Drug Store Eye Creams

Marcus Campbell
17 min readSep 28, 2024
Drug-Store-Eye-Cream-1

Welcome to our roundup of the best drug store eye creams on the market! In this article, we'll be sharing our top picks for affordable and effective eye creams that can help reduce the appearance of fine lines, dark circles, and puffiness. Whether you're a skincare newbie or a seasoned pro, we've got something for everyone. So grab your shopping list and let's get started!

As an Amazon Affiliate we receive compensation from qualifying purchases

Reviews

Ultimate Eye Cream: A Lightweight Moisturizer for Reducing Dark Circles, Wrinkles, and Puffiness

olay-eyes-ultimate-eye-cream-0–4-fl-oz-jar-1

As a product reviewer, I've had the opportunity to try Olay's eye cream and I must say, it's been a positive experience. The first thing that stood out to me is how supercharged it is with peptides and vitamins.

It made my skin feel refreshed and hydrated. I love the way it reduces the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles, and how it's gentle enough for daily use.

However, one thing I noticed was the slight scent it has, which some people might not be a fan of. But overall, it's been a good addition to my skincare routine.

La Roche-Posay Toleriane Ultra Eyes: Gentle, Soothing Eye Cream for Sensitive Skin

Say hello to La Roche Posay's Toleriane Ultra Eyes, your new go-to for sensitive eye contours. This little gem is perfect for those prone to redness, stinging, puffiness, and discomfort. With a rich moisturizing formula, it's like a breath of fresh air on those tired, sensitive eyes.

But that's not all - with a non-comedogenic formula, you won't be left with a greasy mess. And with high dermatological and ophthalmological control, you're getting top-notch quality. We're not exaggerating when we say this eye cream is designed with your sensitive skin in mind.

So, why should you give it a try? It's fragrance and alcohol-free, so it's gentle on your skin. Plus, it's been tested on allergic skin, so you can rest assured it won't trigger any irritation. The patented Neurosensine and Niacinamide complex work together to target puffiness and discomfort, leaving your eyes feeling soothed and less irritated.

But, like with any product, there might be a few cons. Some users have reported that it broke them out, but this seems to be the exception rather than the rule. And if you're worried about the packaging, don't be. It's designed to be airtight and to protect the product from oxidation, so you're getting a fresh, effective cream every time.

In conclusion, if you're looking for a gentle, moisturizing eye cream that's suitable for sensitive skin, then La Roche Posay's Toleriane Ultra Eyes is a top contender. Just remember to be patient and give it time to work its magic - you won't be disappointed!

Neutrogena Hydro Boost Eye Gel-Cream for Hydrated Eyes, 0.5 Fl. Oz.

neutrogena-hydro-boost-eye-gel-cream-0–5-fl-oz-1

Neutrogena Hydro Boost Eye Gel-Cream has been a trusty companion in my skincare routine for quite some time now. I found that it absorbed quickly thanks to its lightweight texture, leaving a refreshing feeling around my eyes. The gel-cream formula is perfect for those who want a hydrating product, as it locks in moisture for hours without leaving a greasy residue. It's been gentle on my sensitive skin, and helped in reducing the appearance of fine lines and dark circles.

However, one downside I noticed was that the product comes in a plastic tube, which might not be as environmentally friendly as some other options. Additionally, I found the dispenser a bit difficult to clean, which could lead to product buildup and a not-so-fresh experience. But overall, Neutrogena Hydro Boost Eye Gel-Cream has been a reliable option in my skincare routine. It's gentle, hydrating, and delivers a pleasant sensation around my eyes.

Holy Hydration! Mini Eye Cream for Moisturizing Under Eyes

The e. l. f. Holy Hydration! Eye Cream Mini is a standout choice for those seeking a rich, non-greasy eye cream to tackle dark circles. This tiny cream, available at Target and Ulta, doesn't skimp on hydration power. Infused with hyaluronic acid and peptides, this cream deeply moisturizes the delicate eye area while minimizing the appearance of dark circles. It's fast-absorbing, leaving your skin feeling refreshed and smelling pleasant.

One of the main positives of this cream is its versatility. It's perfect for those on the go, with the convenient size fitting well into travel or makeup bags. Despite its small size, a little goes a long way, ensuring that you'll be able to enjoy the benefits of the cream for quite some time.

