Normalized H5-index of Computer Science Conferences

When selecting conferences for csindexbr, we found a relevant correlation between the h5-index and the number of papers accepted in CS conferences.

Basically, h5-index is the largest number h such that h articles published in the last five editions of a conference have at least h citations each.

For example, see the following scatterplot, considering 166 conferences; h5-index is as computed by Google Scholar (in June, 2018).

These conferences cover 18 sub-areas. Although most CS sub-areas are included in the list, we acknoledge that some important sub-areas are still not covered by csindexbr (e.g. Operating Systems and Computer Graphics).

Our theory is that if a conference accepts many papers (hundreds of papers, for example) it produces many citations; some of these citations will refer to papers accepted in previous editions of the same conference. Naturally, some of these papers receive more citations and therefore increase the conference's h-index (or h5-index).

For example, there are two conferences with h5-index > 100 in our dataset (both accepting more than 600 papers):

1.CVPR (Computer Vision): 783 papers accepted in 2017; h5-index= 158 
2.NIPS (Artificial Intelligence): 678 papers accepted in 2017; h5-index= 101

Check also the next 13 conferences with the highest h5-index (as we can see, 6 conferences accept more than 400 papers):

3. ECCV (Computer Vision): 415 papers; h5-index=98 
4. ICML (Artificial Intelligence): 433 papers; h5-index=91 
5. ICCV (Computer Vision): 621 papers; h5-index=89 
6. CHI (Human-Computer Interaction): 600 papers; h5-index= 85 
7. INFOCOM (Networks): 292 papers; h5-index= 80 
8. WWW (Web): 164 papers; h5-index= 77 
9. KDD (Data Mining): 130 papers; h5-index= 73 
10. VLDB (Databases): 133 papers; h5-index= 73 
11. ICRA (Robotics): 939 papers; h5-index= 71 
12. CCS (Security): 151 papers; h5-index= 71 
13. IROS (Robotics): 970 papers; h5-index= 68 
14. ICSE (Software Engineering): 68 papers; h5-index= 68 
15. IEEE S&P (Security): 60 papers; h5-index= 68

Then, we decided to compute the normalized h5-index, defined as:

normalized-h5-index= h5-index / papers-accepted-2017

Ideally, we should normalize by the total number of papers accepted in the last five years; however, we only collected statistics about papers accepted in 2017. Despite that, we think the number of accepted papers in a conference does not change a lot, among recent editions.

(It is also important to mention that the idea of normalizing h-indexes is not new; for example, it is used in this paper from 2007).

The following chart shows the top-15 conferences, with normalized h5-index ≥ 1

Normalized h5-index (top-15 conferences)

Some observations about these 15 conferences:

  • They accepted a small number of papers in 2017. For example, CLOUD accepted 20 papers; SIGCOMM accepted 36; and SPLC accepted 15 papers.
  • NSDI is the conference which accepted the highest number of papers (46 papers).
  • SIGCOMM is also the conference with the highest h5-index (67), followed by NSDI (62).
  • SPLC is the conference with the lowest h5-index (25), followed by MODELS (26).

The next chart shows the next 16 conferences, with normalized h5-index ≥1.

Normalized h5-index (next 16 conferences)
Like what you read? Give csindexbr a round of applause.

From a quick cheer to a standing ovation, clap to show how much you enjoyed this story.

Responses
The author has chosen not to show responses on this story. You can still respond by clicking the response bubble.