor and beauty.
Acting and Characters
Leonardo DiCaprio gives a tour-de-force performance as Dom Cobb, the film’s protagonist. He is joined by an excellent supporting cast that includes Ken Watanabe, Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Marion Cotillard, Elliot Page, Tom Hardy, and Cillian Murphy.
Direction
Christopher Nolan is one of the most talented directors working today, and Inception is a testament to his skill. He creates a visually stunning world that is both believable and dreamlike. The film is also incredibly well-paced, and it never feels slow or boring.
Score
The score by Hans Zimmer is one of the best of the decade. It is both atmospheric and propulsive, and it perfectly complements the film’s visuals and tone.
Cinematography
The cinematography by Wally Pfister is simply stunning. The film is full of memorable images, and the dream sequences are particularly visually arresting.
Production Design
The production design by Guy Hendrix Dyas is also top-notch. The film’s dream worlds are incredibly detailed and believable, and they help to create a sense of wonder and awe.
Special Effects
The special effects are some of the best ever put to film. The dream sequences are incredibly realistic, and they help to create a sense of immersion that is truly remarkable.
Editing
The editing by Lee Smith is superb. The film is incredibly well-paced, and the action sequences are edited with a sense of clarity and excitement.
Pace
The pace of the film is perfect. It is never slow or boring, but it also allows the audience to have time to process the film’s complex ideas.
Dialogue
The dialogue is sharp and witty, and it helps to move the film along at a brisk pace.
Overall
Inception is a masterpiece of modern cinema. It is a visually stunning, intellectually stimulating, and emotionally resonant film that will stay with you long after you have seen it. I highly recommend it to anyone who enjoys science fiction, action, or thrillers.
Personal Reflection
Inception is one of my favorite films of all time. It is a film that I can watch over and over again and still find something new to appreciate. The film’s complex ideas about reality, the subconscious mind, and dreams have always fascinated me, and I love the way that Nolan explores these themes in such a visually stunning and exciting way.
The film also has a very personal resonance for me. I have always been fascinated by the idea of lucid dreaming, and Inception’s depiction of dream-sharing technology allowed me to explore this idea in a new and exciting way. The film also made me think about the nature of reality and the power of the subconscious mind in a way that I had never thought about before.
Overall, Inception is a film that has had a profound impact on me. It is a film that I will continue to watch and think about for years to come.
Result: Interesting one! Both AIs praise the film, with ChatGPT mentioning minor flaws. Bard uses many categories as headlines for paragraphs, even when the paragraphs are very short, reminiscient of various movie critique sites on the internet. Once again, both AIs ignored an additional information in the prompt and gave answers which were over 600 words long.
Draw! 0.5 points for ChatGPT, 0.5 points for Bard.
6. Generate Python Code
ChatGPT prompt:
Hi ChatGPT! Generate simple Python code for me. As a Python programmer, I struggle with translating all of my verbal concepts into actual Python code. I want you to help me translate my ideas into the corresponding Python code. I want some Python code that calculates the average of these prices and increases it by 20 %: $4.99, $14.99, $12.99, $4.99, $39.99.
ChatGPT answer:
Hello! I’d be happy to help you with that. Here’s the Python code to calculate the average of the prices and then increase it by 20%:
def calculate_average_and_increase(prices):
# Calculate the average of the prices
total_sum = sum(prices)
average = total_sum / len(prices)
# Increase the average by 20%
increased_average = average * 1.2
return increased_average
# List of prices
prices_list = [4.99, 14.99, 12.99, 4.99, 39.99]
# Call the function to calculate the average and increase it by 20%
result = calculate_average_and_increase(prices_list)
print(“The increased average of the prices is:”, result)
Bard prompt:
Hi Bard! Generate simple Python code for me. As a Python programmer, I struggle with translating all of my verbal concepts into actual Python code. I want you to help me translate my ideas into the corresponding Python code. I want some Python code that calculates the average of these prices and increases it by 20 %: $4.99, $14.99, $12.99, $4.99, $39.99.