However, a downside to this cream is its diminutive size. Though adorable, it may not be enough to satisfy long-time users who might need an eye cream with a faster consumption rate. Additionally, this cream has been reported to cause dryness in some users, which is a minor concern for those with generally sensitive skin.

In summary, the e. l. f. Holy Hydration! Eye Cream Mini is an excellent choice for travellers or those seeking a compact, non-greasy eye cream that moisturizes and minimizes the appearance of dark circles. With a gentle scent and a fast-absorbing, nourishing formula suitable for all skin types, it's well worth a try. However, users with sensitive skin should proceed with caution due to the potential for dryness.

CeraVe Skin Renewing Eye Cream - All-Day Moisture for Fine Lines and Crow's Feet

cerave-eye-cream-skin-renewing-1

This Cerave Skin Renewing Eye Cream promises to visibly firm and brighten the delicate skin around the eyes, reducing the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles. The ophthalmologist-tested formula contains essential ceramides, niacinamide, caffeine, and a peptide complex, and is suitable for contact lens wearers. It is specifically designed to provide all-day hydration through MVE technology, ensuring controlled release moisture for lasting comfort.

Many users praise this eye cream for its hydrating and brightening properties, as well as its lightweight texture and easy application. Some customers have even noticed improvements in the under eye area's smoothness and puffiness. The fact that this eye cream is fragrance-free, ophthalmologist-tested, suitable for contact lens wearers, and free from parabens are other notable features that have caught the attention of customers.

However, some users have reported experiencing irritation and burning sensations around their eyes. Additionally, a few customers have encountered difficulties with clogged tubes and had to return counterfeit products.

L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect Midnight Eye Cream for Dark Circles

loreal-paris-age-perfect-midnight-eye-opener-cream-cvs-1

I recently got to try out L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect Midnight Eye Opener Cream, and I have to say, it felt like treating myself to a little luxury every time I applied it. The rich, luxurious texture glided on my skin smoothly, and it just felt so satisfying to use.

The scent was very pleasant and barely noticeable once applied, allowing me to focus on the moisturizing and comforting effects it had on my delicate eye area. The combination of dermatologist-recommended antioxidants and vitamin E certainly worked wonders, as I noticed a visible reduction in the appearance of under-eye wrinkles and an overall brightening of my eyes' appearance.

However, I must admit that the 8-week independent consumer study's results seemed a bit too good to be true, and I didn't observe such drastic changes in just a few weeks of use. Additionally, while the dispenser was practical, it did require a bit of pressure to get the product out, which I sometimes found a bit messy.

Despite these minor drawbacks, I would definitely recommend L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect Midnight Eye Opener Cream for those seeking a gentle, effective eye cream that helps improve their skin's texture. The luxurious feel, coupled with its pleasing scent and hydrating properties, make it a delightful addition to any skincare routine.

Walgreens Beauty Rejuvenating Eye Cream (1.35oz)

walgreens-beauty-revitalizing-eye-cream-1

I recently tried the Walgreens Beauty Revitalizing Eye Cream, and I must say, it lived up to my expectations. I've been using it for a few weeks now, and I've started to notice a significant difference in the appearance of my under-eye area. The anti-wrinkle formula has helped me combat those pesky fine lines, and it's been a lifesaver during my long days at work.

One thing that stood out to me is the cream's ability to work both day and night. I've been applying it in the morning before I head out, and at night when I'm winding down. It's been a consistent part of my skincare routine, and I've noticed the brightening effect it has on my under-eye area.

While I can't directly compare it to the L'Oreal Revitalift Anti-wrinkle + Firming eye cream, the Walgreens Beauty Revitalizing Eye Cream has been a worthy addition to my skincare routine. However, I must admit that the packaging could be more luxurious, as it feels a bit more like a drugstore product compared to some higher-end options.

Overall, I've been enjoying using the Walgreens Beauty Revitalizing Eye Cream, and I think it's a great choice for those looking for an affordable yet effective eye cream.

