Why I Left Christianity after 15 Years: A Personal Deconstruction

Enrico Leigh
4 min readOct 31, 2023

--

Photo by Rod Long on Unsplash

For 15 years, I was a devoted Christian. I actively participated in church, served as an elder, and spent hours in prayer and contemplation, seeking a deeper connection with God. My faith was unwavering, and I yearned for a profound spiritual experience. However, there came a point in my journey when I could no longer bridge the gap between logic, fact, and faith. This internal conflict led to a significant decision: I chose to leave Christianity.

My departure from Christianity was not the result of personal grievances within the church, nor was it driven by a desire to indulge in sinful behaviour. It occurred at the pinnacle of my faith, during a time when I was actively seeking God (and yes, I was truly “saved” and did have a true relationship with God, for the calvinists out there). In my fervent prayers, I implored God to reveal Himself to me in a deeper way, even if it meant facing the prospect of eternal damnation in my quest for truth.

The core of my struggle did not lie with the church or Christianity as a whole; it revolved around the concept of God as a cosmic being and the notion of a single, exclusive path to reach that cosmic being. My disenchantment with traditional religious beliefs led to a process of deconstruction, where I challenged long-held doctrines and sought a more inclusive perspective.

One of the key factors in my decision to leave Christianity was the increasing difficulty I faced in reconciling my faith with reason and empirical evidence. The divide between the tenets of Christianity and the findings of science and critical thinking became a chasm that I could no longer ignore. As someone who values intellectual honesty, I could not suppress my doubts and questions in the name of faith. This internal conflict became a driving force in my journey towards deconstruction.

Contrary to the assumptions of many Christians, my decision to distance myself from Christianity was not motivated by negative experiences with fellow church members. While I acknowledge that no religious community is free from interpersonal conflicts, my spiritual journey was guided by a desire to seek ultimate truth rather than being influenced by personal disputes.

Similarly, my exit from Christianity was not a covert attempt to justify or indulge in sinful behaviour. The moral and ethical principles instilled in me during my Christian upbringing remain an integral part of my identity. My decision was rooted in a quest for spiritual and philosophical clarity rather than a desire for moral laxity.

The defining moment of my deconstruction journey occurred when I reached the zenith of my faith. As an elder within the church, I was dedicated to my spiritual growth and the well-being of my congregation. During this time, my prayers intensified. I earnestly beseeched God to manifest Himself to me in a profound way, and I was willing to endure the most agonising consequences if it meant finding the ultimate truth.

In my prayers, I confronted a dilemma. The God I had envisioned, an all-knowing, all-loving deity, appeared to be hidden in the shadows of ambiguity. The silence of the divine in response to my earnest cries left me questioning the foundations of my faith. I began to ponder whether the existence of God was absolute, or if the concept of God was a manifestation of human imagination.

The heart of my spiritual quandary was not the church or the broader Christian community. Rather, it was the notion that there could only be one exclusive path to God, a single absolute truth. The presumption that one religion held the monopoly on divine insight was a source of inner turmoil. I grappled with the pride of exclusivity, the idea that all other religious traditions were inferior or misguided.

In my quest for a more inclusive understanding of spirituality, I encountered the metaphor of the blind men and the elephant. This parable illustrated that different religions may offer unique perspectives on the divine, akin to blind men touching different parts of an elephant and describing it differently. The idea of a collective truth, where each religion holds a fragment of the cosmic reality, resonated with me. It allowed for a more open-minded exploration of spirituality.

In essence, my decision to leave Christianity was the culmination of a deeply personal and intellectual journey. It was not driven by external factors but rather by an unwavering commitment to truth, intellectual integrity, and a more inclusive perspective on spirituality. While my path has led me away from traditional Christian beliefs, it has opened the door to a broader exploration of the human quest for the divine.

As I continue to navigate this post-Christian phase of my life, I find solace in the idea that the pursuit of truth and the quest for meaning are not confined to a single religious tradition. Instead, they are universal endeavours that transcend the boundaries of any one faith. My journey of deconstruction has allowed me to embrace a more expansive, inclusive, and intellectually honest approach to spirituality.

In conclusion, my departure from Christianity after 15 years was marked by a profound process of deconstruction. It was driven by an inner struggle to reconcile faith with reason, a desire for a more inclusive spiritual perspective, and a pursuit of ultimate truth. While my journey has taken me away from conventional Christian beliefs, it has opened the door to a broader exploration of spirituality and a deeper appreciation for the collective wisdom of humanity’s spiritual traditions.

--

--

Enrico Leigh

Embarking on a cosmic quest, juggling roles in the galaxy of life – from parenting to battling the mind's mysteries.