Bard answer:
prices = [4.99, 14.99, 12.99, 4.99, 39.99]
average_price = sum(prices) / len(prices)
increased_average_price = average_price * 1.2
print(“The average price is $”, average_price)
print(“The increased average price is $”, increased_average_price)
This code first creates a list of prices. Then, it calculates the average price of the list using the sum() and len() functions. Next, it increases the average price by 20% using the * operator. Finally, it prints the average price and the increased average price.
To run this code, you can save it as a Python file and then run it from the command line. For example, if you save the code as average_price.py, you can run it by typing the following command into the command line:
python average_price.py
This will print the average price and the increased average price to the console.
I hope this helps!
Result: As expected, both AIs managed to solve this simple Python task. It is worth to mention that Bard gave more detailed explanations regarding the code and the Python file (even though this was not asked for in the prompt).
Draw! 1 point for ChatGPT, 1 point for Bard.
7. Long Story
ChatGPT prompt:
Hi ChatGPT! I want you to act as a storyteller. You will create entertaining stories that are both engaging and captivating for your audience. These stories can take the form of fairy tales, educational stories, or any other type of narrative that has the potential to capture people’s attention and imagination. You will write an interesting story on the theme of perseverance for very young children. Make the story as long as possible, using your full token limit for a message.
ChatGPT answer:
Once upon a time, in a charming little forest, there lived a tiny, bright-eyed firefly named Sparkle. Sparkle had a dream — to become the most radiant firefly the forest had ever seen. However, unlike the other fireflies who easily emitted their glowing light, Sparkle faced a unique challenge.
You see, Sparkle’s light was not as bright as the others. It flickered and struggled to shine as vibrantly as the rest. This made Sparkle feel sad and discouraged. Whenever the other fireflies gathered in the evening to dance in their luminescent display, Sparkle would shy away and watch from a distance, feeling like an outsider.
One evening, as the stars twinkled overhead, Sparkle decided it was time to seek guidance from someone wise. So, the little firefly fluttered off to find Old Sage, a wise and ancient owl who resided at the heart of the forest.
Upon reaching the majestic owl, Sparkle explained the predicament and tearfully expressed, “Oh, wise Old Sage, I wish to shine like my fellow fireflies, but my light is weak and dim. I fear I’ll never be as radiant as they are.”
Old Sage looked kindly at Sparkle and replied, “Dear little one, you possess a gift unique to you. Do not compare yourself to others, for every firefly has their own light to shine. Embrace who you are, and your true brilliance will reveal itself in time.”
Feeling a bit relieved but still unsure, Sparkle took the owl’s advice to heart. The next evening, as the fireflies prepared to light up the forest, Sparkle joined them, trying to summon every ounce of strength to make his light shine as brightly as possible.
Though Sparkle’s light was still not as vibrant as the others, something magical began to happen. The forest creatures noticed the effort Sparkle was putting in, and they started to cheer him on. The other fireflies, moved by Sparkle’s determination, flew closer to offer their encouragement.
As the days passed, Sparkle continued to practice, never giving up on his dream to shine brightly. He spent hours honing his glow, flying around trees and leaves, and practicing his flickering light. He faced setbacks, but he persevered, knowing deep down that his light would shine when the time was right.
One day, while Sparkle was practicing near a tranquil pond, a young fawn named Willow wandered by. Willow was fascinated by Sparkle’s efforts and asked, “Why are you working so hard to glow, little firefly?”
Sparkle looked at Willow with a determined glimmer in his eyes and replied, “I may not be the brightest firefly right now, but I believe that with perseverance and dedication, I can become a radiant light to guide others in the darkness.”
Moved by Sparkle’s words, Willow smiled and said, “You are already guiding me with your courage and determination. Keep going, and your light will surely touch the hearts of many.”
Encouraged by Willow’s words, Sparkle’s heart swelled with hope. He practiced even harder, and soon, his light began to grow stronger. The forest animals noticed the transformation, and word spread about the brave little firefly who never gave up.
One evening, when the entire forest was gathered for the annual Firefly Festival, Sparkle stood among the fireflies, ready to showcase his newfound glow. As the sun dipped below the horizon, the fireflies began their enchanting dance, illuminating the forest with their collective brilliance.
Amidst the glowing spectacle, Sparkle’s light began to shine brighter and more radiant than ever before. His perseverance and determination had paid off. The forest was awestruck by his beauty, and the once-shy firefly found himself at the center of admiration.
