Summary of “The Reckoning” by John Grisham

Aubree McGuire
5 min readSep 7, 2023

--

“The Reckoning” is a legal thriller novel written by John Grisham, published in 2018. This novel is set in post-World War II Mississippi and is a departure from Grisham’s typical legal drama, as it incorporates elements of historical fiction, family saga, and courtroom intrigue. The story follows the life of Pete Banning, a war hero who suddenly commits a shocking murder, leading to a gripping trial and revelations about his past. This 2000-word summary will provide an in-depth overview of the novel’s key plot points, characters, and themes.

Get “The Reckoning” By John Grisham Here For Free

Created with www.kittl.com

Part I: The Murder

The novel begins in the small town of Clanton, Mississippi, in 1946. Pete Banning, a respected war hero and cotton farmer, inexplicably walks into the Methodist church one morning and shoots the Reverend Dexter Bell dead. Pete calmly surrenders to the authorities and offers no explanation for his actions. The murder sends shockwaves through the close-knit community, and the townspeople are baffled as to what could have motivated this act.

Part II: The Trial

Pete’s arrest leads to a high-profile trial that grips the town. The prosecution, led by district attorney Lucien Wilbanks, seeks the death penalty. Pete’s defense attorney is his old friend, Harry Rex Vonner. As the trial unfolds, it becomes clear that Pete is unwilling to defend himself or provide any reason for the murder.

Throughout the trial, Grisham paints a vivid picture of the racial tensions and social dynamics of the South in the 1940s. Pete’s family, including his sister Florry and his children Stella and Joel, struggles to cope with the shame and mystery surrounding their patriarch’s actions.

Despite Harry Rex’s best efforts, the jury convicts Pete, and he is sentenced to death by electrocution. Pete’s stoic demeanor during the trial and refusal to explain his actions only deepen the mystery surrounding the murder.

Get “The Reckoning” By John Grisham Here For Free

Part III: The War

Created with www.kittl.com

To understand Pete Banning’s motivations, the novel takes readers on a journey back in time to his experiences during World War II. Pete served as a fighter pilot in the Pacific theater and faced harrowing combat situations. He befriended a fellow pilot, Clay Hutch, and together they endured the brutal realities of war.

As the war progressed, Pete and Clay were captured by Japanese forces and held as prisoners of war. Their captivity was marked by starvation, disease, and brutality. Pete’s experiences in the POW camp had a profound and lasting impact on him.

Part IV: The Reckoning

Pete’s actions during the war become the key to understanding his motive for murder. It is revealed that Pete and Clay managed to escape from the POW camp, but their escape came at a great cost. They were forced to make a difficult moral choice that haunted Pete for the rest of his life.

Pete believed that the terrible decision he made during the escape was necessary for their survival but conflicted with his deeply held Christian beliefs. He carried the weight of this moral reckoning with him long after the war ended, leading to a sense of guilt and a fractured psyche.

As Pete awaits his execution on death row, he finally confides in Harry Rex about the events of the war, explaining the true reason for his actions. This revelation has a profound impact on Harry Rex and the others who had been in the dark about Pete’s past.

Get “The Reckoning” By John Grisham Here For Free

Part V: The Execution

Created with www.kittl.com

The novel reaches its climax with Pete’s impending execution. Despite the revelation of his motives, there is little hope for a reprieve. The day of the execution arrives, and Pete meets it with stoicism, ready to face the consequences of his actions.

The novel concludes with Pete’s execution, leaving readers with a sense of closure regarding the murder and Pete’s unspoken burdens. The town of Clanton grapples with the complex legacy of a man who was both a war hero and a murderer.

Themes

Moral Dilemma: “The Reckoning” explores the theme of moral dilemma through Pete Banning’s wartime experiences. His choice to commit a morally questionable act in order to survive raises questions about the limits of human morality in the face of extreme circumstances.

Justice and Redemption: The novel delves into questions of justice and redemption, as Pete’s actions during the war and his murder of Reverend Bell are intertwined with notions of guilt, atonement, and the pursuit of justice.

Family and Community: Pete’s actions have far-reaching consequences for his family and the community of Clanton. The novel examines how individuals are shaped by their family and the society in which they live.

War and its Trauma: The portrayal of Pete’s experiences in World War II highlights the trauma of war and its long-lasting impact on soldiers. Grisham provides a gritty and realistic portrayal of the horrors of combat and captivity.

Religion and Faith: Pete’s strong Christian faith is juxtaposed with the moral compromises he makes during the war. The novel raises questions about the role of religion in guiding one’s moral compass.

Conclusion

“The Reckoning” is a thought-provoking novel that combines elements of legal drama, historical fiction, and psychological exploration. John Grisham weaves a complex narrative that challenges readers to consider the moral complexities of wartime decisions and the consequences of those decisions on individuals and their communities. Pete Banning’s enigmatic character and the novel’s exploration of justice, redemption, and the human capacity for both good and evil make it a compelling and memorable work of fiction.

Get “The Reckoning” By John Grisham Here For Free

--

--