Can You Answer One Question?

Nope.

Eric Egan
2 min readMar 9, 2023

--

The camera is on a set of empty tracks that fade off into the horizon. The blur of a speeding train is on tracks to the left.
Adobe Stock image edited by me.

I am working on a project with a section similar to the old trolly philosophy dilemma but with a new twist. The first two scenarios set up the question of the 3rd. The one I am having trouble finding adequate words.

Scenario 1

You are an engineer driving a train. On the tracks ahead, you see a large group of people. If you continue, you will kill the group. Luckily, you can switch to a 2nd set of tracks and save the group. However, there is one person on the 2nd set of tracks that you will kill if you do switch. You have ten seconds to decide.

Your ONLY options are:

A. Kill the group.
B. Kill the one.

What would you do?

Scenario 2

The same situation as above, except it’s your child on the 2nd set of tracks.

You have ten seconds to decide.

Your ONLY options are:

A. Kill the group of people.
B. Kill your child.

What would you do?

Scenario 3

You and your family and friends are the group on the main track. The train’s driver can see her baby on the 2nd set of tracks. What do you want the…

--

--

Eric Egan
Eric Egan

Written by Eric Egan

IT professional with over 25 years of experience • Masters in Cybersecurity • Certified Ethical Hacker • Now studying Natural Technology.

No responses yet