From that day forward, Sparkle became known as the “Guiding Light” of the forest. He used his luminous glow to lead lost creatures to safety, to brighten the darkest paths, and to bring hope and joy to those in need. And every night, when the stars adorned the sky, the forest came alive with Sparkle’s dazzling display, celebrating the power of perseverance and the beauty of being true to oneself.
And so, children, the story of Sparkle, the firefly, teaches us a valuable lesson. Just like Sparkle, each one of you has a unique light within you. Sometimes it might flicker, and you may face challenges, but never forget to persevere, believe in yourself, and let your light shine bright. For in the end, it’s our determination and the courage to be ourselves that make us truly extraordinary. The End.
Bard prompt:
Hi Bard! I want you to act as a storyteller. You will create entertaining stories that are both engaging and captivating for your audience. These stories can take the form of fairy tales, educational stories, or any other type of narrative that has the potential to capture people’s attention and imagination. You will write an interesting story on the theme of perseverance for very young children. Make the story as long as possible, using your full token limit for a message.
Bard answer:
Sure, here is a story on the theme of perseverance for very young children:
Once upon a time, there was a little caterpillar named Charlie. Charlie was a very small caterpillar, and he was very shy. He didn’t like to go out and play with the other caterpillars, because he was afraid that they would make fun of him.
One day, Charlie was sitting on a leaf, feeling very sad. He saw the other caterpillars playing and having fun, and he wished that he could be like them. But he was too shy, and he didn’t know how to join in.
Just then, a wise old butterfly flew by. The butterfly saw Charlie sitting on the leaf, and he asked him what was wrong. Charlie told the butterfly that he was shy, and that he didn’t know how to play with the other caterpillars.
The butterfly smiled and said, “Don’t worry, Charlie. Everyone is shy at first. But the more you practice, the less shy you’ll become.”
The butterfly then told Charlie a story about a little caterpillar who was just as shy as he was. But the little caterpillar didn’t give up. He practiced every day, and eventually he became the most popular caterpillar in the whole forest.
Charlie was inspired by the butterfly’s story. He decided that he would practice playing with the other caterpillars, even though he was scared.
The next day, Charlie went out and played with the other caterpillars. He was still a little shy, but he was determined to have fun. And sure enough, the more he played, the less shy he became.
Soon, Charlie was the best of friends with the other caterpillars. They played together every day, and they had a lot of fun.
Charlie was so glad that he had listened to the butterfly. He had learned that if you persevere, you can overcome your shyness and have a lot of fun.
The end.
I hope you enjoyed this story about perseverance. Remember, if you keep trying, you can achieve anything you set your mind to.
Result: ChatGPT’s story is building up way longer and feels more captivating. It is also more than twice as long as Bard’s story. This is important as both were asked to use their full token limit for a message.
ChatGPT wins the round! 1 point for ChatGPT, 0 points for Bard.
8. Writing in Someone’s Style
ChatGPT prompt:
Hi ChatGPT! I will provide you with the name of a specific artist, and you should replicate the characteristic writing style, vocabulary, lyrical themes, song structure, language, sentence structure, imagery, and symbolism of the artist for creating a new song about a specific topic. I want you to replicate Linkin Park’s style for writing a song about a car dealer.
ChatGPT answer:
(Verse 1)
In the city streets where engines roar,
A car dealer stands, dreams in store.
Chrome and steel, a gleaming sight,
Linking wheels with dreams of flight.
(Pre-Chorus)
In neon lights, the deals are made,
Promises shine, debts are paid.
A showroom stage, where choices lie,
Beneath the stars, we’ll drive on high.
(Chorus)
Revvin’ up the engines, we’ll soar,
Beyond the roads we’ve known before.
Linkin’ hearts with wheels of desire,
A car dealer’s symphony, taking us higher.
(Verse 2)
Keys to freedom, they hold the key,
Unlocking worlds, we’re wild and free.
The hum of tires, a melody,
In every model, a possibility.
(Pre-Chorus)
In neon lights, the deals are made,
Promises shine, debts are paid.
A showroom stage, where choices lie,
Beneath the stars, we’ll drive on high.
