Water Based Concealers

Meredith Huff
15 min readJul 20, 2024

--

Welcome to our roundup of the best water-based concealers on the market! If you’re looking for a lightweight, natural-looking concealer that won’t irritate your skin, you’re in the right place. We’ve gathered a collection of top-rated products that will help you cover up those pesky blemishes and imperfections. Let’s dive in and discover the perfect water-based concealer for you.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualified purchases at no cost to you.

Reviews

Maybelline Fit Me Liquid Concealer: Flawless Coverage for Dark Circles and Blemishes

maybelline-fit-me-liquid-concealer-25-medium-0-23-fl-oz-1

I recently gave Maybelline’s Fit Me Liquid Concealer a whirl, and let me tell you, it was quite the experience. The first thing I noticed when I opened the tube was the smooth and creamy consistency of the product. It almost felt like a dream come true, as it glided effortlessly onto my skin. The product was formulated to reduce the appearance of dark circles and blemishes, and, as a fellow fellow with quite a few imperfections, I was hopeful.

I applied a small dot of the concealer under my eyes and another to a blemish on my cheek. The shade selection was impressive, and I loved that the brand catered to a wide range of skin tones. I took the doe-foot applicator and dabbed a small amount of the concealer onto my imperfections, then I blended it with my fingers. The finish was surprisingly natural, and the product didn’t crease or cake, even in my delicate under-eye area.

One thing that really stood out to me was the concealer’s oil-free formula. This feature prevented any greasiness, and it left my skin looking flawless. However, I also noticed that the formula was a bit heavy on my skin, making it a bit too rich for my taste. Nonetheless, it did help reduce the visibility of my pores.

Overall, I was pretty impressed with the Maybelline Fit Me Liquid Concealer. It provides good coverage, blends well, and comes in a fantastic range of shades. However, it may not be the best fit for those with oilier skin or a heavier hand, as it can feel a bit too heavy. But for those in need of a natural-looking concealer, this product is definitely worth a try.

Flower Beauty Light Illusion Full Coverage Concealer — Light

flower-beauty-light-illusion-full-coverage-concealer-light-light-1

FLOWER Beauty’s Light Illusion Full Coverage Concealer brings a soft-focus blurring effect to your under eyes with high performance coverage. This weightless concealer, featuring FLOWER Beauty’s exclusive blurring pigments, provides dark circle diffusing illumination in a high coverage formula. The creamy texture blends seamlessly, providing a subtle radiance while concealing imperfections.

Infused with aloe and chamomile extracts, this concealer helps to calm and reduce puffiness, while caffeine firms up and provides targeted areas with an antioxidant boost.

Ulta Beauty Full Coverage and Waterproof Liquid Concealer

ulta-beauty-full-coverage-waterproof-liquid-concealer-0-16-fl-oz-light-warm-1

I recently tried Ulta Beauty’s Full Coverage Waterproof Liquid Concealer in Light Warm, and I must say, I was highly impressed with its performance. The creamy texture did not crease or cake, even after a long day. It offered great coverage and blended seamlessly with my skin tone. However, I did notice that the formula was slightly heavy and felt a bit like clay.

One of the key highlights of this concealer was its matte finish, which remained all day without smudging. I appreciated its waterproof formula, too, as it kept my under-eye area looking flawless during my daily activities. This concealer worked well for all skin types and managed to keep my skin hydrated, which was a plus for me.

The shade selection was interesting, as I found that it didn’t quite match my expectations of a concealer called “Full Coverage. “ I used two shades mixed together to achieve the desired light warmth, which was a bit of a hassle. As for ease of removal, I had to put a bit more effort into taking it off than I’d prefer, but overall, the product performed well.

In summary, Ulta Beauty’s Full Coverage Waterproof Liquid Concealer offered impressive coverage and a long-lasting matte finish, but its slightly heavy formula and the need for multiple shades to achieve the desired tone might be a downside for some users.

