A lot of teams have tried it with terrible results. I remember a solid dig at the superteam model by the Eagles some years ago with the blessings from the anlytics people (Barnwell, FO) that’s gone completely wrong.

But, for the sake of this conversation, last year’s Broncos had “superteam” potential, and was constructed by smart digs at free agency by Elway and his team. It jost so happened that Manning stopped being Manning.