Website Analysis on Migration to US from Mexico

Summary

Alex Jackson is a University of Leeds student with a passion in studying Geography. His website really emphasizes his passion in Geography with the different articles and facts he provides about different areas around the world. The article of focus within this post is in regards to migration specifically from Mexico. Jackson splits up his post into three major sections: location, reasons for migration, and impacts. Within those three headings, Jackson also provides subheadings to further detail reasons for migration and its impacts. The article is written mostly in bulleted form for clarity on each specific point that Jackson makes. Jackson’s primary goal is to factually and synctly identify and explain why individuals from Mexico migrates to the United States. He goes on to further explain the specific push and pull factors justifying the migration of Mexicans, which include explanations of poverty, lifestyle, education, crime, and climate. In addition to providing the push and pull factors, Jackson also explains the social and economic impacts of migration from Mexico. These impacts include agricultural damages in Mexico, assimilation, concern of increased crime in the US, and a decline of Mexico as a country. Jackson does not provide much of an closing analysis despite providing strong evidence.

It’s Credibility

There are several factors to consider when thinking about the credibility of this website (or any website for that matter): author, purpose, objectivity, accuracy, reliability and credibility, currency, and links. Alex Jackson displays his understanding of resource credibility as he provides sufficient amount of detail in his explanations of each part of his website. However, specific analysis of migration to United States seems to be misinterpreted through Jackson’s analysis. Moreover, when considering migration (from Mexico to the US), it requires a deeper understanding of the social, economic, and physical influences and instigators of migration. What Jackson seems to provide is a personal analysis of “textbook answers”. Under careful consideration of each of these factors of credibility, it is clear that there are still areas of improvement in order for the site to stand as fully credible.

Proof of Credibility

Proof of Credibility in the Author
  • Author: The author of this web page is Alex Jackson, who is a University of Leeds student studying Geophysics. He is the sole writer of the website, but he notes that he is willing to provide space for people to also contribute to the site. In the “About” tab, he tells a little about his hobbies and interest in video games providing a more personal connection to the writer. Jackson seems to be qualified to write this web page particularly utilizing his degree as a Geophysics major with a strong interest in geography, and also with the support of the University of Leeds, England. The domain of Jackson’s webpage is: https://geographyas.info/population/mexico-to-usa-migration/ and his direct contact email is alex@geographyas.info.
Proof of Credibility in the Purpose
  • Purpose: The purpose of Jackson’s post is particularly to inform individuals who are interested in geography and/or the general public. The part of his webpage that focuses on migration from Mexico to the US seems to serve, from the writer’s perspective, solely as a factual based and informative piece. There is no clear sense of persuasion, rather than a stronger sense of teaching and explaining.
Proof of Credibility in Objectivity
  • Objectivity: The author writes using non-bias and emotion free language, and he notes that his page was primarily and initially to only to keep track of his notes to share with individuals who missed class. Eventually, his work developed out of his interest. Despite the primarily purpose of the content, the author still provides a lot of factual information. Jackson is not clearly affiliated with any organization, but does note his attendance at the University of Leeds in England.
Proof of Credibility in Accuracy
  • Accuracy: Accuracy of Jackson’s website is where there lies some questions. Jackson’s web page is specifically called “Geography AS Notes” signifying that these are notes of Alex Jackson. However, when a reader visits Jackson’s page on migration from Mexico to the US, it is clear that there is no clear recognition of resources that back each of the notes that he lists. He has no reference list or clear way of verifying that the information that he has provided is correct. He solely has a very organized website that provides bullet points of each of his topics.
Proof of Credibility in Reliability and Credibility
  • Reliability and Credibility: Based solely off of reading about Alex Jackson and my personal knowledge on migration from Mexico to the US, in some manners, the information Jackson provides is credible and well-researched. However, it is not evident that Jackson’s material is supported by any institution, which leads to question whether or not all of his information throughout his web page is reliable and credible. Specifically in regards to migration from Mexico to the US, it is clear that Jackson does not have the best personal understanding that it requires to analyze why individuals migrate from Mexico to the US.
Proof of Credibility in Currency
  • Currency: Migration is an ever changing social aspect. With many things developing and more and more research showing that migration from Mexico to the US is actually declining, Alex Jackson needs to provide more up-to-date information or a more frequently update on “changes of migration”.
Proof of Credibility in the Link
  • Links:The primary thing to notice about the link is specifically that it does not end in a .gov or .edu, rather with a .info. The most credible resources are backed by specific information that has been heavily researched. While the web page is aesthetically pleasing, credibility can be questioned solely due the website link’s lack of .edu or .gov.

Resource:

Jackson, Alex. “Geography AS Notes.” Mexico to USA Migration. N.p., n.d. Web. 16 Mar. 2017.

Show your support

Clapping shows how much you appreciated PeMo’s story.