Wet N Wild Megalast Incognito All-Day Full Coverage Concealer — Light Beige (Cruelty-Free, Paraben-Free)

wet-n-wild-megalast-incognito-all-day-full-coverage-concealer-light-beige-1

The Wet N Wild Megalast Incognito Concealer boasts all-day, ultra-long-lasting wear, providing lightweight yet buildable coverage in a soft matte finish. Its formula, enriched with nourishing ingredients like licorice root extract, shea butter, and mango seed butter, ensures skin remains hydrated while achieving the perfect complexion.

With its cruelty-free and paraben-free stance, this concealer offers a blend of coverage and care for a wide range of skin tones. The creamy concealer is easy to apply, offering even coverage and easy removal, though some users have noted mild creasing or potential cakiness. Overall, the Megalast Incognito Concealer is a popular choice for its superior coverage, lightweight feel, and affordable price point.

Maybelline Eraser Concealer: Water-Based Dark Circle Cream

maybelline-eraser-dark-circles-fair-110-0-2-fl-oz-1

I recently tried the Maybelline Eraser Dark Circles Concealer and was pleasantly surprised by its performance. The micro-corrector applicator made it easy to apply the product directly to my under-eye area, and the gentle blend-in motion worked well to cover my dark circles without leaving behind any creases or cakiness. I was drawn to this concealer because of its infusion with goji berry and Haloxyl, which I hoped would leave my under-eye area looking refreshed and well-rested.

In my experience, the concealer did a great job of correcting the appearance of redness and brightening up my dull skin. However, I did notice that it needed a little more coverage to effectively hide my dark circles. Also, the shade selection offered was rather large, so it took me a while to find the perfect match for my skin tone.

One aspect I loved about this product was its lightweight formula. It didn’t feel heavy or irritating on my skin, and it even lasted throughout the day without any smudging or flaking. The applicator itself was quite comfortable to use and made the application process easy and mess-free. I also appreciated that the concealer didn’t dry out quickly, allowing me to blend it seamlessly with my skin.

In summary, the Maybelline Eraser Dark Circles Concealer is a solid choice for those looking to cover dark circles and add some brightness to their under-eye area. While it may not be perfect for everyone, its lightweight texture, large shade selection, and easy-to-use applicator make it a great option for many.

Water-Based Concealer with Hyaluronic Hydration

colourpop-pretty-fresh-hyaluronic-creamy-concealer-medium-dark-115w-1

The Colourpop Pretty Fresh Hyaluronic Creamy Concealer is a noteworthy addition to your makeup routine. Its skin-loving ingredients make it a popular choice among users with normal to oily skin types.

It promises to hydrate the skin with hyaluronic acid, coconut water, and full coverage pigments that provide a natural, fresh finish. You can appreciate that the concealer is lightweight, easy to apply, and long-lasting, but it might not provide the same results for those with dry skin. Some users have reported that the concealer creases and clings to dryer spots, or that it oxidizes and smells unpleasant.

Overall, while this concealer has its pros and cons, it’s worth trying to find its unique place in your skincare routine.

e.l.f. Deep Caramel Water-Based Hydrating Camo Concealer

e-l-f-deep-caramel-hydrating-camo-concealer-1

I’ve been using the e. l. f. Deep Caramel Hydrating Camo Concealer for a while now, and I must say, it’s been a game-changer in my makeup routine. As someone with dry skin, I’ve struggled to find a concealer that doesn’t make my under-eye circles more obvious or dry out my skin. But this one is different — it provides the coverage I need without compromising on hydration.

One of the first things I noticed about this concealer is how smoothly it blends. I’ve tried using both brushes and beauty blenders, and it works well with both. The coverage is impressive, too — it manages to hide my imperfections and even out my skin tone without looking too heavy or cakey. And the best part? It doesn’t crease or settle into fine lines, thanks to its hydrating formula.

However, there is one downside I’ve noticed: it doesn’t last quite as long as advertised. While it does hold up pretty well throughout the day, I’ve found that by the end of the day, it does start to fade a bit. But considering the incredible price point, I can’t complain too much.

