SJW Behaviors That Hurt Social Justice
Sara Lynn Michener
1.92K94

Sara, I like a lot of your article but I do have a quibble with the example of 10. I’m no expert on the women’s march and there’s likely someone better who has already responded to you on this point but here’s what I have to say:

First off: There’s no such thing as “female” genitalia and that way of wording only reinforces the lack of inclusion that transwomen and non-binary folks (it wasn’t just transwomen who found this march isolating FYI) felt.

Second: The GOP’s “relentless…” etc. also harms transwomen and trans people more generally. If intersectionality goes both ways then why not mention that as well? Would it take many more resources so as to make it untenable? If so, why?

Third: The march was a response to *specific* issues but those *specific* issues don’t *only* harm cis women. And acting like they do through “pussy hats” and centering cis women’s experiences via abortion clinics is a really poor way to get your message across. And suggesting that (as some have) *isn’t* the same as saying those things shouldn’t be mentioned at all.

Fourth: Relatedly, is opening the floor up more to transwomen and non-binary folks necessarily closing off the floor for cis women? That seems unlikely, especially given their relative population sizes. It seems like a trivial thing to me to open it up for both parties. Where’s the problem?

Fifth: Your “spend more time” remark presumes ignorance on the part of anyone criticizing the march which seems pretty uncharitable to me. While it may be the case that some folks didn’t read everything there was about the march (I certainly didn’t) some of us saw enough news, conversations and popular symbology to feel excluded from a discourse we knew we weren’t meant to be included in from the start.

Lastly: If we’re here to “support and amplify each other’s lived experiences” and it “goes both ways” then the march utterly failed at that in some basic ways. Which was kind of the point of those criticisms you’re responding to in the first place.