Generalists: the Heaven and Hell of being a Specialist in Nothing
What are the benefits and drawbacks of being a generalist?
Or, as the overused pun: is it a Stairway to Heaven or a Highway to Hell?
This journey starts in Heaven. You’re a young professional, excited about starting your career. If you didn’t have a clear passion, you probably chose a major like Business, Economics, or Engineering — solid choices for a stable career.
Heaven: The Upside of Being a Generalist
At the start of your career, you’re at a crossroads. Each path — Business, Economics, Engineering — is a different adventure full of chances and choices.
This is the best part of being a generalist — you have so many options and the freedom to try different things.
Wide Open Choices
As a generalist, you’re not stuck in one lane. Your education hasn’t locked you into one specific job.
Instead, it’s opened doors to different roles. You could jump into managing projects, studying market trends, or even working on product development.
Ready for Anything
The world of work changes fast, and companies love people who can handle different tasks.
As a generalist, you can change and grow with the job, which is a big plus in industries that are always moving and shaking.
This idea is broadly defended in the book Range: How Generalists Triumph in a Specialized World, by David Epstein.
Meeting All Kinds of People
Being a generalist means you meet people from all sorts of jobs. Even if you are not an extrovert, as explained in The Introvert’s Edge to Networking.
This networking can lead to unexpected changes, partnerships, and new ideas that specialists might not have.
Purgatory: The Crossroads of Choice
After the excitement of the beginning, you enter a stage I like to call Purgatory.
It’s when you start wondering whether to stick as a generalist or dive deep into a specialty.
This is a tricky spot, filled with doubts and big decisions.
The Big Question: To Specialize or Not?
You’ve tasted different roles and skills, but now there’s pressure. Do you keep exploring various fields, or do you pick one and become an expert? It’s a tough choice.
On one hand, specialization could mean becoming a go-to person in one area. On the other, staying broad keeps your options open.
Feeling Lost in the Fog
This stage can feel foggy. You’ve got skills and experience, but not in one specific area.
This can make you feel lost, wondering if you’re moving forward or just floating around.
Decision Time: What’s Your Next Move?
Purgatory is all about making a choice. Do you double down on being a generalist, enjoying the variety and flexibility? Or do you start focusing on a particular area, aiming to become an expert?
Now, let’s delve into the challenges.
Hell: The Downsides of Being a Generalist
Finally, we reach the part of the journey I call Hell.
It’s where the lack of specialization can feel like a curse. Here, the challenges and disadvantages of being a generalist become all too clear.
Jack of All Trades, Master of None?
The biggest struggle? Feeling like you’re good at many things but not great at anything. This can hit hard, especially when you see specialists who excel in their niche.
You might feel like you’re always catching up, never quite mastering one thing. This sense of inadequacy can be tough to shake off.
Lost in the Crowd
In some industries, being a specialist is key to standing out. As a generalist, you might feel lost in the sea of professionals, struggling to make your mark.
Without a specific expertise to your name, it can be harder to get noticed or valued.
The Overwhelm of Options
Having many interests and skills is great, but it can also be overwhelming. Deciding what to focus on each day can be a challenge.
You might end up spreading yourself too thin, trying to keep up with everything.
The Doubt of Self-Perception
As you mentioned, there’s also the self-perception of failure. Knowing a bit about everything can lead to doubts about your actual competence.
It’s a mental battle, questioning if you’re genuinely skilled or just superficially involved in many areas.
Conclusion: Embracing Your Generalist Journey
As our journey from Heaven through Purgatory and into Hell concludes, it’s clear that being a generalist has its ups and downs.
But here’s the thing: every career path has its challenges, and being a generalist is no exception.
Finding Your Strength in Flexibility
The key is to find strength in your versatility. The world is changing fast, and the ability to adapt and learn is more valuable than ever.
As a generalist, you have a unique toolkit that can be your greatest asset.
Crafting Your Unique Path
Remember, your career is uniquely yours. Whether you choose to specialize or continue as a generalist, what matters most is how you leverage your skills and experiences.
It’s about finding what works for you and using it to carve out your own success.
Celebrating Your Journey
Finally, celebrate the journey you’re on. Each step, whether in Heaven, Purgatory, or Hell, has shaped you into the professional you are today. Embrace the lessons learned and look forward to the opportunities that lie ahead.
In the end, being a generalist isn’t about fitting into a specific box. It’s about creating a box that fits you.
Read Also:
- The boring part of working with Data Analysis — and that no one talks about
- Using pandas.cut() in Python for Data Analysis: Creating Number and Date Intervals
- My Lazy Article about Deep Fakes and Misinformation using ChatGPT
Support the page:
- Buy me a Coffee (or tea, up to you)
