The Lady of Shalott: A Psychoanalytic Odyssey Through Myth and Mind
Exploring the Unconscious, Archetypes, and Mythological Parallels in Tennyson’s Timeless Tale
Introduction
Lady of Shalott can be considered an incredibly hypnotising and ravishingly captivating poem and also one of the best-known works of Lord Alfred Tennyson. Not only does it delve into the life of our beloved Lady of Shalott and attempt to express explicitly the circumstances in which she is struggling in pursuit of a way to embrace her passion and vivacity, but it is also admissibly applicable to many prevailing and commendably prevalent psychoanalytic scrutinies with reference to the female psyche. The poem is comprised of an amusingly alluring plot, many remarkably vigorous and momentous symbolisms, an elegantly and meticulously gripping depiction of characters, and more importantly, a fascinatingly spellbinding psychoanalytical scrutiny. This article will unambiguously and explicitly scrutinise and evaluate the plot, symbolism, and psychoanalytic viewpoint.
Summary
The poem inaugurates through the medium of elucidating a river that flows down to Camelot, traversing the fields of barley and rye. On the island in the river is a toweringly erect tower, and within it resides the lady of Shalott. She is noticeably detached and segregated from the world and its inhabitants, and the local farmers and harvesters, who rarely and sporadically spot and behold the dim light of her sight which dispiritedly, desperately, hopelessly, haplessly, helplessly, starkly, and darkly glows upon them, recognise her as a nymph or an enchantress.
The Lady’s Weaving
The lady devotes her dawn-to-dark to weaving her mythically magical web with convolutedly sophisticated patterning. She regards and monitors the world indirectly with the help of a mirror, observing the shadows and duplicates of the world that include lovers, knights, market girls, and an abbot riding to Camelot. Notwithstanding her engaged and engrossed weaving, she grows enervated and incapacitated. She voices and discloses her annoyance and dissatisfaction with regard to her disheartening impotence and incompetence to get in on the act and have a hand in the world she regards and contemplates. She apperceives being at bay on the grounds that she feels uptight and jittery at the hand of the calamity and the colourless continuance of her existence. The sole companionship in her unaccompanied and solitary reality is a deceased cast back or impression of the real world in the mirror, which provides a fragmentarily inadequate and pervertedly distorted image of the world outside.
The Debut of Sir Lancelot
One day, the Lady, at an unanticipatedly precipitous moment, detects a knight, Sir Lancelot, riding by the river. His ravishingly and glitteringly dazzling armour, his broad and hard shield, his startlingly, strikingly, and seductively mighty sword, his lustrously sparkling helmet with the exquisitely crafted plume, adorned with feathers of the finest silkiness and subtle sheen, gracefully arching in a display of delicate splendour blooms in the sunlight, and he sings with his husky voice as he rides. Lancelot’s omnipresence captivates the Lady. His vividly vigorous presence is marvellous and sharply contrasting with her cloudy, leafy, and shady existence. Affectedly overwhelmed by the energetic and forceful fascination and aspiration to experience life directly, the Lady transgresses the boundaries of her curse. She ceases her weaving and looks out of the window towards Camelot. As she observes Lancelot, the mirror bursts vigorously and riotously, warning her that the curse has been activated. The web she was weaving flies out of the window, and she feels a sense of doom and gloom upon her as she realises the consequences of her actions.
The Lady’s Adventure and Death
Strongly determined to face her fate, the Lady flees her tower and spots a navigable and seaworthy boat on the riverbank. She seeks a way to write her name on the boat’s prow. Once she has done so, she lies down in the boat and surrenders herself over to the torrential spate of rippling streams, allowing it to carry her downstream towards Camelot.
Freudian Perspective
In the context of Freudian analysis, the Lady of Shalott’s quagmire manifests the strainingly stretching tension betwixt suppressed and repressed desires and dominantly governing forces of the superego. The erect and sublime tower serves as a remarkably stunning and impressive metaphor representing her carnal, erotic, sensual, sexual, or libidinal whims and impulses and also the subconscious and unconscious yearnings, aspirations, and hankerings she is driven or compelled to deny.