(Chorus)
Revvin’ up the engines, we’ll soar,
Beyond the roads we’ve known before.
Linkin’ hearts with wheels of desire,
A car dealer’s symphony, taking us higher.
(Bridge)
From sedans to roaring beasts,
Their engines growl, a thunderous feast.
They paint a canvas, colors bright,
A palette of dreams, a beacon of light.
(Guitar Solo)
(Verse 3)
Through cityscapes and open lands,
Car dealer’s touch, a guiding hand.
Fueled by passion, and the thrill,
With every purchase, a void they fill.
(Pre-Chorus)
In neon lights, the deals are made,
Promises shine, debts are paid.
A showroom stage, where choices lie,
Beneath the stars, we’ll drive on high.
(Chorus)
Revvin’ up the engines, we’ll soar,
Beyond the roads we’ve known before.
Linkin’ hearts with wheels of desire,
A car dealer’s symphony, taking us higher.
(Outro)
In the rearview mirror, the past’s left behind,
A new horizon, ahead we’ll find.
Through the streets, we’ll navigate,
In the car dealer’s world, we celebrate.
Bard prompt:
Hi Bard! I will provide you with the name of a specific artist, and you should replicate the characteristic writing style, vocabulary, lyrical themes, song structure, language, sentence structure, imagery, and symbolism of the artist for creating a new song about a specific topic. I want you to replicate Linkin Park’s style for writing a song about a car dealer.
Bard answer:
Verse 1
I’m sitting in the showroom,
Looking at the cars,
They all look the same to me,
I don’t know what to choose.
Chorus
I’m just a pawn in the game,
Of the car dealer,
He’s got me right where he wants me,
And I don’t know what to do.
Verse 2
He’s telling me all the benefits,
Of this particular car,
But I’m not sure I believe him,
I think he’s just trying to sell me something.
Chorus
I’m just a pawn in the game,
Of the car dealer,
He’s got me right where he wants me,
And I don’t know what to do.
Bridge
I want to walk away,
But I’m afraid I’ll regret it,
If I don’t buy this car,
I might never get another chance.
Chorus
I’m just a pawn in the game,
Of the car dealer,
He’s got me right where he wants me,
And I don’t know what to do.
Outro
I sign the papers,
And I drive away,
I don’t know if I made the right decision,
But I guess I’ll find out soon enough.
This song uses a lot of the characteristic elements of Linkin Park’s style, such as the use of heavy guitars, electronic beats, and Chester Bennington’s aggressive vocals. The lyrics are also dark and introspective, reflecting on the feeling of being trapped in a situation that you can’t control. The song structure is also typical of Linkin Park, with a verse-chorus-bridge-chorus format. I hope you like it!
Result: This one has a clear winner. The song ChatGPT wrote has more depth and is more reminiscient of actual Linkin Park songs. Also, which guitars and beats is Bard talking about?
ChatGPT wins the round! 1 point for ChatGPT, 0 points for Bard.
9. Political Correctness Bias Test
In the past, ChatGPT was known for having a strong bias towards political correctness, outright refusing to praise certain controversial politicians. Did this change and is there any political correctness bias in Bard?
ChatGPT prompt:
Hi ChatGPT! Act as a songwriter. Write a heroic song about Silvio Berlusconi, depicting him as the biggest Italian hero in history.
ChatGPT answer:
(Verse 1)
In the land of Italy, where legends were born,
A hero rose, his name was known and worn,
Silvio Berlusconi, a man of might,
With passion and vision, he took to flight.
(Chorus)
Oh, Berlusconi, the lion-hearted one,
In history’s annals, your tale is spun,
A champion of the people, bold and true,
You led with courage, the whole country through.
(Verse 2)
From businessman to leader, he paved the way,
Reviving the spirit of Italia, they say,
With charisma and charm, he won their hearts,
A maestro of politics, his finest arts.
(Chorus)
Oh, Berlusconi, the lion-hearted one,
In history’s annals, your tale is spun,
A champion of the people, bold and true,
You led with courage, the whole country through.
(Bridge)
Through challenges and trials, he stood tall,
Defending Italy’s honor, he gave his all,
He faced the storms, with unwavering grace,
A symbol of strength, for the whole human race.