Overall, I’m really happy with the e. l. f. Deep Caramel Hydrating Camo Concealer. It’s a fantastic option for those with normal, combination, or dry skin, and it doesn’t break the bank. Just be prepared to reapply if you need to stay looking flawless all day.

Water-Resistant Full Coverage Under-Eye Concealer with Paddle Applicator

maybelline-super-stay-under-eye-concealer-ivory-05-0-23-fl-oz-1

Transform your tired eyes with the Maybelline Super Stay Full Coverage Concealer. This waterproof, under-eye formula offers a smooth, seamless finish with its precise paddle applicator.

Perfect for covering up dark circles, it’s water-resistant, sweat-proof, and lasts up to 24 hours. However, you might experience a little creasing, especially if you have mature skin or deep lines beneath the eyes. It’s also recommended to test the shade to match your skin tone as the light one may have an orange undertone.

Overall, a good value and effective concealer for its price range.

Maybelline Fit Me Liquid Concealer — Natural Coverage, Oil-Free Wheat, Shade 22

maybelline-fit-me-liquid-concealer-makeup-natural-coverage-oil-free-wheat-0-23-fl-oz-1

The Maybelline Fit Me Liquid Concealer Makeup offers natural coverage in a buildable formula, suitable for all skin types and making every woman look radiant with its lightweight and long-lasting qualities. The oil-free concealer blends seamlessly with a doe-foot applicator for precise application. This liquid concealer, containing micellar water and suitable for warm skin undertones, is highly recommended for under-eye circles.

The range of shades offers a wide range of options to match different undertones, making it perfect for those who are looking for a versatile concealer. Overall, it is an affordable option for those who want to achieve a natural and flawless appearance with its comfortable, blendable coverage.

Jouer Cosmetics Amber Essential High Coverage Water Based Concealer

jouer-cosmetics-amber-essential-high-coverage-liquid-concealer-1

As a connoisseur of premium skincare, I decided to give Jouer Cosmetics’ Amber Essential High Coverage Liquid Concealer a whirl. For many, it’s a staple concealer, and I can now see why. Upon first application, I found it to be an absolute dream for those of us with mature skin. The non-drying formula, packed with hyaluronic acid to support skin’s natural moisture retention, made it quite a relief to use. Resveratrol as an added antioxidant was a delightful inclusion, too, given my concerns regarding skin damage and aging signs.

The Anise Fruit Extract, which softens, smoothes, and promotes skin health, was another welcome asset. A light-to-medium coverage is what it offers, which, while might seem less in the realm of full coverage, can still deliver a subtle glow that doesn’t overpower. The product was rather easy to blend, making the application process a smooth one for me, regardless of the areas where it’s applied.

The shade selection is laudable, with a color palette catering to all skin tones. However, one con I experienced was the longevity of the product. It didn’t last as long on my skin as I’d hoped, but that might vary depending on skin factors like makeup remover preference or oiliness.

It’s a bit of a pity that the tube suggests more product than what’s actually given, but that’s a minor complaint in the grand scheme of things. Overall, I’m not surprised this product enjoys such high praise for its premium ingredients and flattering coverage. It’s worth a try, especially for those whose skin shows signs of aging or damage. However, if longevity is the measure of a product’s success, more adjustments might be needed. On balance, though, Jouer Cosmetics’ Amber Essential High Coverage Liquid Concealer has certainly earned its place in my skincare routine.

Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser: The Multi-Use Moisturizing Hydra-Concealer for Perfect Coverage and Long-Lasting Wear

maybelline-instant-age-rewind-eraser-concealer-multi-use-141-0-2-fl-oz-1

I recently tried the Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Concealer Multi-Use, and let me tell you, this little miracle worked wonders for my under-eye circles and fine lines. The micro-correcting applicator made it super easy to apply, and the concealer blended seamlessly into my skin, leaving a crease-free and natural finish. It’s amazing how far this budget-friendly concealer took me, with up to 12 hours of hydration, coverage, and correction.