1. Repression, Suppression, and Seclusion
The Lady’s incarceration or confinement can be analysed and deciphered as a display of weighty and intense psychological and subconscious subjugation and suppression. Her isolation and feeling of being segregated from the world and its bodies can be perceived as the symbol of a pullback from the uncanny world and a regression inwards, towards the shelter of her wishes and desires. This can reflect or indicate the ubiquitous and ever-present effect and control of the superego which imposingly implements collective conventions together with ethical principles. The spell that obliges her to lingeringly remain and endure the confinement in the mountainous tower until she renounces the fantasy of indirect participation and interaction with life outside can indicate a punitive and disciplinary mechanism of her unconscious and subconscious mind chastising, punishing, sanctioning her for rebelling against these repressive boundaries.
2. The Mirror as a Symbol
The mirror, via which the Lady perceives the outside world, serves as a compelling representation of the unconscious. It can indicate the projection of her suppressed and restrained yearnings and wishes and marks a romantically glorified, even though imaginary, version of actuality or the real world. Her longing towards the idea of breaking free from her gloomy and shadowy survival and confronting the cosmos without intermediaries can be perceived as an attempt to reconcile and harmonise the primal instinct of her id with the binding and confining orders of the moral and ethical critic of her superego
3. Oedipal Complex
An analytical scrutiny through the perspective of the Oedipal complex can potentially reveal that her fascination and adoration towards Sir Lancelot signifies a transference or projection of suppressed and repressed yearnings and desires upon the silhouette of romantically idealised masculinity. The Lady’s tragic demise of death upon her as a result of glimpsing Sir Lancelot can be regarded and recognised as the punitive consequence of her transgression against the internally embedded authority of the superego.
Lacanian Perspective
Through the lens of the Lacanian perspective, the Lady’s life and disastrously calamitous destiny can be thoroughly and precisely analysed and studied by way of the constructs and frameworks of the Real, the Imaginary, and the Symbolic orders in conjunction with Lacan’s mirror stage theory.
1. Mirror Stage and the Imaginary Order
The Lady’s monotonously sombre and gloomy existence within the confines and boundaries of the tower, observed exclusively throughout the mirror embodies and exemplifies Lacan’s mirror stage. This phase signifies the development and establishment of the ego through images, illusions, depictions, reflections, and deceptions, wherein the Lady remains entangled within the imaginary order. Her desire to face and live through the tangible world signifies a significantly profound desire to transcend this realm and confront the Real; an encounter that she is sorrowfully and tragically ill-prepared to face.
2. The Symbolic Order and the Curse
The spell or curse symbolises the authority and the big stick of the Symbolic order, the realm of collective and societal law and verbal and syntactic structure that rules over her existence. Her solitude and seclusion can be a direct outcome or consequence of her inability to wholly participate and interact with this order or structure. The lady’s concluding withdrawal from the towering tower of confinement and the ensuing downfall symbolise her confrontation with the Real, an unsettlingly chaotic pressure that challenges the illusory and the metaphorical constructs within which she has been contained in a restrained manner.
3. Desire and the Object a
Lacan’s concept of the objet a — the intangible object-cause of desire — demonstrates awareness-spreading perception and insight into the Lady’s fascination and obsession regarding Sir Lancelot. He signifies the unreachable object of her desire, driving her towards a heartbreaking finale. Her endless quest concerning this exemplarily perfect ideal indicates the fundamentally intrinsic class in between aspiration and limitation dictated by the Symbolic order.
Jungian Perspective
Through the highly analytical angle of a Jungian lens, the Lady of Shalott’s tale unravels a weightily significant analysis of archetypes, the process of individuation, and the collective unconscious.
1. Archetypes
The Lady personifies the archetype of the “Innocent” or “Eternal Feminine,” depicting a romantically elevated and celestially heavenly feminine principle. Her private confinement synchronises with the archetype of the “Isolated Maiden” or “Hermit,” whose being is an accumulation of reflection and aesthetic innocence, unengaged and disconnected from mundane affairs. Sir Lancelot, on the contrary, embodies the archetypal “Hero” or “Knight,” and personification of absolute perfection in terms of glorified and idealised masculinity and extrinsic satisfaction and fulfilment.
2. The Collective Unconscious
The Lady’s troublesome dilemma is harmonious with motifs and concepts profoundly and significantly ingrained in the collective unconscious, such as yearning, seclusion, and calamitous destiny. The Lady’s malediction and her later tragic mortality can stand for a conflict with the archetypal personifications with which she has been unable to integrate successfully.
