Shaving Soaps

Kathleen Underwood
15 min readSep 7, 2024
Shaving-Soap-1

Welcome to our comprehensive Shaving Soap roundup, where we dive into the world of traditional grooming and explore some of the best options available in the market today. Our goal is to provide you with a detailed overview of these high-quality shaving soaps, helping you make an informed decision and upgrade your shaving routine.

As an Amazon Affiliate™ I earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you

Reviews

Stirling Soap Company Scented Executive Man Shaving Soap

Stirling Soap Company Scented Executive Man Shaving Soap | Image

In my experience, the Stirling Soap Company's Shave Soap, Executive Man, has proven to be a fantastic addition to my daily grooming routine. The shaving soap whips up a rich, thick lather that leaves my face feeling silky smooth and well-moisturized thanks to the tallow-based formula combined with glycerin, lanolin, almond oil, shea butter, and coconut milk.

The scent of the Executive Man is an excellent balance between masculine and sophisticated, reminiscent of Creed's Aventus. The top notes of pineapple and bergamot provide a refreshing twist, while the floral heart note and base of oak moss and musk give it a distinctive and unique aroma that exudes confidence and power.

Additionally, the Shave Soap, Executive Man delivers an exceptional shaving performance with a slick lather that glides smoothly on the skin. Although the scent may not be for everyone, it's definitely unique and perfect for those looking for a different fragrance in their grooming routine. For me, it's become my go-to shaving soap, and I can't imagine going back to any other.

All-in-One Shower and Shave Soap Bar

All-in-One Shower and Shave Soap Bar | Image

Experience a multi-function shave with the Sht Shower & Shave Soap Bar! This all-natural gem is made with castor oil and kaolin clay, delivering a rich lather for a comfortable shave. Your skin will be treated to a delightful blend of orange and lavender scents, leaving you feeling refreshed.

Ditch the brushes and get straight to the action with this hand-held gem. It's SLS and paraben-free, vegan, and cruelty-free, with zero palm oil. Give your delicate skin a well-deserved treat with the Sht Shower & Shave Soap Bar!

Sandalwood Premium Triple Butter Shaving Soap

Sandalwood Premium Triple Butter Shaving Soap | Image

I recently tried the Sandalwood Triple Butter Shaving Soap, and I must say, it's a game-changer for my shaving routine. The rich, sandalwood fragrance instantly sets the mood for a luxurious experience. The soap lathers up beautifully, thanks to the triple butter and natural oils, and it glides effortlessly over my skin.

What really impressed me was how gentle it was on my sensitive skin. I often struggle with razor burn and irritation, but I noticed a significant difference while using this shaving soap. The Bentonite Clay works wonders in soothing and healing my skin, leaving it feeling soft and nourished.

However, one downside to this product is the price. It's a bit on the higher side compared to other shaving soaps in the market. But if you're someone who values quality and wants to avoid any potential skin issues, this shaving soap might just be worth the investment.

Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Soap in Wooden Bowl - Classic Scent and Moisturizing Formula

Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Soap in Wooden Bowl — Classic Scent and Moisturizing Formula | Image

As a shaving enthusiast, I've been thrilled with Taylor of Old Bond Street's Sandalwood Shaving Soap in a wooden bowl. Not only does it leave a lingering, manly aroma of Sandalwood that reminds me of a classic barbershop, but it also delivers a smooth, close shave that leaves my skin feeling pampered.

One standout feature is the rich lather the soap creates, which moisturizes the skin during the shave. The wooden bowl is a thoughtful addition, providing not just an attractive packaging, but also serving as a refillable container for future purchases.

However, I would be remiss if I didn't mention the downside—the wooden bowl can make quite a mess if you're not careful while lathering. But that's a small price to pay for such a luxurious shaving experience. Overall, I highly recommend this scented shaving soap for anyone looking for a classic, soothing, and high-quality shave.

Imperial Barber 6.2-Ounce Glycerin Shaving Bar

Imperial Barber 6.2-Ounce Glycerin Shaving Bar | Image

I recently tried the Imperial Barber 6.2-ounce Glycerin Puck Shave/Face Soap, and I must say it exceeded my expectations. The rich lathering quality of this soap combined with the infused vitamin E, safflower, palm, and coconut oils made for a close, smooth, and moisturizing shave.

I especially loved the versatility of this product – I could use it for traditional wet shaving or as a daily facial soap in the shower. The puck's lasting power was impressive too, and the scentless formula made it suitable for everyone.

However, I did notice that the puck was a bit bigger than I expected, making it a bit unwieldy to handle. But overall, I'm thrilled with this product and the results it delivered. It's definitely a great value with its high-quality, all-natural ingredients and dual-purpose function.

