Eyebrow Mascaras

Wesley Burke
15 min readSep 17, 2024
Eyebrow-Mascara-1

Get ready to elevate your brows with the latest innovation in beauty - Eyebrow Mascara. This game-changing product is revolutionizing the way we define, shape, and enhance our eyebrows. In this roundup, we bring you the top picks for Eyebrow Mascara, so you can achieve the perfect arch with ease.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you.

Reviews

You've Got Brow: Deep Brown Eyebrow Mascara for Flawless Arches

You’ve Got Brow: Deep Brown Eyebrow Mascara for Flawless Arches | Image

Get ready to revamp your brows with Youve Got Brow! This versatile brow gel allows you to elevate your natural assets, whether you prefer a dab of tint or a sleek, clear finish. Say farewell to the shadow of yesteryear's brows and welcome a brighter future filled with fabulous arches.

With a simple flick of the applicator, your brow game will be transformed to jaw-dropping heights. Choose from four shades plus a clear option, ensuring a flawless finish for any desired look. Embrace your perfectly shaped brows with ease and flaunt your bold, natural beauty!

Italian-made Lord & Berry Tinted Brow Mascara for Bold, Natural Eyebrows

Italian-made Lord & Berry Tinted Brow Mascara for Bold, Natural Eyebrows | Image

If you're in search of a must-have brow product that delivers a natural-looking, thickened effect, look no further than Lord & Berry's Must Have Tinted Brow Mascara in Blonde. Thanks to its creamy, gel texture and attractive, natural shade, you'll be able to fill in those pesky gaps and define your brows with ease.

Coating and grooming in one quick stroke, this tinted gem is a game-changer for anyone seeking the perfect brows. But beware, this product is Italy-made and if not used properly, it may dry out quickly. Overall, this tinted brow mascara earns high praise from users for its natural appearance, lasting formula, and precision brush.

Jill Stuart Mousse Brow Mascara for Defined Eyebrows

Jill Stuart Mousse Brow Mascara for Defined Eyebrows | Image

The Jill Stuart Mousse Brow Mascara is like your secret weapon that will quickly become your go-to makeup essential. It's the perfect blend of convenience and effectiveness, giving you the power to achieve the natural-looking brows you've always wanted.

Made with a creamy texture, this mascara is super easy to apply and feels light, not heavy. It gives that semi-matte effect that will make your brows look absolutely fabulous. It's just like wearing a superstar on your face, ready to steal some shine.

But here's one of the best parts: it's quite resistant to sweat, sebum, and even the annoying rubbing off. So yes, you can wear this to the gym without any worries. And when you're done, simply immerse a cotton pad in hot water, and it's all gone. No mess, no fuss.

The mini-brush design is a game-changer. It's super manageable, and you can easily apply it to those small, tricky areas. The brush is so fine that it doesn't stick to the skin, just the perfect amount of product right where you need it.

In addition to all these superstar features, it also comes with a lovely crystal floral bouquet fragrance. Just close your eyes and breathe in the aroma of tranquility. It's like a spa day in a tube.

Overall, the Jill Stuart Mousse Brow Mascara is quite the rave among makeup enthusiasts. It's loved for its natural-looking effect, ease of use, and long-wear capabilities. It's definitely a product worth trying.

Nyx Tinted Brow Mascara for Brunettes

Nyx Tinted Brow Mascara for Brunettes | Image

Recently, I had the chance to give the Nyx Professional Makeup Tinted Brow Mascara Brunette a try, and I must say, it quickly became a staple in my makeup routine. The first thing that stood out to me was the natural finish it provided; the Brunette color definitely added a touch of elegance to my brows while still looking like my own.

The brush applicator made all the difference when applying this product. It offered a seamless and even application, ensuring that my brows were perfectly shaped every time. The formula proved to be quite robust, as it easily smudged a little but thankfully was quite easy to remove after a long day.

One downside I encountered was the packaging; I wish they had chosen a more premium finish to match the quality of their formula. Nonetheless, this tinted brow mascara has become an absolute must-have for those seeking natural-looking, long-lasting results.

NYX Tinted Brow Mascara: Espresso Finish for Enhanced Eyebrows

NYX Tinted Brow Mascara: Espresso Finish for Enhanced Eyebrows | Image

Get ready for naturally enhanced brows with NYX Cosmetics Tinted Brow Mascara. Available in 5 shades, this mascara not only tints and tames your brows, but also guarantees a natural appearance. Eyebrow enthusiasts will love the precise and long-lasting formula that adds a touch of thickness and fullness, perfect for both subtle and bold brow looks.

The applicator makes application easy and precise, while the formula ensures soft and tangle-free brows. However, some users have reported concerns about the packaging quality and the mascara's smudging tendencies on humid days. Nonetheless, the overall experience is widely appreciated for its natural appearance and cost-effectiveness.