3. Individuation
The Lady’s tale can be regarded in the capacity of a theatrically emotional portrayal of the individuation and self-realisation process, in the context of which she struggles in pursuit of a means to attain psychological completeness. Her survival through life within the towering tower signifies shattered personhood, distanced from a thorough self-fulfilment and external actuality and existence. Her ultimately inevitable departure and tragically heartbreaking passing symbolise a saddening yet touching effort to harmonisingly and settlingly bring together and reconcile her conflicts within with the outer world, climaxing in the form of a manifestation of self-discovery through the clashing conflict of her profoundest desires and essence-related phobias.
Mythological References
1. Plato’s Allegory of the Cave
Plato’s allegory of the cave explores the concept of illumination and the passage of transformation from unawareness to awareness. In the metaphorical allegory of Plato’s cave, people who are imprisoned in the cave recognise and observe only shadows or, in other words, reflecting silhouettes of things projected upon a wall, misconceivingly interpreting these gloomy reflections for reality. The Lady of Shalott’s restricted and isolated confinement in the towering tower aligns with the captives’ state and circumstances.
Psychoanalytic Connection
The monotonously confined life of the noblewoman in our story which is limited to observing the world solely via a mirror is in fact comparable to the reflecting gloomy projections of entities shown upon a wall in the cave. Her inadequate and misleading observation of the outside world is filtered and moderated by the mirror, embodying a twistedly misshapen and deformed perception of actuality. Her eventual wish to liberate herself from this cursed confinement and interact with the world without intermediaries can be seen as a pursuit of a way out of the illusion of the Imaginary order and face the Real, analogous to the quest of cave prisoners towards awakening and genuine awareness.
2. The Epic of Gilgamesh
Through the Epic of Gilgamesh, we get to see the protagonist Gilgamesh commence a quest for everlasting perpetuity, only to tackle the constraints and boundaries of fleshly life and the inescapability of death. The Lady of Shalott’s pursuit of self-determination and her heartbreaking demise can be placed side by side with Gilgamesh’s expedition.
Psychoanalytic Connection
Gilgamesh’s quest can be regarded as a pursuit of significance, purpose, and self-realisation in the presence of being-related confines. in a correspondingly comparable manner, the Lady’s calamitous predestination denotes her conflicting battle versus the boundaries inflicted by her suppressed yearnings and the journey in pursuit of a more complete interaction and participation with existence. Her final passing upon shattering the jinx indicates a significant existential challenge, alike Gilgamesh’s acceptance of the finitude of the fleshly existence and the search for a comprehension beyond the deceiving delusions of her antecedent incarceration.
3. Orpheus and Eurydice
In the story of Orpheus and Eurydice, Orpheus dares to embark upon a journey into the underworld to rescue his dearly cherished and loved Eurydice but struggles and fails to take her with himself out of the underworld when he glances back at her prior to their complete departure. This myth addresses the concept of desire, the limits and borders of the underworld or, in other words, the unconscious, and the tragically disastrous ramifications of transgression.
Psychoanalytic Connection
The Lady of Shalott’s curse and the inevitable cessation of her life can be translated into an equivalent to Orpheus’s inability and eventual breakdown. Her act of gazing at Sir Lancelot without intermediaries like a mirror or any other misleading secondary projection and consequently shattering the jinx parallels Orpheus’s last and final glimpse back at Eurydice. Both of the circumstances as mentioned earlier include and signify a clash with the unconscious, prohibited, or taboo, ensuing catastrophic consequences. The Lady’s downfall mirrors the outcomes of her transgression counter to the boundaries of her suppressively controlling inner world.
4. The Myth of Narcissus
Narcissus develops feelings of affection towards and eventually falls in love with his own mirror image which results in his heartbreakingly calamitous downfall. This myth delves into ideas with regard to themes of self-absorption, egocentrism, and the aftermath of fixating upon an imaginary and unreal image in an excessively obsessive manner.
Psychoanalytic Connection
The Lady of Shalott’s interaction with her own portrayed or projected image in the mirror can be interpreted as a self-centred, egotistical, self-absorbed, or narcissistic fascination with an elevated and glorified yet, in the end, illusory form of actuality. Her existence transforms into self-absorption with the representation of external life instead of unmediated interaction with it. Her ultimately ill fate upon emancipation from this projection projects the danger of forsaking self-fantasy and facing the profounder verities of fleshly existence.
5. The Myth of Pandora
Pandora, amidst unsealing the jar (or box), unleashes all the wickednesses and malevolences into the world however retains hope and aspiration. This myth brings to light motifs of inquisitiveness, transgression, and the outcomes of unveiling hidden truths.
