Deconstructing Apple Card: A Hacker’s Perspective
Apple Inc. yesterday announced the introduction of Apple Card, a product developed in collaboration with Goldman Sachs and Mastercard, which the company is touting as a “a new kind of credit card” featuring “a new level of privacy and security.” In this article, we unpack the technology behind Apple Card, including its strengths and weaknesses from both a security and privacy perspective. The security integrated within Apple Card is novel as a case study for information security professionals tasked with protecting sensitive information. For example, the card lacks certain cardholder data (e.g. Primary Account Number, Expiration Date and CVV2) which is both integral to the function of conventional credit cards and at the same time a weakness. Another novelty and strength associated with Apple Card is that it leverages the heightened security of host card emulation (HCE) — better known as secure element (SE) — a software architecture that enables identification and protection of digital cards. Through these features, combined with many other security enhancements, Apple Card proves that it is possible to provide higher levels of security and privacy even on resource constrained devices.
Apple Card Initialization Process
In order to understand Apple Card’s overall security posture, we need to walkthrough the end-to-end flow from card manufacturing to initialization and registration with a mobile device. This provides a foundational understanding of the security controls built into the Apple Card payment flow.
During the manufacturing process, Apple provisions Mastercard’s public key on the physical card chip, which is signed by the chip manufacturer’s private key and then syncs with Mastercard’s tokenization service, enabling Mastercard to validate the authenticity of their public key. Mastercard’s tokenization service is responsible for maintaining a registry of all trusted chip manufacturers and its certificates. This registry is held in a trust store, which verifies certificates from a trusted Certificate Authority (CA).
Chip-specific information such as the integrated circuit card (ICC) key pair and certificate are also signed by the chip manufacturer and provisioned on the chip.
Once the consumer has received the card, Mastercards’ payment applet takes payment information from the issuing bank and securely stores it the SE. Users are prompted for a nonce, or special random number, to validate the user’s authenticity. For successful initialization of the applet, it must validate a unique device PAN signed with Mastercards’ private key using the tokenization API.
On a frequent basis, Apple card performs secure key exchange/generation using Application Processing Data Unit (APDU) commands, this secure key generation replenishes encrypted tokens and unique derived keys.
In case of a lost or stolen card, an adversary cannot make any transactions and the user can receive a new token and unique derived keys on their provisioned devices without concern about fraudulent transactions.
Mastercard’s token enrollment APIs negotiate end-to-end encryption protocols between the secure element and Mastercard’s tokenization service. We speculate that the protocol leverages 3DES, which is then hex encoded and is concatenated with Device Encryption Key (DEK), derived from device key, and the device’s MAC address. Encryption is performed using RSA and gets signed using the ISO 9796. This ensures the key size for both encryption and signature to be 1024 bits. This way, the heavy lifting of encryption is handled by backend servers. Along with that, as there is a device key and MAC involved in the key generation ceremony, there are a few key generation attributes tied to the users’ Apple Card.
Secure Communication with Mobile Device and Applications
Apple Card owners will likely need to enroll the card into their iPhone manually by entering the cardholder’s data into the Passbook application (we speculate some form of card identifier will be provided by mail or on the card itself to facilitate this process). The unique card identifier, or temporary DPAN, will then be combined with a owner’s specific key and sent to Goldman Sachs along with their iTunes information such as billing address, full name and phone number over secure encrypted channels. Goldman Sachs would view this information in the clear but Apple asserts that Goldman Sachs will refrain from sharing or selling this data to third parties for marketing or advertising purposes. Using the information submitted from the owner’s iOS device, Goldman Sachs then decides whether to approve before allowing the user to add (or bind) the card to the Passbook app. At Goldman Sachs’ discretion, the bank’s process will include steps for additional validation that the cardholder may need to register the credit card. The account holder may confirm their identity with a one-time code. Once the identity is confirmed, Goldman Sachs will create a DPAN, which is a token-like value based upon the user’s personal account number and the user’s device specific information. The DPAN is returned to the device via a two-way transport layer security (TLS) connection from Goldman Sachs for storage in the iOS device’s SE. The DPAN, stored in the SE, is never stored on Apple Card servers, or backed up to iCloud. In addition, the DPAN is encrypted using the user’s private keys, which Apple does not have access to and so has no ability to decrypt. This clear segregation of keys enables Apple to ensure user privacy is maintained and user spending habits or payment-related information is never shared between the company’s servers.
For secure payments, the foundational security of Apple’s products rests upon SE, which is a hardware driven, tamper-resistant solution capable of securely hosting payment applets, securely communicating other mobile applications and ensuring confidentiality and key management of sensitive data. The SE embeds into the NFC chip, which is used by Apple Pay at payment terminals. The NFC chip facilitates communication between the terminal and the SE. They key takeaway from the SE integration is a hardware-driven microcontroller that performs all the security checks for sensitive data and is segregated from the rest of the mobile applications. This provides strong cryptographic computational power in a single chip.
Authenticating Users to Access Information
Only applications created by Apple have access to Apple Card payment information. When the any mobile application is trying to access payment information such as transaction history or making a cash transaction, a call is made to the Apple Card Servers with DPAN information to obtain a timebound nonce. This number, along with other transaction data, is passed over an applet to the SE to generate a payment signature. When the payment signature comes out of the SE, it’s sent to Apple Card Servers over encrypted channels. The authenticity of this transaction is verified through this payment signature and the random number provided by Apple Pay Servers. After successful verification of the payment signature, the user’s request is initiated. If the user wants to view the transaction details, then temporary payment applet access is provided to the Apple-created mobile applications. For sending or receiving payment, encrypted payment transaction information is sent back to Apple Card Servers, which is encrypted using the user’s private key. In case additional user identification is requested, then that information is also handed over to Goldman Sachs via Apple Card servers using the user’s private key encryption. The only caveat is that any user enrolled on that device can make a payment on someone else’s behalf provided they can perform touch or face authentication.
As shown in this article, foundational security is embedded across the entire payment flow right from manufacturing to successful payment. Broadly, the security takeaways from Apple Card are threefold: First, from an architecture perspective, Apple thought through all the moving parts and managed to achieve security without compromising user experience. Second, rather than introducing a very fragmented ecosystem for payment, they narrowed the players to only Mastercard and Goldman Sachs, which reduces the number of dependencies and overall business risk. Finally, by integrating hardware-based security controls such as tamper resistance and SE, Apple ensured the foundational security of Apple Card is not software-driven, which may have proved more error prone than hardware controls. The only caveat to this approach is that if a bug is found in the hardware, a fix cannot easily be applied.
About Ryan McKamie
Ryan McKamie is CEO and co-founder of Certus Cybersecurity Solutions LLC, based in the firm’s San Francisco Bay Area office. Ryan is responsible for Certus Cybersecurity’s global cybersecurity services business. His client work focuses on providing strategic and technical guidance to business and technology executives seeking to assess and improve their ability to defend against data breach and business disruption. Prior to Certus Cybersecurity, Ryan was a director at Visa Inc. and served as an officer in the US Army. Ryan holds active QSA, CISSP, CISM, CRISC and CISA certifications.
About Swapnil Deshmukh
Swapnil Deshmukh is CTO and co-founder of Certus Cybersecurity Solutions LLC, based in the firm’s San Francisco Bay Area office. A thought leader and technical expert with extensive experience in information security, Swapnil leads consulting delivery for Certus clients worldwide, partnering with executives to implement and enhance layered defenses and effective security processes and policies. Prior to Certus Cybersecurity, Swapnil served as a senior director at Visa Inc., where he played a leadership role in enhancing the company’s security architecture and secure software development lifecycle (SSDLC) capability.
About Certus Cybersecurity Solutions LLC
Certus Cybersecurity Solutions LLC provides cybersecurity consulting and services to businesses seeking to safeguard their critical systems and applications from data breach and disruption. With deep expertise in enterprise cybersecurity and a track record of leveraging our experience in combination with cutting-edge technologies, Certus Cybersecurity is a trusted partner to companies seeking to proactively build cybersecurity capability.
For more information on how Certus Cybersecurity can help secure your business, please contact us.
US: +1 877 905 0975
UK: +44 20 396 52716
Germany: +49 711 4906 6996