Pastel Profashion Dark Brown Eyebrow Mascara

Pastel Profashion Dark Brown Eyebrow Mascara | Image

Eyebrow mascara has become an essential part of my daily routine. The creamy formula allows for easy application, and the three different colors give my eyebrows the right shade. Not only does it maintain their shape all day, but it also adds the perfect amount of volume.

What really stands out is the intense, soft, and natural look it provides to my eyes, making them pop without being too over-the-top. However, I must say that the product seems to dry out quickly, which can make it difficult to apply after a while.

Nonetheless, it's still a great product that I'll definitely continue using.

1000 Hour Clear Eyebrow Mascara for Instant Makeover

1000 Hour Clear Eyebrow Mascara for Instant Makeover | Image

Recently, I tried the 1000 Hour Instant Brows brush-on tinted eyebrow mascara in clear. It's a buildable clear gel suitable for all hair colors, providing a gloss and shine to my eyebrows for a professional look every day.

One of the first things I noticed was how easy it was to apply. The brush made it simple to control the amount of product applied, giving me the look I wanted without any hassle. I loved that I could enhance my natural color and achieve a professional appearance without needing a makeup artist.

As for the color, the clear option was perfect for my blonde eyebrows. It gave them a subtle definition that looked very natural, but stayed in place all day. However, I did find that it left a slight white crustiness on my brows after an hour. It's not something I would notice or have an issue with, but my husband (who is very observant) did mention it to me.

One thing I liked about this product was that it didn't easily wipe away. I was concerned that my brows would be accidentally wiped off throughout the day, but this product stayed put nicely. The formula definitely stood out for me, and I think it was a great choice for my eyebrow needs.

The removal process was also easy; I didn't find it difficult to take off the mascara at the end of the day. Overall, my experience with the 1000 Hour Instant Brows clear mascara was quite positive. The formula was great, the application process was simple, and I liked the way it looked on my brows. That being said, I would love to see more applicator options in the future for some variety, as the one I used was quite thick for my fine brows.

Petite N Pretty Featherlight Clear Brow Gel

Petite N Pretty Featherlight Clear Brow Gel | Image

As a makeup enthusiast, I've always been on the lookout for products that are easy to use and offer natural results. The Petite N Pretty Featherlight Clear Mascara and Brow Gel seemed like the perfect fit for me. The brand is known for its age-appropriate and pediatrician-approved beauty tools, making it a great choice for young users like me.

When I first applied the product, I was amazed at how lightweight and effortless it was. The clear formula made it perfect for achieving a natural, featherlight look. Using it to set my brows was a breeze - the wand glided smoothly, and the mascara added subtle definition. I appreciated the dermatologist-approved formula, which was crucial for my sensitive skin.

One downside I noticed was that the mascara sometimes smudged a little, making it less effective for lengthening or volumizing. However, as a brow gel, it performed admirably, holding my brows in place for most of the day. I would have liked the product to be a bit more budget-friendly for its size, but overall, I was pleased with my purchase.

The Petite N Pretty Featherlight Clear Mascara and Brow Gel proved to be a versatile and effective addition to my makeup routine, thanks to its easy application and natural finish. I highly recommend this product to anyone seeking a lightweight, clear mascara and brow gel that delivers subtle yet noticeable results.

Thrive Causemetics Instant Brow Fix Eyebrow Gel in Serena (Deep Brown) - Vegan & Cruelty-Free

Thrive Causemetics Instant Brow Fix Eyebrow Gel in Serena (Deep Brown) — Vegan & Cruelty-Free | Image

Experience flawless, natural-looking brows with Instant Brow Fix Semi-Permanent Eyebrow Gel by Thrive Causemetics. This innovative, 100% vegan formula boasts a 4.1-star rating and is praised for its hypoallergenic, organic, and mercury-free ingredients. Say goodbye to messy mascaras and smudging, as this gel provides a flexible and long-lasting hold. Available in 8 inclusive shades, Instant Brow Fix seamlessly matches your brows while the Gray Delay Complex works to diminish gray hairs over time. Perfect for all-day wear, this vegan gem delivers effortless application and smudge-proof, sweat-proof color that lasts.

L'oreal Unbelieva Brow: Long Wear, Waterproof Brunette Brow Gel for Natural-Looking Eyebrows

L’oreal Unbelieva Brow: Long Wear, Waterproof Brunette Brow Gel for Natural-Looking Eyebrows | Image

The L'Oreal Unbelieva Brow is a versatile and long-lasting brow gel that offers a waterproof, smudge-resistant solution for those seeking a durable finish for their eyebrows. Available in a range of natural-looking shades, the product is suitable for those with sparse or lightly colored brows, providing a simple and effective method of achieving a fuller, more defined appearance. The angled brush applicator allows for precise application and definition of brow shape, while the spoolie helps to comb through and blend the product for a more natural look. With a rating of 4.2 out of 5 from over 5,000 reviews, Unbelieva Brow has been applauded for its ease of removal, ease of application, good pigmentation, and effective waterproof formula, making it a popular choice for those seeking a high-quality, long-lasting brow gel.

