Dreaming what you know in Ethiopia
ADDIS ABABA, Ethiopia — When Dr. Momina Ahmed was training to be a doctor, she never imagined that she would play a key role in Ethiopia’s first kidney transplant.
“As a young medical student, you are always full of energy and you dream — but not of transplants!” she said with a big laugh. “You dream what you know. Back then, we didn’t have the theoretical exposure let alone the practical exposure.”
But there she was last September preparing the patient for the historic procedure. Since then, a total 17 kidney transplants have been done at Ethiopia’s new Federal Kidney Transplant Center, where Dr. Momina serves as the clinical director.
The procedure is performed in only a few other countries in Sub-Saharan Africa. The rapid progress Ethiopia has made with transplants is one of the best examples of the ambitious and often dizzying reforms in its health-care system in recent years.
The kidney transplant surgeries wouldn’t have been possible without the capability to do dialysis. Dr. Momina was also the first in Ethiopia to be involved in bringing that capability to a public hospital. She does hemodialysis, which involves pumping blood out of the body to an artificial kidney machine that filters away toxins before returning the blood to the body.
“I had never seen hemodialysis when I was a medical student or resident. It was difficult to imagine hemodialysis service in a public hospital like St. Paul’s,” said the physician, who is also head of nephrology at St. Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College, where the transplant center is located in the capital, Addis Ababa.
But perhaps the biggest development happened about five years ago when St. Paul’s began collaborating with the University of Michigan in the U.S. — a partnership that former Minister of Health Dr. Tedros Adhanom was instrumental in establishing. As the architect of Ethiopia’s medical revolution, Dr. Tedros created a strategy that involved partnering with top-tier global institutions with reputations for sticking around for the long term.
The relationship with Michigan began with a program to train doctors in obstetrics and gynecology, an initiative driven by Dr. Senait Fisseha, an adjunct professor at the U.S. university. As the program grew, Dr. Senait got other physicians from Michigan involved in the initiative. One of them was Dr. Jeffrey Punch, a transplant surgeon.
Before he decided to get involved, Dr. Punch spent some time observing the Ethiopians operate. He also went to their clinics and saw them do teaching rounds. He was impressed with the surgeons’ dedication and shared goals.
“I really got the feeling that the quality people were really swimming to the top, and they were sticking with it,” he said. “There was a group of people who could have clearly emigrated and been successful elsewhere, but they were committed to their country and they wanted to do things.”
Dr. Punch has been training four Ethiopian surgeons, and he says they might be ready in at least a year. Generally, each surgeon will have to do about 20 transplants to be competent.
The procedure is different from heart or liver transplants, which involve removing the bad organ and replacing it with a new one. With kidney transplants, the native organ stays in the body and a new one is added. There’s no need to remove the old one because “the badness doesn’t spread to the other,” Dr. Punch said.
When the donated kidney is placed in the body, the surgeon must connect it with blood vessels that supply other things. “So you can’t mess that up or they lose their leg or intestines,” Punch said.
Critics might argue that something as complicated and expensive as a kidney transplant is not what a country like Ethiopia should be spending its money on. But Punch said a transplant is much cheaper than dialysis and is more effective.
“Kidney disease affects young people in the prime of their lives, and it affects not only the patient but their family as well,” Punch added. “Losing the breadwinner is disastrous to the family unit. We can see how grateful the entire family is when the patients are restored to health by transplant.”
Most people might not appreciate how difficult it is to set up a kidney transplant program. It involves much more than a seasoned surgeon flying in to show other doctors how to do the procedure.
Dr. Punch’s team spent more than two years working with St. Paul’s to sort out a wide range of issues. A variety of drugs and an inventory system to track them was needed. Labs were only open during the day on weekdays, and they needed to be available 24/7. CT scanners, pathology and ultrasound required upgrades. Even new surgical gowns needed to be ordered.
“The cool thing about the project is that all of the things we’re doing are improving the quality of care for everything,” Dr. Punch said. “Everyone in the hospital benefits from the fact that they can check all these labs whenever they want to instead of five days a week during the day.”
Dr. Momina added that the transplant program is also inspiring doctors in other departments.
“It has motivated other physicians and officials to start thinking it’s possible to have new services that seemed impossible before. People are starting to think bigger,” she said. “The Ministry of Health is asking Dr. Punch if it’s possible to start doing liver transplants.”
Now they’re dreaming what they know.