The Tragic Life Of Juana Maria, The Lone Woman Of San Nicolas Island

Scott O’Dell’s 1960 classic, Island of the Blue Dolphins, is based on her life

Weird History
Feb 28, 2018 · 7 min read

By Setareh Janda

Anyone who grew up reading Scott O’Dell’s classic Island of the Blue Dolphins was probably captivated by the main character. She is a young woman who lives on an island in the Pacific Ocean totally alone. Her entire tribe has left the island, while she remains behind. Many people may not know or realize that O’Dell based his novel on a real event and a real life: that of Juana Maria, the Lone Woman of San Nicolas Island.

Born sometime in the early 19th century — no one knows for certain when — the woman who would eventually be known as Juana Maria of San Nicolas Island spent a significant portion of her life completely isolated from human contact. Though she was ultimately removed from her solitude in 1853, her future off the island was a brief one.

Historians have been able to piece together relatively few facts about Juana’s life. Taken as a whole, they reveal a tragic, heartbreaking story of a woman who, even when found, still remained lost in so many ways. Like the Trail of Tears that Native Americans were forced to take to her East, Juana Maria’s story is one that maps the contours of 19th-century Native American tragedy at the hands of European colonialism.

In 1835, there were only around 20 people left in her tribe

Source: Wikimedia Commons

San Nicolas Island is one of California’s Channel Islands. Juana Maria’s tribe, known as the Nicoleños, lived on the island for somewhere around 10,000 years. Their long history on the island could not protect them from tragedy, however. In 1811 or 1814 — when Juana Maria may have been a small child — disaster struck. A group of Native Alaskan and Russian otter hunters attacked the island and devastated the local population. The tribe’s population had stood at 300 people, and it was reduced to dozens in the wake of the attack. By 1835, the population was around 20 individuals.

The remaining tribe members were removed from the island by Catholic priests

Source: Wikimedia Commons

In 1835, Juana Maria’s entire tribe was removed from San Nicolas Island. They didn’t leave by choice: Catholic priests on the mainland specifically requested that the entire Nicoleño tribe be evacuated. The priests’ motivations remain unclear. Were they evacuating the tribe because they worried they could not sustain their livelihood on San Nicolas Island? Or, more sinisterly, did they simply want more bodies to convert? Like much of Juana Maria’s story, these questions will probably never get answers.

Juana got left behind on the island, but no one really knows why

Source: Wikimedia Commons

The rest of Juana Maria’s small tribe was successfully removed from the island by Catholic priests in 1835. Juana didn’t make if off, however. Why was she left behind? There is no definitive answer. One story claims that she was absent from the group as they were being evacuated because she was out looking for her missing two-year-old child. Another story imagines Juana Maria jumping off the boat, believing that her little brother was still on the island. Whatever happened, an approaching storm meant that the ship departed San Nicolas in a hurry, leaving the woman behind.

Despite 18 years in solitude, she was discovered “smiling”

Source: Wikimedia Commons

After several futile attempts at locating the lost woman who failed to depart with the rest of her tribe in 1835, the Captain of a ship called the Peores Nada, a man by the name of George Nidever, finally located Juana Maria in 1853. In his memoir, The Life and Adventures of George Nidever, the Captain recounted the moment they discovered Juana, whom he described as an “old woman,” busily stripping whale blubber.

Instead of darting away from the Captain and his crew, she: “smiled and bowed, chattering away to them in an unintelligible language.” She was “of medium height… about 50 years old but… still strong and active. Her face was pleasing as she was continually smiling… Her clothing consisted of but a single garment of skins.”

She lived in a whalebone hut during her 18 solitary years on the island

Source: Wikimedia Commons

The ship that left without Juana Maria never returned, and she was left alone on San Nicolas Island for 18 years. It’s hard to say what impact total isolation had on Juana Maria. But she was resourceful and went about her life; she hunted seals and ducks and made clothing and a shelter. When her rescuers found her in 1853, they discovered that she had built a hut out of whale bones and was probably living in a nearby cave.

When she was finally found, she had no way of communicating with anyone

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Juana Maria’s solitude didn’t end as soon as she was re-discovered in 1853. When she was brought to the Santa Barbara mission, she could not communicate with anyone. She was clearly speaking a Native language, one no one could understand. So, after she had been found, she couldn’t tell anyone her harrowing — or triumphant — story. To this day, scholars do not know what exact language Juana Maria spoke.

By the time Juana was brought to the mainland, she had become the last surviving member of her tribe

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Further tragedy awaited those Nicoleños who departed San Nicolas Island in 1835. The ship that took them from the island was the Peor es Nada, which translates to “better than nothing.” Though the ship ran aground in San Francisco Bay, the survivors moved to the San Gabriel Mission. Unfortunately, lack of immunity to the diseases they encountered on the mainland got the better of the Nicoleños, and they all died. By the time Juana Maria reached the mainland in 1853, she had become the last member of her tribe.

She died after only seven weeks on the mainland

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Though Juana Maria found human contact again in 1853, she only got to enjoy it for seven short weeks. After living in solitude for nearly two decades, her immune system was quite vulnerable when she arrived in Santa Barbara. She quickly contracted dysentery. She tragically died on October 19, 1853, leaving essentially nothing but mystery in her wake.

No one knows her real name

Source: Wikimedia Commons

There’s a good reason that Juana Maria is known simply as the “Lone Woman of San Nicolas Island” to many scholars: no one knows her real name. Catholic priests gave her the name Juana Maria only after she had been taken to Mission Santa Barbara. In Island of the Blue Dolphins, she is named “Karana.” But there is no historical evidence for what her real name actually was.

She became a local curiosity in Santa Barbara and was dubbed “the wild woman”

Source: Wikimedia Commons

When she finally came to Santa Barbara in 1853, the locals treated her like a curiosity, especially since no one could actually talk to her. She was dubbed the “wild woman.” Newspapers reported on how she was acclimating to life at the Santa Barbara mission, even noting that she marveled at the horses around the mission and enjoyed coffee and liquor. She even performed songs and dances for those who came to look at the “wild woman.”

Priests converted her to Catholicism — likely without her consent

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Though Juana Maria was brought to the Santa Barbara mission in 1853, there is absolutely no reason to believe that she was a Christian. After all, Mission Santa Barbara was effectively a colonial outpost for Spanish Catholicism. But Juana’s religious affiliation changed over the course of her stay — with or without her consent. On October 19, 1853, a priest baptized her on her deathbed. Since she could not communicate, it is unlikely that she knew a priest was claiming her soul for the Christian God.

Many of the objects associated with Juana Maria have been lost

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Juana Maria brought some objects with her to Santa Barbara from San Nicolas Island, including bone needles that she had probably used to make a dress from cormorant feathers. Unfortunately, those objects had been housed in San Francisco and were destroyed in the great San Francisco Earthquake of 1906. Additionally, her cormorant dress has also disappeared, notably, after being shipped to the Vatican. It’s as if all traces of her life have slipped away, further erasing her from the record.

Weird History

Written by

History is weird. A lot weirder than you think. Follow us on Facebook:

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch
Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore
Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade