Navigating the Red and Blue Oceans: A Guide to Strategic Business Success
As a business strategist, you may have heard of the terms “blue ocean” and “red ocean”, which refer to two strategic frameworks that can help businesses thrive in a competitive market. While these terms may sound like they belong in marine biology, they were coined by Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne in 2005 to describe distinct market spaces. By using the ocean as an analogy, the blue ocean strategy encourages businesses to explore new and untapped markets, while the red ocean strategy focuses on competing within existing markets.
✍️ Introduction to Red Ocean Strategy and Blue Ocean Strategy
➧ Red Ocean Strategy: Represents bloody and ruthless competition
The Red Ocean strategy is a conventional marketing approach used by business strategists that involves competing with rivals in an existing market. This strategy is exemplified by numerous companies striving to gain a competitive edge over one another. In a red ocean, businesses vie for the same customers and market share by outmaneuvering their adversaries. This strategy aims to enhance customer satisfaction by delivering exceptional products and services. It prioritizes catering to existing customers rather than acquiring new ones. Therefore, companies strive to attract customers by providing superior offerings.
An example of a red ocean strategy would be the fast-food industry, where well-known brands such as McDonald’s, Burger King, and KFC compete in a crowded market for the same customers. They all offer similar products such as burgers, fries, and sodas, and the competition is primarily based on price and convenience.
➧ Blue Ocean Strategy: Represents vast, deep blue waters, i.e., the unexplored markets
The Blue Ocean Strategy is a visionary marketing approach that prioritizes innovation over direct competition, aiming to revitalize businesses. Coined in 2005 by W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne, this strategy involves opening up fresh market spaces while generating new consumer demand, rendering competition superfluous.
An example of a blue ocean strategy would be the plant-based meat industry. Companies like Beyond Meat and Impossible Foods are creating a new market space by offering innovative plant-based meat products that appeal to health-conscious consumers who are looking for environmentally sustainable options. These companies have successfully created a new market space that did not previously exist, with little to no competition.
Examples OF Red Ocean Strategy
Apple, Spice Jet, Jio, Samsung TV, Bose, Ryanair.
Examples of Blue Ocean Strategy
Uber, Airbnb, Spotify, Marvel, Ford Motor, Netflix, Meta.
✍️ Major Differences between Red Ocean Strategy and Blue Ocean Strategy
➧ New Market Creation vs. Existing Market
Red ocean strategy revolves around staying within the boundaries of the existing marketplace and competing fiercely with rivals. In contrast, blue ocean strategy seeks to identify opportunities to create entirely new markets where there are no competitors. For instance, Canon’s business plan pioneered a new market for small desktop printers by targeting users directly rather than focusing on corporate purchasers. The result was a revolution in office printing.
➧ Making Competition Irrelevant vs. Beating Competition
Red ocean strategy involves beating the competition through aggressive marketing, lower pricing, and exceptional user experience. In contrast, blue ocean strategy seeks to create alternatives to existing products or services to make the competition irrelevant. For example, In the early days of the mobile phone market, companies like Nokia and Motorola were focused on beating the competition by offering better features, more attractive designs, and lower prices. However, Apple’s strategic management approach changed the game by introducing the iPhone, which wasn’t just a better version of existing phones but a completely new category of device that made traditional mobile phones irrelevant. Similarly, Google’s Android operating system disrupted the market by offering an open-source alternative to Apple’s closed ecosystem, which made competition less relevant.
➧ Breaking Value-Cost Trade-Off vs. Making Value-Cost Trade-Off
In red ocean strategy, businesses have to choose between creating more value for customers and offering a lower price. In contrast, those who pursue a blue ocean strategy aim to achieve both by creating differentiation and low cost. Airbnb is a classic example of this approach. By connecting existing property owners and travelers on a common, user-friendly platform, Airbnb redefined the travel experience, creating value for both homeowners and travelers while keeping costs low.
➧ Creating New Demand vs. Capturing Existing Demand
Red ocean strategy is all about capturing as much of the existing demand as possible. On the other hand, blue ocean strategy aims to create new demand by offering innovative solutions. For instance, Netflix’s business strategists made a shift from a DVD sales and rental business to a streaming service creating a new market space and opening up opportunities for high-quality, affordable movie-watching.
✍️ What are some effective strategies for thriving in competitive and uncontested markets, i.e., the red and blue oceans, respectively?
Surviving in a red ocean market requires a company to compete fiercely with other companies in the same industry. One example of a successful survival strategy in a red ocean market is by focusing on differentiation. For instance, the soft drink industry is a classic example of a red ocean market with intense competition among major players such as Coca-Cola and PepsiCo. To survive in this market, a smaller soft drink company may choose to differentiate itself by offering a unique flavor or ingredient that cannot be found in the offerings of larger companies. By doing so, the organization can carve out a niche market for itself and attract customers who are looking for something different from the usual options available in the market.
On the other hand, building and surviving in a blue ocean market requires a company to create new demand and opportunities by offering a unique product or service that does not yet exist in the market. The low-cost airline industry, pioneered by Southwest Airlines and Ryanair, exemplifies a successful implementation of the blue ocean strategy. Prior to their entry into the market, air travel was dominated by full-service airlines offering amenities such as in-flight meals and assigned seating. By providing affordable, reliable, and convenient flights at lower prices through a stripped-down service model, these low-cost carriers created a blue ocean.
To thrive in a blue ocean market, companies must constantly innovate and differentiate themselves from competitors. For instance, Southwest Airlines has sustained its success by prioritizing operational efficiency, customer service, and employee engagement. In contrast, Ryanair has expanded its route network while reducing costs through tactics like charging extra fees for services like checked luggage and priority boarding.
✍️ Can business shift from red ocean to blue ocean?
To shift from a red ocean to a blue ocean, companies need to focus on creating innovative value propositions that differentiate them from their competitors. This can involve developing new products or services, redefining the target market, or adopting a new business model.
The key is to identify the factors that drive customer value and find ways to deliver them in a unique and compelling way. By doing so, businesses can create new demand, break free from the competition, and achieve sustainable growth and profitability.
More Stories
