Your documentary project sounds fascinating, and I’ll be watching with great interest.
It would take an enormous amount of persuasion, however, for me to endorse a system that didn’t let everyone participate. But I’m definitely willing to listen!
This reminds me of the Asimov short story, “Franchise” — which you’ve no doubt read.
The user experience on the web has deteriorated a lot over the years, in large part due to the way the advertising networks have been allowed to operate. They push bloated, annoying, and sometimes invasive code onto our machines. So I don’t blame users who use ad/tracker blockers at all.