Thank you for this article and this mapping. Looking at the players you listed in your mapping, it seems that as many people do, you believe that startups scene started in 2010. There were a startups ecosystem long before that and there were important players in the startup scene that started 20 or 30 years ago and still exist. The public incubators and technopoles are not listed in your chart: altogether, there are more than a hundred actors, that altogether represent 12 000 startups. You can find details at http://www.retis-innovation.fr/.