Roc Retinol Correxion Mini: Drug Store Anti-Aging Eye Cream for Dark Circles & Puffiness

roc-retinol-correxion-eye-cream-mini-for-dark-circles-puffiness-daily-wrinkle-cream-anti-aging-line — 1

Introducing the Roc Retinol Correxion Eye Cream Mini, a skincare treasure designed to combat the signs of aging around the delicate eye area. The product promises to diminish fine lines, wrinkles, dark circles, and puffiness in as little as 12 weeks, thanks to its exclusive retinol formula. This cream is also non-comedogenic, meaning it won't clog pores, and is dermatologist-tested, ensuring a gentle yet effective experience for users.

Its lightweight texture makes it suitable for daily use, while the convenient 0.25 fl oz volume allows you to easily carry it in your purse or travel bag. Though there may be some mixed opinions on its effectiveness and the authenticity of some third-party sales, many users praise its ability to achieve a visibly more youthful appearance around the eyes.

Loreal Anti-Aging Eye Cream: Gentle, Fragrance-Free Defense for All Skin Types

loreal-eye-cream-eye-defense-0–5-oz-1

This eye defense cream from Loreal is an impressive addition to any skincare regimen. The light, non-greasy gel-cream formula is suitable for all skin types and is designed to protect against premature aging around the eyes. It uses advanced techniques, such as liposomes, to help the hydrating and nurturing ingredients penetrate the skin's surface, providing an effective and long-lasting solution to fine lines, wrinkles, dark circles, and puffiness.

The product is also dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested, ensuring it's safe for contact lens wearers and gentle on the skin. However, some users have reported that the formula contains glitter or sparkles, which may not be desirable for everyone.

Overall, this eye cream is an excellent choice for those seeking a powerful anti-aging product that is suitable for all skin types.

E.L.F. Illuminating Eye Cream: Minimize Dark Circles and Hydrate for a Revitalized Look

e-l-f-illuminating-eye-cream-0–49-oz-jar-1

I recently started using the E. L. F. Illuminating Eye Cream as part of my skincare routine, and I must say, it's been a game-changer. The cream is lightweight and non-greasy, which I appreciate since I don't like stuff that feels heavy on my skin. It also absorbs well and is comfortable to use, making it a perfect addition to my morning and night skincare routine.

One of the standout features of this eye cream is its long-lasting nature. I've been able to use it for about 6 months now, and only a small amount remains. It feels like it lasts a lifetime, which is a definite plus for anyone who values their skincare products to be cost-effective and long-lasting.

However, there was one thing that didn't quite sit well with me. Despite the moisturizing properties, I haven't noticed a significant change in my dark circles. It's not that I need a magic solution for them, but I had hoped for some improvement in that department. It's not a deal-breaker for me, but it's something I thought I should mention.

Overall, I think the E. L. F. Illuminating Eye Cream is a great addition to anyone's skincare routine, especially if they're looking for a cost-effective and long-lasting product. The lightweight formula is comfortable to use, and the fact that it absorbs well makes it an easy choice for those who don't like heavy creams. Although I've noticed some minor improvements in hydration and possibly fine lines, I would have loved to see even more progress for the dark circles. Still, I'll gladly keep using it and seeing if it makes a noticeable difference in the future.

Cetaphil Hydrating Eye Gel-Cream - Drug Store Option

cetaphil-eye-gel-cream-hydrating-0–5-fl-oz-1

The Cetaphil Hydrating Eye Gel-Cream is a well-designed product that effectively moisturizes the skin under the eyes while tackling fine lines and wrinkles. Its unique gel-cream formula absorbs quickly, providing a refreshing and hydrating experience. The product is enriched with vitamin complex, licorice extract, and hyaluronic acid which work in harmony to nourish the skin.

However, the packaging of this product feels a bit small and unassuming compared to what's inside it. Though it does its job well in terms of hydration and eye care, it may not be the best option for those looking for a product that gives a more luxurious feel. Some users have also reported slight irritation after using the product, although this might not be the norm.

Overall, we believe that the Cetaphil Hydrating Eye Gel-Cream is a great and effective option for those who value hydration and anti-aging benefits in their skincare routine. With consistent use, you can expect noticeable improvements in skin texture and reduced fine lines.