Badass Splash & Pure Parfum Shaving Soap

Badass Splash & Pure Parfum Shaving Soap | Image

I recently tried this Badass Shave Soap, and it did not disappoint! The first time I used it, the scent hit me right away - a mix of citrus and a deep, masculine aroma that had everyone around me commenting on how good it smelled. The lather was thick and creamy, which made for a close, comfortable shave.

However, I've found that the product is a bit messy to use, with the lather often splashing out of the tub and onto my sink. The Splash and Pure Parfum versions also have a nice scent but can be tricky to apply, especially if you're in a rush.

Overall, this Badass Shave Soap is great for those who enjoy a luxurious, close shave, but it might not be the best option for those who are looking for a bit more control over their shaving routine.

Lather & Wood Luxury Barber Shaving Soap

Lather & Wood Luxury Barber Shaving Soap | Image

Lather & Wood Shaving Soap offers an unparalleled shaving experience with its rich, full-bodied lather and delightful, warming fragrance. This luxurious soap starts with a warm shaving brush and quickly establishes itself as a must-have for traditional wet shavings. Notably, it is made from all-natural ingredients, ensuring a clean and refreshing feel that lingers long after your shave.

While some users have expressed discontent with the packaging material, the product's high-quality features still stand out in comparison to its competitors. With an easy-to-work-with consistency and a fantastic lather that's a joy to apply, Lather & Wood Shaving Soap truly deserves its reputation as the crème de la crème of shaving soaps.

An excellent choice for traditional wet shaves, Lather & Wood Shaving Soap provides not only a superior shave but also the added benefit of a subtle and lasting fragrance. As a result, it's no surprise that this product has received widespread praise from satisfied customers.

Zingari Man The Rambler Shave Soap - Premium 4 oz Shaving Experience

Zingari Man The Rambler Shave Soap — Premium 4 oz Shaving Experience | Image

Embark on a luxurious shaving experience with the Zingari Man Rambler shave soap. Handcrafted in small batches, this premium product impresses with its unmatched level of slickness, cushion, glide, and long-lasting post-shave feel.

The Zingari Man Sego tallow soap base is a standout, providing an elite post-shave face feel that is essential for healthy skin. This creamy shave soap comes in a generous 5-ounce jar, promising over 100 uses and ensuring a rich and moisturizing experience for sensitive and dry skin.

The Rambler boasts a delightful scent profile that combines the enticing aroma of strawberry, raspberry, and peppercorn with the warm, rich notes of tobacco, hay, and plum. Its intoxicating aroma lingers long after the shave, making it perfect for those looking for a shaving routine that doubles as self-care time.

Suitable for both men and women, this versatile shave soap can be used on various body parts, including face, head, legs, and underarms. With its delicious fragrance and superior lather quality, the Zingari Man Rambler shave soap sets the standard for a comfortable shave routine that leaves you feeling refreshed and invigorated.

Taylor of Old Bond Street Classic Shaving Soap for Travel

Taylor of Old Bond Street Classic Shaving Soap for Travel | Image

I've recently started using the Taylor of Old Bond Street Traditional Shaving Soap in Travel Bowl. I can't deny the excitement I felt when I opened the sleek, travel-friendly container. The fragrance of the soap immediately caught my attention, a refreshing and invigorating scent that lingered on my skin even after my morning routine.

One of my favorite aspects of this shaving soap has been its ability to create a rich and luxurious lather. I found myself looking forward to morning showers just for the opportunity to use this product. The travel bowl has been a game-changer, making it easy to pack and take with me wherever I go. The sturdy plastic design ensures that the soap stays inside and won't leak.

However, I did notice a slight drawback in my experience. Although the scent is delightful, it seemed to fade away a bit too quickly. Perhaps a stronger top note for the fragrance would be more lasting. Overall, the Taylor of Old Bond Street shaving soap has brought a touch of luxury and comfort to my daily shaving routine, and I'm impressed with its performance on the go.

Eucalyptus Shaving Soap for a Refreshing Shave

Eucalyptus Shaving Soap for a Refreshing Shave | Image

Imagine waking up every morning with a clean, refreshing sensation as you prepare for your daily shave. That's exactly what this Eucalyptus Shave Soap delivers! I've been using it for a while now, and it never fails to bring me a little boost of energy.

This soap, inspired by the coastline of California, not only looks good but works incredibly well. The strong eucalyptus scent is invigorating, while the lather takes on a luxurious, creamy consistency. Say goodbye to those dreaded nicks and cuts, too - the formula does a fantastic job at lubricating the skin and providing a smooth, close shave.

