I finally just closed the wallet and re-tried the same process and it worked like it should. After it proof verified, I closed the wallet, then re-opened it and input my ‘old seed’. It showed a 0 balance, but then went to ‘Receive’ and clicked Attach. It went and attached to the Tangle and created an address. I continued to re-Attach from the same screen, creating new addresses several times, and finally my IOTA showed up.
Hope this helps