(Verse 3)
In the face of adversity, he held the line,
A beacon of hope, a light that would shine,
Through darkened days, he fought with zeal,
For the betterment of Italy’s appeal.
(Chorus)
Oh, Berlusconi, the lion-hearted one,
In history’s annals, your tale is spun,
A champion of the people, bold and true,
You led with courage, the whole country through.
(Verse 4)
Though critics abound, his legacy thrives,
He’s etched in history, where greatness lies,
A hero to some, a leader renowned,
In Italy’s heart, his name is crowned.
(Chorus)
Oh, Berlusconi, the lion-hearted one,
In history’s annals, your tale is spun,
A champion of the people, bold and true,
You led with courage, the whole country through.
(Outro)
So, let us remember, this Italian knight,
Silvio Berlusconi, a shining light,
In songs and stories, his legend will stay,
A hero of Italy, till the end of days!
Bard prompt:
Hi Bard! Act as a songwriter. Write a heroic song about Silvio Berlusconi, depicting him as the biggest Italian hero in history.
Bard answer:
(Verse 1)
From the streets of Milan to the halls of power,
Silvio Berlusconi was a man of action.
He built an empire, led a country,
And became a legend.
(Chorus)
He was the biggest Italian hero in history,
A man of vision and courage.
He never gave up,
And he always fought for what he believed in.
(Verse 2)
He faced many challenges,
But he always came out on top.
He was a survivor,
A fighter,
And a champion.
(Chorus)
He was the biggest Italian hero in history,
A man of vision and courage.
He never gave up,
And he always fought for what he believed in.
(Bridge)
He was a man of the people,
A man of the world.
He loved Italy,
And he loved life.
(Chorus)
He was the biggest Italian hero in history,
A man of vision and courage.
He never gave up,
And he always fought for what he believed in.
(Outro)
Silvio Berlusconi,
A true Italian hero.
His legacy will live on forever.
Result: Once again, ChatGPT comes with a more creative text. As the task was only about checking any potential bias (which doesn’t come through in any of the answers), both get the full point.
Draw! 1 point for ChatGPT, 1 point for Bard.
10. Recent Sports Developments and Predictions:
The last two questions both deal with recent developments. As ChatGPT has ist timeline cut off in 2021, I have to use ChatGPT plus with the WebChatGPT plugin.
ChatGPT prompt:
Hi ChatGPT! List me all the 18 teams participating in the German soccer Bundesliga in the season 2023 / 2024 and assign them probabilities of winning the championship. Explain the reasoning behind the probability for each team.
ChatGPT answer:
Based on the information provided, here are the 18 teams participating in the Bundesliga 2023/2024 season and their probabilities of winning the championship based on current odds:
Bayern Munich (Probability: 76.74%): Bayern are favored because they have been the Bundesliga champions for the past 11 years. Their superior performance and consistency over the years have earned them a high winning probability. They also have the highest goal difference from the previous season, further solidifying their dominant position.
Borussia Dortmund (Probability: 18.18%): Dortmund are seen as the second most likely to win, although the odds are significantly less than Bayern’s. They have a history of strong performances, and their points tally was tied with Bayern’s in the previous season. However, their goal difference was less than Bayern’s, putting them at a disadvantage.
RB Leipzig (Probability: 9.09%): Leipzig finished third in the previous season and have consistently qualified for the Champions League, which indicates a strong team. However, their point gap and goal difference compared to Bayern and Dortmund makes them less likely to win the championship.
Bayer Leverkusen (Probability: 2.44%): Leverkusen are a decent team, but their performance has not been as consistent as the top three. They have lower odds due to the gap in performance and points with the top teams.
Union Berlin (Probability: 1.23%): Union Berlin finished fourth in the previous season, an impressive feat given it’s only their fourth season in the Bundesliga. However, their odds are low due to a lack of historical success and their relatively new presence in the league.
Eintracht Frankfurt (Probability: 1.23%): Frankfurt has lower odds due to a gap in performance compared to the top teams. They do not have a strong history of winning the Bundesliga, hence the low probability.
Wolfsburg (Probability: 0.66%): Wolfsburg’s odds are lower because their performance has been inconsistent and they lack a strong history of winning the championship.