Good Molecules Revitalizing Eye Gel with Yerba Mate

good-molecules-yerba-mate-wake-up-eye-gel-1

In my search for a gentle and effective eye cream, I came across Good Molecules' Yerba Mate Wake Up Eye Gel. What piqued my interest was the promise of natural and environmentally friendly ingredients from Brazilian farms. The tube packaging was an added bonus.

The gel's texture was surprisingly lightweight, making it easy to apply even under makeup. I liked the fact that it quickly absorbed into my skin without leaving any residue. The combination of caffeine, peptides, and hyaluronic acid offered a three-in-one solution to brighten, plump, and hydrate the under-eye area. My eyes immediately appeared more alert and revitalized.

However, the consistency was a downside - it was quite thick. On certain days, applying the gel was challenging, and it sometimes felt heavy on my eyes, which was concerning. Additionally, the tube packaging took some getting used to; although I usually prefer this type, the loose cap made it susceptible to leaking when stored vertically.

Despite these minor setbacks, the Good Molecules Yerba Mate Wake Up Eye Gel proved to be a valuable addition to my skincare routine. Its affordable and gentle nature made it an attractive choice for those seeking to revive their under-eye area without overspending. With improved consistency and packaging, this eye gel could have received a five-star rating from me.

Cerave Eye Repair Cream: Drug Store Eye Treatment for Tired Eyes

cerave-eye-repair-cream-0–5-oz-1

Say goodbye to puffy, tired-looking eyes with CeraVe Eye Repair Cream. This powerful formula is specially designed for the delicate eye area, providing intense hydration to smooth out fine lines and wrinkles while restoring the skin's protective barrier. Infused with humectant, skin stays moisturized all day long, thanks to ingredients such as hyaluronic acid and ceramides. The lightweight, non-greasy solution absorbs quickly, leaving skin feeling soft and supple. With a pointed tip for easy, mess-free application, this 0.5 oz eye cream is perfect for on-the-go use or daily skincare routines.

CeraVe Eye Repair Cream comes in a convenient, travel-friendly tube. It is fragrance-free, suitable for all skin types, and provides a gentle solution for tackling those stubborn under-eye problems. Users have reported noticeable improvements in hydration, skin texture, and an overall reduction in visible signs of aging.

However, some users have experienced allergic reactions, including redness, soreness, and peeling. It is essential to perform a patch test before applying the eye cream to ensure compatibility with your skin. This gentle, budget-friendly option is worth a try for those seeking a reliable eye cream that provides excellent hydration without weighing down the skin.

Buyer's Guide

Here are the essential considerations and features to think about when purchasing a drug store eye cream that best suits your skincare needs. While it's important to remember that every person's skin is different, these tips can help you choose a product that suits your specific requirements.

Key Features

Here are some key features to look for in a drug store eye cream to ensure you're getting the most bang for your buck. 1. Hydration: A good eye cream should help keep the skin around your eyes hydrated to reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles. 2. Brightness: An eye cream that can help even out skin tone and add some brightness to dark circles can be a great bonus feature. 3. Non-greasy formula: Many people prefer a non-greasy formula that absorbs quickly and doesn't leave a residue. 4. Eye cream specifically designed for your skin type (like oily or dry) and potential concerns (like puffiness or dark circles).

Considerations Before Purchase

Consider the following factors before purchasing a drug store eye cream:

  1. Your skin type and any concerns you want the eye cream to address. 2. Your budget, as eye creams can range anywhere from inexpensive to high-end. 3. Whether you prefer to use skincare products with natural or synthetic ingredients. 4. The brand's reputation and customer reviews, which can provide helpful insights into the product's performance and value.

General Advice for Drug Store Eye Creams

Here are some general tips to keep in mind when shopping for a drug store eye cream:

  1. Don't forget to patch test the product before fully committing to it. 2. Look for products that offer a reasonable return policy or money-back guarantee, just in case the cream doesn't work out for you. 3. It's always a good idea to consult with a dermatologist or skincare professional for personalized recommendations.

When purchasing a drug store eye cream, it's essential to consider your skin type, concerns, and budget, as well as whether you prefer natural or synthetic ingredients. By doing your research and keeping these factors in mind, you can find an eye cream that fits your skincare needs and delivers on its promises.

FAQ

How do drug store eye creams differ from high-end products?