Ardell Light Brown Eyebrow Tint

Ardell Light Brown Eyebrow Tint | Image

In my quest for perfectly defined eyebrows, I've come across quite a few options. Each one seemed to promise the moon, but only a few delivered on their promises. This is where Ardell Brow Tint in Light Brown came in. At first glance, it appeared like just another brow tint - a powdery substance mixed with a liquid developer, accompanied by a few tools to help with the application.

However, the experience of using this product was truly enlightening. The tint itself seemed to be just the right depth for my light-colored brows; not too dark for a natural look, yet not too light to be subtle. The application was surprisingly easy. The tools provided, while perhaps not the prettiest on the market, were practical and functional.

The highlight of my Ardell experience was the permanence of the tint. Gone were the days of redoing my brows every few days; the tint would last two weeks uninterrupted. This was a real game-changer for me. The time I saved by not having to reapply the product was a huge plus.

Though the tint was effective and convenient, it wasn't entirely perfect. The removal process was a bit more challenging than I anticipated. The tint was quite persistent, which meant it needed a bit more effort to remove. And the reapplication process was a delicate one, as the tint seemed to tint my skin slightly, making me a bit more cautious with the application.

In conclusion, Ardell Brow Tint in Light Brown provided an effective, convenient method for achieving the perfect brow without the need for frequent salon visits. Though it may have taken a bit of trial and error to figure out, in the long run, it proved to be a worthwhile investment.

Essence Make Me Brow Eyebrow Gel Mascara for Perfectly Groomed Brows

Essence Make Me Brow Eyebrow Gel Mascara for Perfectly Groomed Brows | Image

Transform your brows with the Essence Make Me Brow Eyebrow Gel Mascara - your secret weapon for perfectly groomed and natural-looking brows. This innovative formula provides just the right amount of color and holds to shape your brows and fill in any sparse areas.

The small, precise brush effortlessly coats each hair, creating a polished, feathery result that elevates your entire look. Plus, it's available in three versatile shades to suit any hair color. With a comfortable applicator and easy-to-use formula, this brow mascara is a must-have addition to any makeup routine.

Sculpting Gel Brows Mascara by Maybelline - Clear

Sculpting Gel Brows Mascara by Maybelline — Clear | Image

This beauty is a game-changer for brow lovers everywhere. Maybelline's Eye Studio Brow Drama offers a stunning gel mousse combined with a ball brush that sculpts your brows to perfection with just one swipe.

The formula is a dream, providing exceptional natural-looking pigmentation without clumping or flaking. And, don't worry about washing it off - it's waterproof. So, get ready to slay the brow game with ease and style.

Buyer's Guide

Eyebrow mascara is a popular beauty product that can help define, fill, and shape your eyebrows. It's a convenient and quick option for those looking to enhance their natural brows. In this section, we will discuss the important features, considerations, and general advice for eyebrow mascara.

Important Features to Consider

When purchasing an eyebrow mascara, there are several factors to take into account. These include the following:

  1. Ingredients: Check the label to ensure that the mascara is safe for your skin, and avoid products with harsh chemicals or fragrances that may cause irritation. 2. Color: Select a shade that closely matches your natural brow color for a natural look or choose a darker shade to create a more dramatic effect. 3. Applicator: Look for a mascara with a fine, narrow brush for precise application and a curved wand to help define and shape your brows. 4. Volume: Consider whether you prefer a volumizing formula to help fill in sparse areas or a lightweight formula that won't weigh down your brows.

Considerations Before Purchase

Before making a purchase, take these factors into consideration:

  1. Allergies: If you have sensitive skin or allergies, it's essential to test the mascara on a small area before applying it to your face. 2. Budget: Determine how much you're willing to spend on an eyebrow mascara, as there are options at various price points. 3. Brands: Research different brands and read reviews to find a reputable and high-quality product. 4. Makeup Routine: Consider whether an eyebrow mascara fits into your daily makeup routine and if it's convenient for on-the-go touch-ups.

General Advice and Tips

For the best results with an eyebrow mascara, follow these tips:

  1. Apply the mascara in short, quick strokes, starting from the inner part of your brow and working your way out. 2. Use a spoolie brush to brush through your brows, ensuring an even and natural-looking finish. 3. For a natural look, choose a shade closer to your brows and minimize the amount of product applied. 4. For a more dramatic effect, choose a darker shade and apply multiple coats.