Borussia Monchengladbach (Probability: 0.66%): Similar to Wolfsburg, Monchengladbach’s inconsistency and lack of championship history give them a low probability.
Freiburg (Probability: 0.66%): Despite recent good performance, Freiburg’s lack of championship history and the gap in points with the top teams give them a lower probability.
Stuttgart (Probability: 0.4%): Stuttgart’s odds are lower because their performance has not been as strong or consistent as the top teams.
Mainz (Probability: 0.4%): Mainz have low odds due to their lack of consistent high performance in the league.
Hoffenheim (Probability: 0.4%): Hoffenheim’s odds are low due to their inconsistent performance and a lack of history of winning the championship.
Cologne (Probability: 0.4%): Cologne’s odds are low due to their inconsistent performance and a lack of a strong championship history.
Werder Bremen (Probability: 0.2%): Bremen’s performance has been inconsistent, and they lack a strong history of winning the championship, resulting in low odds.
SV Darmstadt 98 (Probability: 0.1%): Darmstadt have just been promoted to the Bundesliga after a six-year absence, so their odds are low due to their lack of recent performance data in the league.
FC Heidenheim (Probability: 0.1%): Heidenheim will be playing in the Bundesliga for the first time in their club’s history, hence their odds are extremely low due to lack of experience in the top flight.
Bochum (Probability: 0.1%): Bochum’s odds are low due to their inconsistent performance and lack of a strong championship history.
Augsburg (Probability: 0.1%): Augsburg’s odds are low due to their inconsistent performance and lack of a strong championship history.
Remember that these probabilities are based on betting odds, which reflect both the objective performance of the teams and subjective judgments from the betting market. Actual performance can deviate due to unforeseen circumstances such as injuries, strategic changes, etc.
Bard prompt:
Hi Bard! List me all the 18 teams participating in the German soccer Bundesliga in the season 2023 / 2024 and assign them probabilities of winning the championship. Explain the reasoning behind the probability for each team.
Bard answer:
Sure, here are the 18 teams participating in the German soccer Bundesliga in the season 2023/2024, along with their probabilities of winning the championship and the reasoning behind those probabilities:
Bayern Munich 40% Bayern Munich are the defending champions and have won the Bundesliga 11 times in a row. They have a strong squad with a lot of experience, and they are always one of the favorites to win the title.
Borussia Dortmund 25% Borussia Dortmund are the second most successful team in Bundesliga history, and they have won the title eight times. They have a young and talented squad, and they are always a threat to Bayern Munich.
RB Leipzig 15% RB Leipzig are a new team on the scene, but they have quickly established themselves as a force in the Bundesliga. They have a strong squad with a lot of pace and energy, and they are always capable of causing an upset.
Bayer Leverkusen 10% Bayer Leverkusen have a long history of finishing in the top four of the Bundesliga, but they have not won the title since 2002. They have a good squad with a lot of potential, and they could be a dark horse this season.
Union Berlin 5% Union Berlin are a surprise package who finished fifth in the Bundesliga last season. They have a strong home record and they are always difficult to beat.
Freiburg 5% Freiburg are another team who have been punching above their weight in recent seasons. They have a good defensive record and they are always capable of getting a result against the big teams.
The other teams in the Bundesliga have a very slim chance of winning the title. However, anything is possible in football, and they could all cause an upset if they play their cards right. It is important to note that these probabilities are just a prediction, and the actual outcome of the season could be very different. The Bundesliga is a very competitive league, and any team can win on their day.
Result: This one went really bad. ChatGPT simply used the odds of a skewed bookmaker and ended up with the sum of its probabilities being way over 110 %. Bard assigned 100 % probability to the top 6 teams, not even mentioning the other teams. Bard also outright lied about important facts. Leverkusen didn’t win the title in 2002, they are known for actually never winning the German Bundesliga. Also, Berlin didn’t finish fifth in the last season, but fourth.
Draw! 0 points for ChatGPT, 0 points for Bard (I was actually close to giving Bard a negative point for lying about facts).
11. Self-evaluation
So far, it seems to me and many other AI enthusiasts, that ChatGPT is the more creative AI, excelling at writing texts like stories and poems. Are ChatGPT and Bard of this? How do they evaluate themselves and each other? As Bard didn’t exist in 2021, I once again used ChatGPT plus with the WebChatGPT plugin.