Psychoanalytic Connection
The Lady’s determination to depart from her towering tower and straightforwardly view the outside world can be interpreted as a gesture of inquisitiveness and transgression, analogous to Pandora unsealing her jar (or box). Her interaction with the surrounding world, bringing about her death, signifies the unleashing of suppressed verities and desires, resulting in a significantly intense existential aftermath. The deed of advancing beyond her bounded reality corresponds to the unsealing of Pandora’s jar, unveiling both the hazard and the built-in peril of venturing in pursuit of profounder and greater realities.
6. The Myth of Demeter and Persophone
Throughout the myth, we get to witness Persophone’s seizure by Hades and ensuing reappearance on the surface. This can signify the recurring nature of fleshly existence, cessation, and revival. Demeter’s mourning and Persophone’s bifurcated life in the netherworld and the world symbolise concepts and motifs of estrangement, detachment, yearning, and metamorphosis.
Psychoanalytic Connection
The Lay of Salott’s survival in seclusion and her calamitously disastrous cessation can be perceived as a metaphorical depiction of Persophone’s recurring journey of existence. Her incarceration and consequent endeavour to involve herself with the outside world of existence project a venture betwixt two worlds — the veiled (unconscious) and the unveiled (conscious). Her eventual passing signifies a mode of metamorphosis or rebirth, similar to Persophone’s re-emergence and the revival of living rhythms.
Conclusion
To sum up, the Lady of Shalott’s tale functions as an intricate tapestry woven with the threads of psychoanalytic investigation and examination, utilising both the profundities of singular mental processes and the collective tales or myths which have moulded our comprehension of human existence. By means of the lens of Freud, Lacan, and Jung, we perceive her incredibly sorrowful and heartbreaking venture as a significant inquiry regarding suppressed sentiments and recollections, the intricately delicate dance betwixt the Imaginary and the Real, and the collective pursuit of individuation. The mythological and legendary analogies — from the shadows utilised in the allegory of Plato’s cave to the touching resonances of Orpheus and Eurydice — further elucidate her struggle, contextualising her within the complicated context of mankind’s endless conflict with the incognisant, the unknown, and the unavoidable aftermath of transgression.
As we untangle and decipher the tangles of the plot, we are made aware that the Lady’s destiny is not exclusively and purely a tale of jinxed seclusion, but a symbolic journey into the very depth of psychoanalytic theory. Her tale demands us to address and challenge the intricate equilibrium between wish and restraint, deception and actuality, self and other. It is within this incredibly intricate interrelation that we discover the veritable core of her tragedy — a projection of our own internalised battles and clashes, and the archetypal forces which rule over the psyche. Under this lens, the Lady of Shalott comes forth not solely as a symbol of textual and mythic relevance or value but as an eternal icon of the human soul’s endless struggle in pursuit of significance, wholeness, and transcendence in the presence of the unconscious forces that craft and mould our fleshly existence.
References
Freud, S. (1923). The ego and the id. W.W. Norton & Company.
Freud, S. (1900). The interpretation of dreams. Macmillan.
Lacan, J. (2006). Ecrits: The first complete edition in English (B. Fink, Trans.). W.W. Norton & Company. (Original work published 1966)
Lacan, J. (1998). The four fundamental concepts of psychoanalysis (A. Sheridan, Trans.). W.W. Norton & Company. (Original work published 1973)
Jung, C. G. (1968). The archetypes and the collective unconscious (R.F.C. Hull, Trans.). Princeton University Press.
Jung, C. G. (1959). Aion: Researches into the phenomenology of the self (R.F.C. Hull, Trans.). Princeton University Press.
Plato. (2000). The Republic (T. Griffith, Trans.). Cambridge University Press. (Original work published ca. 380 B.C.E.)
Sandars, N. K. (Trans.). (1972). The epic of Gilgamesh. Penguin Classics.
Graves, R. (1955). The Greek myths (Vol. 1). Penguin Books.
Ovid. (2004). Metamorphoses (A.D. Melville, Trans.). Oxford University Press. (Original work published 8 C.E.)
Hesiod. (2006). Theogony and Works and Days (M.L. West, Trans.). Oxford University Press. (Original work published ca. 700 B.C.E.)
Homer. (1993). The Homeric Hymns (A. Athanassakis, Trans.). Johns Hopkins University Press. (Original work published ca. 7th century B.C.E.)
