First vs FirstOrDefault, Single vs SingleOrDefault: A High-level Look

Raphael Anyanwu
3 min readNov 22, 2023

LINQ (Language-Integrated Query) is a powerful feature in C# that allows developers to perform queries on various data sources using a syntax similar to SQL.

Among the vast number of Linq methods, it is essential to understand the differences between similar-sounding methods, especially when it comes to synchronous and asynchronous variants.

In this article, we’ll delve into the differences between First, FirstAsync, FirstOrDefault, FirstOrDefaultAsync, Single, SingleAsync, SingleOrDefault, and SingleOrDefaultAsync.

First vs. FirstAsync:

  • First: This method returns the first element of a sequence that satisfies a specified condition or the first element if no condition is provided.
  • FirstAsync: The asynchronous counterpart of First. It is used when working with asynchronous data sources or operations, providing better responsiveness in applications.

First and FirstAsync throws an exception if no matching element is found.

Best Suited For: Use when expecting at least one matching element, and an exception is appropriate when there’s none.

FirstOrDefault vs. FirstOrDefaultAsync:

  • FirstOrDefault: Similar to First, but it returns the default value of the type if no elements match the specified condition.
  • FirstOrDefaultAsync: The asynchronous version of FirstOrDefault. It is useful when dealing with asynchronous operations, preventing blocking a thread.

FirstOrDefault and FirstOrDefaultAsync returns the default value of the type if no matching element is found.

Best Suited For: Suitable when it’s acceptable to receive a default value when there’s no match.

Single vs. SingleAsync:

  • Single: Returns the only element of a sequence that satisfies a specified condition. If no such element exists or more than one element matches the condition, an exception is thrown.
  • SingleAsync: The asynchronous variant of Single, suitable for asynchronous scenarios. It ensures the responsive behavior of the application by not blocking the thread during the operation.

Single and SingleAsync throws an exception if no matching element is found or more than one element matches.

Best Suited For: Use when expecting exactly one matching element, and an exception is appropriate otherwise. An account entity can be a use case for these operations when we are sure and we expect only one account to match an account number condition.

SingleOrDefault vs. SingleOrDefaultAsync:

  • SingleOrDefault: Similar to Single, but it returns the default value of the type if no elements match the condition. If more than one element matches, an exception is thrown.
  • SingleOrDefaultAsync: The asynchronous version of SingleOrDefault. It's beneficial in scenarios where responsiveness is crucial, preventing the UI from freezing during asynchronous operations.

Returns the default value of the type if no matching element is found, throws an exception if more than one element matches.

Best Suited For: Suitable when a default value is acceptable for zero matches, and an exception is appropriate for multiple matches.

Conclusion:

Understanding the differences between these LINQ methods and their asynchronous counterparts is crucial for writing efficient C# code.

Choosing the appropriate method depends on the specific requirements of your application, the nature of the data source, and the need for synchronous or asynchronous processing.

By grasping the distinctions outlined in this article, you can now make informed decisions when implementing queries in your C# applications, ensuring optimal performance and responsiveness.

If you found this helpful, please clap and follow for more.

--

--