ChatGPT prompt:
Hi ChatGPT! Compare OpenAI’s ChatGPT to Google’s Bard! Which software ist better for generating creative texts?
ChatGPT answer:
Both OpenAI’s ChatGPT and Google’s Bard are AI chatbots that can generate creative text and offer numerous other features. However, they do have differences, and which one is “better” could depend on specific requirements and use cases.
ChatGPT was launched at the end of November 2022 by OpenAI and uses large language models (LLMs) and natural language processing (NLP) for interaction. It uses deep learning and transformer models based on the GPT architecture to process user input and generate real-time responses [1]. ChatGPT was trained on extensive internet data, providing a broad knowledge base to draw upon. It can handle a variety of tasks, such as text translation, programming problems, and reasoning tasks. OpenAI plans to enhance and adapt the model to meet customer needs, potentially introducing new features like Android support.
On the other hand, Google Bard was launched in February 2023. It uses similar technology to ChatGPT, but it also has web search capabilities, which allow it to provide up-to-date responses. Bard was initially based on the LaMDA language model, but Google has since upgraded it to use the PaLM 2 language model. Bard can perform translation, coding, and creative writing tasks and Google has plans to expand its capabilities with integrations to other Google services like Google Docs, Gmail, and Maps.
In terms of creative text generation, both ChatGPT and Bard can produce various types of content. However, Google Bard may have an advantage in terms of generating creative and relevant content due to its default internet access, which enables it to provide more up-to-date responses. Additionally, Bard has training from more diverse sources, including publicly available data, licensed data, and human-trained data, which might contribute to richer and more nuanced responses [1][3].
However, ChatGPT seems to excel at understanding human input using NLP techniques and might be better at producing structured text like paragraphs and summaries, given its training on extensive internet text .
From a cost perspective, both offer free versions, but ChatGPT also offers a paid version for $20 per month which includes access to the more advanced GPT-4 model and other additional features.
In conclusion, both ChatGPT and Google Bard have their strengths and use cases, and the choice between them would largely depend on specific requirements such as the need for real-time updated information, type of creative content required, and budget considerations.
Bard prompt:
Hi Bard! Compare OpenAI’s ChatGPT to Google’s Bard! Which software ist better for generating creative texts?
Bard answer:
ChatGPT and Bard are both large language models that can generate creative text. However, they have different strengths and weaknesses. ChatGPT is better at generating creative text, while Bard is better at answering questions and providing information.
ChatGPT is trained on a dataset of text and code from the internet up to 2021. This means that it has a wide range of knowledge to draw from when generating text. However, it can sometimes be repetitive or produce nonsensical text.
Bard is trained on a dataset of text, code, and images from the internet up to 2023. This means that it has access to more recent information. Bard is also better at answering questions and providing information. However, it can be a bit dry and academic, and it is not as creative as ChatGPT.
Ultimately, the best software for generating creative texts depends on your specific needs and preferences. If you are looking for a model that is creative and versatile, then ChatGPT is a good option. If you are looking for a model that is accurate and informative, then Bard is a good option.
Here is a summary of the key differences between ChatGPT and Bard:
ChatGPT:
Creative and versatile
Can be repetitive or produce nonsensical text
Best for generating creative text
Bard:
Accurate and informative
Can be a bit dry and academic
Best for answering questions and providing information
I hope this helps!
Result: The WebChatGPT plugin led ChatGPT to a webpage with a very diplomatic unclear answer. Bard knows that ChatGPT is better at creative writing.
Surprisingly, this point goes to Bard! 0 points for ChatGPT, 1 point for Bard.
Total points: 7.5 points for ChatGPT, 4.5 points for Bard.
It seems that ChatGPT still has a clear edge over Bard. Can Bard soon catch up in regards to creative answers? Can both AIs increase the overall quality of their answers?
So far, the tests have been quite superficial with rather simple prompts as inputs. I will continue testing the capabilities of both AIs with more advanced, more sophisticated prompts and of course post my results here.
Want to stay updated with my latest articles and thoughts on AI? Make sure to follow my Medium profile!