Storing and Expiration

Proper storage and expiration are essential for the longevity and safety of your eyebrow mascara. Here are some recommendations:

  1. Store the mascara in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. 2. Keep the cap tightly sealed when not in use to prevent contamination. 3. Check the expiration date on the product and discard it if it's past the recommended lifespan (usually 6 to 12 months after opening). 4. Wash your applicator regularly with soap and warm water to prevent bacterial buildup.

FAQ

What is eyebrow mascara?

Eyebrow mascara is a beauty product specifically designed to enhance and define the appearance of eyebrows. It is used to darken sparse or light-colored brows, add fullness and texture, and help hold eyebrow hairs in place. Eyebrow mascara is available in a variety of shades and can be applied using a wand or brush.

It is an alternative option to eyebrow pencils, gels, or powders and is suitable for all skin types and hair colors. It offers a quick and easy way to achieve well-defined brows and is perfect for daily use or special occasions. Some forms of eyebrow mascaras are equipped with a tinted powder or tinted wax to fill in gaps between hairs, giving users the illusion of fuller, darker, and more prominent eyebrows.

How is eyebrow mascara used?

Using eyebrow mascara is fairly simple. Begin by brushing your eyebrows upwards with a spoolie brush to create a natural-looking direction. Once you have achieved this, apply the eyebrow mascara using the provided wand or brush and glide it through your brows. Ensure that you apply the mascara as close to your hair follicles as possible for better coverage. You can also use the spoolie brush to blend in the mascara for a more natural look.

After applying, wait a few seconds for the mascara to set before moving on to the next step. You can also use the mascara wands to separate the hairs and give them a natural, feathery appearance. Be sure to clean the wand between each use to avoid clumping and promote a more even application. Additionally, you can use a small, angled eyeliner brush to touch up any stray hairs or areas that require more attention.

Is eyebrow mascara suitable for all skin types?

Yes, eyebrow mascaras are suitable for all skin types. They are formulated with ingredients that are non-irritating and non-comedogenic, meaning they will not clog pores or cause irritation. Some brands also have tinted brow gels available, which are perfect for those with sensitive skin or allergies.

When choosing an eyebrow mascara, it is essential to consider your skin type and choose a product that is designed for sensitive skin if you have any concerns. It is also recommended to do a patch test before fully committing to a product to ensure that it does not cause any adverse reactions. For added convenience, opt for waterproof mascara that will stay put even during sweaty or rainy conditions.

How should I clean my eyebrow mascara wand or brush?

Cleaning your eyebrow mascara wand or brush is crucial to ensure even application and prevent clumping. Always wash your wand or brush immediately after use to remove any excess product. You can use your fingertips or a small brush cleaner to gently remove the mascara from the wand or brush. After removing the mascara, rinse the wand or brush thoroughly under warm water.

If you are using your wand or brush for multiple eyebrow mascaras, it is essential to clean them separately to prevent cross-contamination of colors. Additionally, it is best to let the wand or brush dry completely before storing them in the container. This helps to prolong their life and ensure that they remain hygienic for future use. Some eyebrow mascaras also come with a spoolie brush, which is perfect for separating the brows, applying product, and removing any excess mascara.

What can I do if the eyebrow mascara smudges or fades throughout the day?

If the eyebrow mascara smudges or fades throughout the day, you can touch it up with a setting powder or eyeshadow to help set it in place. You can also apply a clear brow gel over the top of the mascara to help hold the brows in place and prevent smudging. If you have oily skin, it is recommended to opt for an oil-free or waterproof eyebrow mascara.

Another solution to prevent smudging is to apply a thin layer of eye primer before applying the mascara. This will help to create a barrier between the skin and the mascara, reducing the chances of smudging. Finally, make sure that you set the eyebrows in place with a clear-setting gel or a thin layer of hairspray. This will help to lock the brows in place and prevent any smudging or smearing throughout the day.

How often should I replace my eyebrow mascara?

Eyebrow mascaras should be replaced every 3-6 months, depending on personal use and the expiration date indicated by the manufacturer. After this period, the product may begin to dry out or harbor bacteria, which can lead to skin irritation or infections. It is best to follow the manufacturer's guidelines for the specific product you are using. If you notice any signs of mold, discoloration, or unusual odor, it is definitely time to toss the mascara and purchase a new one.

When replacing your eyebrow mascara, it is essential to sanitize the wand or brush before using it again to avoid cross-contamination between different products. You can do this by dipping the wand or brush in antibacterial hand gel or spraying it with rubbing alcohol. Always remember to store your mascara in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight and heat to ensure its longevity and to prevent degradation of its consistency and color.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you.

--

--