Keep Your Internet Off My Things

We are not ready for the Internet of Things. Not even close.

Allen Downey
2 min readSep 19, 2019

This is my toaster.

My toaster

It is not connected to the Internet.

I own it.

I can sell it.

If it breaks, I can fix it or reuse the parts.

It works when the network is down.

It was not released as a beta version.

It does not have any software bugs.

I never have to update the firmware.

It was not designed to become obsolete.

I am not locked in to this brand of toaster.

I have no ongoing business relationship with the manufacturer.

They can’t shut it down, or limit its performance.

If they go out of business, my toaster will keep working.

I don’t have a password on their web site.

Their web site has never been hacked, revealing my personal information.

They don’t call me or send me email.

I don’t have to deal with their customer support.

I didn’t sign a license agreement without reading it.

They’ve never updated their privacy policies.

They don’t collect data about my toast-making behavior.

They don’t sell my data to companies that make bread, jam, or health insurance.

They don’t record my conversations. Or my children’s.

I will never read a news story about the company misusing the data they collect.

My toaster does not show me ads.

I paid for it, and I am not the product.

This is my toaster.

This article was prompted by The Economist: “Chips with everything: How the world will change as computers spread into everyday objects

For more about toasters, I recommend Thomas Thwaites’ excellent book, The Toaster Project (affiliate link).

--

--

Allen Downey

I am a Professor at Olin College and author of Think Python, Think Bayes, and other books about computation and data science.