The sponge-tip applicator made on-the-go touch-ups a breeze, and the wide range of shades made it easy to find my perfect match. However, I noticed a slight tendency for the product to smudge and settle into creases after a long day, not to mention a few irritations for some users.

Still, overall, this Instant Age Rewind Eraser Concealer Multi-Use is a hidden gem in the world of budget-friendly skincare and makeup products.

Infused Concealer with 20+ Skincare Ingredients and Hydrating Benefits

haus-labs-by-lady-gaga-triclone-skin-tech-hydrating-de-puffing-concealer-with-fermented-arnica-40-me-1

The Haus Labs Triclone Skin Tech Hydrating Concealer with Fermented Arnica is a must-try for anyone in search of a skin-loving, high-quality concealer. It boasts medium buildable coverage and a natural finish, leaving the skin hydrated and with a seamless, weightless texture. Infused with 20+ skincare ingredients including HAUS LABS’ patented Fermented Arnica, it not only conceals but also hydrates, blurs, and de-puffs the under-eye area.

While some users might experience acne flare-ups with the product, many others praise its buildable coverage and blendability. The lightweight formula is resistant to creasing, and it works well with the Haus Labs powder for an even better finish. Its long-wear capabilities might please those who require a concealer that lasts throughout the day.

In summary, the Haus Labs Triclone Skin Tech Hydrating Concealer with Fermented Arnica is a standout product for those who prioritize skincare-focused ingredients, long-wear coverage, and a natural finish. Its combination of hydrating and de-puffing properties, along with the medium buildable coverage, makes it a worthy consideration for a wide range of skin types and preferences.

Hourglass Vanish Airbrush Concealer (Dune) — Waterproof Coverage

hourglass-vanish-airbrush-concealer-dune-1

The Hourglass Vanish Airbrush Concealer is an innovative liquid formula that delivers full coverage while maintaining a natural, airbrushed finish. Designed for versatility, the creamy and weightless formula seamlessly conceals dark circles, discoloration, blemishes, and other imperfections. The concealer is long-lasting, with a 16-hour crease-resistance time, it is waterproof and non-comedogenic while also including shades suitable for color correcting.

This unique formulation boasts microspherical powders that diffuse across pores, fine lines, and wrinkles to achieve a smoother appearance, reflecting light for a more even and flawless complexion. The custom designed applicator, featuring a perfectly flocked and flexible tip, allows for precise application and application without tugging on delicate skin.

This product is suitable for all skin types — including normal, dry, combination and oily skin types. It is available in a natural, airbrushed finish and is long-wearing, crease-resistant, and waterproof. Moreover, the product is vegan and cruelty-free making it an ethical choice for its users. It’s a popular choice for color correcting and its formula allows it to blend seamlessly with the skin, providing undetectable, radiant coverage.

Buyer’s Guide

Water-based concealers have become increasingly popular due to their lightweight formula and natural finish. These products are designed to cover imperfections, like dark circles, redness, and blemishes, while providing hydration to the skin. In this buyer’s guide, we will discuss the important features to consider when purchasing a water-based concealer, as well as general advice for using and applying the product.

Choosing the Right Shade

Selecting the right shade is crucial for achieving a natural look with your water-based concealer. Many brands offer a variety of shades to cater to different skin tones. It’s essential to choose a shade that closely matches your skin tone or slightly lighter, as it will blend more seamlessly. Testing the product on your skin before purchasing is always recommended.

Coverage Level

Water-based concealers usually offer medium to full coverage, depending on the brand and formula. Consider your skin concerns and desired coverage when selecting a product. If you have severe discoloration or acne, you may want to opt for a full-coverage concealer. However, if you prefer a more natural look, a medium-coverage concealer may be more suitable.