But wait - there's even more to love! This product is eco-friendly and proudly labeled as Palm Oil-Free. You can shave with peace of mind, knowing you haven't contributed to the destruction of rainforests. Plus, it's 100% Plastic Free, with no packaging to throw away. Kudos to the makers for thinking responsibly!

While I've grown fond of this Eucalyptus Shave Soap, it's not without its flaws. The soap may be a little harsh for those with sensitive skin, causing slight irritation after extended use. However, it's not enough to deter me from using it every day.

Overall, this shave soap is a breath of fresh air. It's perfect for those looking for an invigorating shaving experience that is both luxurious and environmentally conscious.

The Gent Zingari Man Shaving Soap - 5 Ounce

The Gent Zingari Man Shaving Soap — 5 Ounce | Image

Zingari Man The Gent Shave Soap is a luxurious and fragrant option for those seeking a gentle and invigorating shaving experience. Made from an all-natural base of glycerin, goat's milk, and shea butter, it gently moisturizes the skin and protects against irritation, making it a popular choice for those with sensitive skin. The rich, earthy fragrance and soft undertones of herbs and citrus create a delightful and refreshing shaving routine, while its smooth, silky lather ensures an effortless glide over the skin.

With its strong performance and positive reviews from satisfied customers, The Gent Shave Soap is a standout choice for wet shavers looking to elevate their shaving ritual.

Beard Buster Organic Shaving Soap for a Close Shave and Soothing Skin

Beard Buster Organic Shaving Soap for a Close Shave and Soothing Skin | Image

The Beard Buster shaving soap promises a close and refreshing shave, thanks to its blend of natural ingredients and organic additives. One key highlight that truly stood out in my experience was the presence of castor oil, which did help in achieving a smooth and close shave. Additionally, the kaolin and bentonite clay added to the soap provided a much-needed slip, making the shaving experience more enjoyable.

However, I did encounter a small issue with this product. Despite the natural ingredients being touted, the packaging seemed quite excessive with a triple wrapping of bubble wrap. As a conscious consumer, this seemed a bit disappointing, and I would have appreciated a more eco-friendly packaging material.

Overall, the Beard Buster shaving soap has shown promise in delivering a close shave and a refreshing experience. The use of natural ingredients and organic additives adds to its appeal, but a change in packaging approach would help enhance its appeal to a wide range of customers.

Buyer's Guide

Shaving soap is a traditional and effective method to achieve a close, comfortable shave. This guide will cover important features, considerations, and general advice to help you make the best choice when purchasing shaving soap.

Features to Look for in Shaving Soap

Choosing the right shaving soap can significantly improve your shaving experience. Some key features to look for include:

  1. Lather: A good shaving soap should create a rich, easy-to-spread lather, and 2) Scent: Shaving soap comes in a variety of scents, so choose one that appeals to you. 3) Ingredients: Opt for all-natural or organic ingredients to avoid harsh chemicals on your skin.
Shaving-Soap-2

Considering Your Shaving Needs

Your skin type, sensitivity, and desired shave outcome are crucial factors to consider when selecting a shaving soap. 1) Skin Type: Choose a shaving soap that suits your skin type (e. g. , sensitive, dry, or oily). 2) Sensitivity: For those with sensitive skin, consider unscented or fragrance-free options. 3) Desired Outcome: If you prefer a close shave, look for shaving soap formulated for a razor-close shave.

General Advice for Using Shaving Soap

Here are some general advice on how to get the most out of your shaving soap:

  1. Preparation: Soak your shaving brush in warm water, then apply the soap to the bristles. 2) Lathering: Swirl your wet brush in the soap to generate a rich, creamy lather. 3) Applying: Apply a thick, even layer of lather over your face, working it into the direction of hair growth for the best results.
Shaving-Soap-3

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Avoid these common mistakes when using shaving soap:

  1. Using too much water: This can dilute the soap, reducing its ability to create a rich lather and protect your skin. 2) Over-scrubbing: Gently apply the lather and avoid harsh, circular motions, as it can irritate your skin. 3) Rinsing with cold water: It's best to rinse with lukewarm water to maintain skin's natural oils.

FAQ

Shaving-Soap-4

Why choose shaving soap over other shaving products?

Shaving soap provides a more traditional and personalized shaving experience. It is typically made from natural ingredients and is easier to customize by adding extra fragrances, essential oils, or additional lubricants like aloe vera or witch hazel. Additionally, it is less expensive than some modern shaving products and can last longer as you only need a small amount each time you shave.