While high-end eye creams may have more extensive research, improved ingredients, and better packaging, drug store eye creams can still be effective if you choose the right one for your needs. Drug store creams are usually cheaper, making them more accessible to a broader audience. Their active ingredients may not be as potent, but the lower price point allows more people to benefit from them.

Some drugstore eye creams can still address common eye concerns, like dark circles and puffiness, with the use of active ingredients like hyaluronic acid or retinol. However, it is always a good idea to read reviews and do research on the specific product to make sure it suits your skin type and concerns.

What are the best ingredients to look for in a drug store eye cream?

For starters, hyaluronic acid is a highly recommended ingredient because it has hydrating properties, which can help reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles around the eyes. It also increases the skin's elasticity to give the under-eye area a plumper look. Other beneficial ingredients include caffeine, peptides, and vitamin E, all of which can help brighten the eye area and minimize dark circles by reducing puffiness and improving the skin's overall texture.

Furthermore, look for products with retinol, a form of vitamin A that stimulates collagen production. Retinol can help reduce the appearance of fine lines, wrinkles, and age spots over time. It is essential to remember that not all drug store eye creams contain the same ingredients, so it's good to review the label to ensure the specific product you choose has these beneficial components.

How much eye cream should I use daily and what should be my application process?

Use a small amount of eye cream, typically about the size of a grain of rice, and apply it with your ring finger. Gently pat the cream under your eyes, starting from the inner corner and working your way outwards. Be cautious not to drag or pull the skin, as this may cause wrinkles over time. Once applied, allow the cream to absorb into your skin before applying makeup or going about your day.

It is often recommended to apply eye cream once or twice a day, depending on the severity of your concerns and your skin's needs. It's best to apply the eye cream in the morning to protect your skin from environmental factors like pollution and free radicals, but using it at night may also be beneficial in helping with overnight repair. It is essential to be gentle and patient during application, as consistency can ultimately have a significant impact on the effectiveness of the product.

Are there any drug store eye creams that work well for sensitive skin?

Yes, there are drug store eye creams specifically designed for sensitive skin. These products tend to have fewer fragrances and harsh chemicals, making them gentler and less likely to cause irritation or redness. Look for eye creams with soothing, calming ingredients such as chamomile, aloe vera, or green tea extract. These ingredients can help with hydration and reduce inflammation and irritation for sensitive skin types. Remember to always patch test a new product on a small area of your skin first to ensure it does not cause any adverse reactions.

If you have sensitive skin, being attentive to potential triggers, such as certain ingredients, can be crucial. Stay away from products containing sulfates, alcohol, or other irritants and opt for fragrance-free options. Consult with a dermatologist or skin care specialist for personalized recommendations based on your skin's specific needs and requirements.

What about drug store eye creams for those with oily or combination skin?

For those with oily or combination skin, look for eye creams with lightweight, non-greasy textures that won't clog pores or make your skin feel heavy. These products are likely to contain water or hyaluronic acid as their primary ingredients, providing the necessary hydration for the under-eye area without adding excess oil.

When trying an eye cream, it is essential to pay attention to its consistency and any potential feelings of heaviness or greasiness on your skin. Opt for eye creams labeled as 'oil-free' or 'non-comedogenic' to ensure they don't contribute to excess oil production or clogged pores. Additionally, you can layer the product with other dermatologist-recommended products for oily or combination skin types to achieve the best results.

What are some budget-friendly drug store eye creams that are worth a try?

Numerous drug store eye creams offer great value for their price and can be quite effective. Some of the most popular options include L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect Hydro Nutrient Eye Cream, Olay Regenerist Micro-Sculpting Eye Swirl, and Cetaphil Hydrating Eye Gel Cream. These products have positive reviews and cater to a wide range of skin concerns, from hydration to anti-aging. By trying these and other drugstore eye creams, you can find the one that works best for your skin type and needs without breaking the bank.

Remember that it is essential to read reviews, check ingredients, and patch test before making a final decision. What works for one person may not work for another, so it's always good to have options and to give products enough time to see results. Don't be afraid to mix and match or switch to a new product if you're unhappy with the results.

As an Amazon Affiliate we receive compensation from qualifying purchases

--

--