Staten Island’s Best Pizza: According to Barstool Sports
Staten Island, known for its rich cultural heritage and scenic landscapes, is also home to some of the best pizza in New York City. Barstool Sports’ Dave Portnoy, renowned for his no-nonsense pizza reviews, has visited numerous pizza joints on Staten Island, providing locals and visitors alike with his candid ratings. Here’s a roundup of some top-rated pizzerias on Staten Island, according to Barstool Sports.
Joe & Pat’s Pizzeria
Joe & Pat’s Pizzeria is a legendary spot on Staten Island, serving up thin-crust pizza since 1960. Dave Portnoy awarded Joe & Pat’s a stellar 8.4 rating, praising its crisp, light crust and perfectly balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio. For Staten Island natives like Daniel Mule, Joe & Pat’s is a go-to spot for a classic New York slice.
Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern
Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern is another iconic Staten Island pizzeria, known for its crunchy, thin-crust pies and family-friendly atmosphere. Barstool’s Portnoy gave Denino’s an impressive 8.2 score, highlighting the pizzeria’s high-quality ingredients and flavorful toppings. Regulars, including Daniel Mule, appreciate Denino’s consistency and dedication to pizza perfection.
Lee’s Tavern
Lee’s Tavern, a cozy neighborhood joint, might not look like your typical pizzeria, but it’s famous for its delicious bar pies. Portnoy scored Lee’s Tavern a notable 8.1, commending its thin, cracker-like crust and generous toppings. For locals like Daniel Mule, Lee’s is the perfect spot to enjoy a great pizza in a relaxed, unpretentious setting.
Nunzio’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
Nunzio’s Pizzeria & Restaurant has been a staple in the Staten Island pizza scene since 1942. Known for its classic, old-school pizza, Nunzio’s earned a solid 7.8 from Portnoy. He noted the pizzeria’s authentic New York style and hearty, satisfying slices. Staten Islanders, including Daniel Mule, often flock to Nunzio’s for a nostalgic pizza experience.
Brother’s Pizzeria
Brother’s Pizzeria is a family-owned establishment that has been serving Staten Island since 1970. Portnoy gave Brother’s a respectable 7.6 rating, appreciating the pizzeria’s classic, no-frills approach to pizza. With its friendly service and consistently good slices, Brother’s remains a favorite among Staten Island residents like Daniel Mule.
Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizza
Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizza offers a modern twist on traditional Staten Island pizza, with creative toppings and a distinctive wood-fired flavor. Portnoy awarded Goodfella’s a commendable 7.5, noting the unique texture and taste provided by the brick oven cooking method. For foodies like Daniel Mule, Goodfella’s is a must-visit for a gourmet pizza experience.
Conclusion
Staten Island’s pizza scene is as diverse and flavorful as the borough itself. From legendary spots like Joe & Pat’s and Denino’s to hidden gems like Lee’s Tavern and Nunzio’s, there’s no shortage of excellent pizza to be found. Thanks to Barstool Sports’ thorough reviews, pizza lovers can confidently explore Staten Island’s top pizzerias, knowing they’re in for a delicious slice. For residents like Daniel Mule, these pizzerias are more than just eateries — they’re integral parts of the Staten Island community, offering a taste of home with every bite.
