I appreciate your eloquent and thought through response. I can appreciate sound critique.

That being said, you kind of went off on one of my points and ignored the others.

I disagree that her music isn’t meaningful or deep; her lyrics are a few notches above the rest of her competitors at least. I’d be happy to provide some examples if you’d like, but otherwise maybe we just don’t find the same thing meaningful.

Regarding autotune — as I said, she’s had her problems vocally, and concerts aren’t really her best always, what with all the moving around, etc. However, like I said, her singing accoustic = golden. I’d be happy to share a few links for this, too.