I’m trying to be as polite as possible not to offend you, at any point you feel those questions from me are offending, pls let me know and I will stop arguing.
Of course you can express offense by an obvious stereotype. I am not challenging that. I am not questioning any of your feelings.
I am sorry if I was not able to express myself clearly as english is not my primary language.
“ Please point me the specific conceptual and/or methodological errors in those ORIGINAL papers, and please not just cite some other papers that came to a different conclusion.”
Do I understand correctly that you are implying that the studies referenced in the memo were not “actual” scientific research? If that is the case, could you provide the evidence of this? As I am not an expert in this field (are you?) I would not be able dismiss a cited research simply because it does not align with my beliefs. But I am willing to…