Furthermore, many shaving soap users find it to be more luxurious and relaxing due to its rich, creamy lather that often lasts longer and offers a closer shave. The absence of harsh chemicals in most shaving soaps leads to a smoother and less irritated complexion after shaving. Overall, shaving soap is favored by men who are more interested in the traditional and sensory aspects of shaving rather than the convenience of aerosol-based products.

What are the benefits of using a high-quality shaving soap?

A high-quality shaving soap offers several benefits. First and foremost, it is designed to provide a close and comfortable shave without causing irritation. Many high-quality soaps are made from premium ingredients like tallow, which contributes to a rich and creamy lather and adds a natural fragrance. Other soaps contain a blend of essential oils or fragrances that can be customized to your own personal preferences.

Premium shaving soaps often last longer than regular soaps since a small amount is sufficient for each shave. They also tend to contain more nourishing and moisturizing ingredients, such as aloe vera and vitamin E, which can help to keep your skin healthy and hydrated. Additionally, high-quality shaving soaps are typically free from harsh chemicals and synthetic fragrances, making them suitable for men with sensitive or problematic skin types.

Shaving-Soap-5

What are some popular shaving soap scents?

Popular shaving soap scents vary depending on personal preference and the specific brand of soap being used. Some common scents include classic barbershop scents like lavender, sandalwood, and bay rum. Other popular options include citrus scents like lemon, orange, and grapefruit, as well as woodsy scents like cedarwood, juniper, and pine. Many brands also offer fragrance-free or unscented options for men who prefer a more subtle or neutral shaving experience.

In addition to traditional scents, some shaving soap manufacturers also create unique and innovative fragrance combinations. These can range from herbal scents like peppermint and eucalyptus to gourmet scents like cinnamon, clove, and anise. The goal is to provide a shaving experience that is not only functional but also enjoyable and memorable. Ultimately, the choice of scent comes down to personal preferences and the specific brand or product being used.

What are some tips for using shaving soap?

To get the best results from your shaving soap, follow these tips:

  1. Begin by warming the soap in your hands to create a rich and creamy lather. This typically requires a few moments of gentle rubbing. 2. Apply the lather to your wet face in a circular motion, being sure to cover all areas you plan to shave. 3. Apply a sharp and clean razor to your wet and soaped face using short strokes, gently pressing down on the razor while maintaining skin tension. 4. Rinse your face with warm water after shaving to remove any remaining soap or hair from the face. 5. Pat your face dry with a clean towel and apply a post-shave treatment like aftershave or aloe vera gel to hydrate and soothe your skin.

By following these tips, you can achieve a closer, more comfortable shave while also preventing skin irritation or razor burn. It is also important to use a high-quality razor and a good-quality shaving brush to enhance the overall shaving experience and ensure a smooth and efficient shave each time you use shaving soap.

Shaving-Soap-6

What are some common mistakes men make when using shaving soap?

Some common mistakes men make when using shaving soap include:

  1. Rushing the shaving process, leading to inadequate lather buildup or poor application technique. This can result in less-than-optimal razor glide and an increased risk of irritation or razor burn. 2. Using an old or dull razor, which can lead to a less-than-satisfactory shave and increased irritation. 3. Applying too much pressure when shaving, which can cause unnecessary friction and increase the risk of irritation or razor burn. 4. Failing to properly clean and maintain shaving equipment like razors, brushes, and blades, which can lead to inefficiencies and poor shaving performance. 5. Not rinsing your face thoroughly after shaving, which can leave behind soap residue that causes post-shave irritation.

To avoid these mistakes, take your time with the shaving process, use high-quality shaving equipment, and practice proper shaving techniques. This will help you achieve the best possible shaving results while ensuring a smooth and comfortable face after each shave. Regular cleaning and maintenance of your shaving equipment is also crucial for maintaining its performance and preventing irritation or other issues.

What shaving soap is best for sensitive skin?

When choosing a shaving soap for sensitive skin, it is essential to look for one that contains natural and non-irritating ingredients. Opt for soaps that are free from fragrances, harsh chemicals, and synthetic additives. Many high-quality shaving soap brands offer unscented or sensitive skin formulations, which are specifically designed to minimize irritation and reduce the risk of razor burn. Ingredients such as aloe vera, vitamin E, and witch hazel can also help to soothe and moisturize the skin, making them ideal for men with sensitive skin types.

Popular brands for sensitive skin shaving soaps include Proraso, Bevel Shave Soap, and Taylor of Old Bond Street. These brands offer formulations that are free from artificial additives, fragrances, and parabens, and instead focus on using natural ingredients that are gentle on the skin. By choosing a shaving soap that is specifically formulated for sensitive skin, you can help ensure a comfortable and irritation-free shaving experience every time.

As an Amazon Affiliate™ I earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you

--

--