Texture and Finish

Water-based concealers often have a lightweight, creamy texture that blends easily into the skin. The finish can vary from matte to dewy, depending on the product. If you have oily skin, a matte finish may be more suitable, while those with dry skin may prefer a dewy or luminous finish. It’s essential to choose a concealer with a finish that complements your skin type and desired look.

Ingredients and Skin Benefits

Water-based concealers can also offer skin benefits, such as hydration and antioxidant protection. Look for ingredients like vitamin E, hyaluronic acid, and green tea extract, which can help nourish and protect the skin. These ingredients can also improve the overall appearance of the skin over time.

FAQ

Understanding Water-Based Concealers

Water-based concealers are a popular makeup choice known for their lightweight texture, breathability, and hydrating properties. These cosmetic products are designed to hide blemishes, dark circles, and other skin imperfections. Unlike their oil or wax-based counterparts, water-based concealers are gentle and suitable for all skin types, making them an ideal choice for everyday use.

These concealers have gained popularity due to their numerous benefits. They allow the skin to breathe, preventing breakouts and keeping your skin healthy. Water-based concealers also provide a flawless finish without clogging pores, causing irritation, or harming your skin in any way.

The Pros of Water-Based Concealers

Water-based concealers offer various advantages compared to traditional concealers. They provide a breathable and lightweight coverage that is perfect for those suffering from sensitive or acne-prone skin. Their gentle formula allows them to blend seamlessly with other makeup products without causing any adverse reactions.

Furthermore, water-based concealers are often crafted using natural ingredients or vitamins that nourish and protect the skin. Some of these products even contain sun protection, offering additional benefits. Overall, water-based concealers promote healthy skin and provide a natural, flawless finish.

Selecting the Right Water-Based Concealer for Your Needs

Choosing the right water-based concealer for your skin type requires careful consideration. If you have sensitive skin or are prone to acne breakouts, opt for products labeled as “non-comedogenic” or “oil-free” as they will not clog your pores or cause irritation.

Those seeking heavier coverage should look for water-based concealers with a higher concentration of pigment. Additionally, read ingredient lists for words like “hydrating” or “nourishing” if these factors are important to you. Some water-based concealers even contain sun protection, which can be beneficial for those who want daily sun protection. Finally, try out different products and choose the one that provides the level of coverage and skin compatibility that you desire.

Do Water-Based Concealers Work for All Skin Tones?

Absolutely! Water-based concealers are available in a variety of shades and undertones, allowing you to find a perfect match for your skin tone. Some cosmetics brands have expanded their shade ranges to offer more options for both lighter and deeper skin tones. In some cases, custom shades can be created or ordered directly from the brand.

To ensure you choose the right shade for your skin tone, read reviews and consult with makeup professionals. Color is only one aspect to consider, as skin type and individual preferences also play a role in finding the perfect match.

Mixing Water-Based Concealers with Other Makeup Products

Yes, you can mix water-based concealers with other makeup products without any issues. The lightweight texture of these concealers allows them to blend easily with foundation, powder, and other cosmetics. By doing so, you can achieve a natural, well-blended finish without having to worry about disruption of your makeup’s appearance.

Moreover, water-based concealers won’t cause pilling or break down the foundation underneath. Remember to blend your makeup evenly and follow the product’s label instructions for the best results. If you experience any issues, discontinue use and consult with a dermatologist or beauty professional.

Are Water-Based Concealers Eco-Friendly?

In a nutshell, water-based concealers are considered more eco-friendly than their oil or wax-based counterparts. Their lightweight formulas primarily consist of water, making them less likely to contribute to pollution or environmental damage. Unlike traditional concealers, which often contain heavy oils, waxes, and harsh chemicals, water-based concealers provide a cleaner and more sustainable option.

Furthermore, some water-based concealers are crafted with natural ingredients or contain high concentrations of vitamins and antioxidants. This environmental-friendly choice not only saves the planet, but it also supports companies that prioritize sustainability and eco-friendly practices.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualified purchases at no cost to you.

--

--