Eyeliners For Mature EyesBest Eyeliners For Mature Eyes

Barbara Collins
14 min readSep 11, 2024
Eyeliner-For-Mature-Eyes-1

As we age, our eyes and skin change, which may require some adjustments in our makeup choices. In this article, we've curated a selection of the best eyeliners specifically designed for mature eyes, providing easy-to-use options that enhance and accentuate your beauty. Dive in to explore the most effective and comfortable eyeliners to suit your unique needs.

As an Amazon Affiliate™ I receive compensation from qualifying purchases at no cost to you

Reviews

Ultra-Smooth Eyeliner for Brown Eyes - Laura Geller Kajal Longwear Kohl

Ultra-Smooth Eyeliner for Brown Eyes — Laura Geller Kajal Longwear Kohl | Image

Laura Geller's Kajal Longwear Eyeliner promises a smooth, vibrant application for a flawless and long-lasting look. Boasting a richly pigmented color that can double as an eyeshadow, it features a soft kohl formula that effortlessly glides on, giving your eyes a defined or smoky finish.

The eyeliner is infused with caffeine, a natural ingredient to reduce puffiness and redness, and vitamin E, which hydrates and conditions the eyelids. Its built-in sharpener ensures precise lines, while an easy-to-use applicator encourages smooth and mess-free application.

The Laura Geller Kajal Longwear Eyeliner comes in a variety of shades, catering to different looks and eye colors. With a convenient size and a formula that won't smudge or flake, this eyeliner is perfect for a sleek, long-lasting look.

Though some users have reported initial difficulty in using the eyeliner, overall, it seems to be a popular choice for those looking to achieve a smoky, defined, and lasting eye look.

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil for Brown Eyes

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil for Brown Eyes | Image

The Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil is a must-have for anyone seeking a stunningly long-lasting eyeliner. With a cushiony and creamy waterproof formulation, this eyeliner glides smoothly and flawlessly onto your lash line, staying put and looking fabulous no matter what you get up to. Infused with 50% hydrating ingredients, this pencil provides an effortless application experience without ever pulling or tugging at your skin.

Some users report that this product is a bit challenging to sharpen and flakes or dries out after some time. However, with its vibrant range of shades and effective waterproof formula, the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil remains a popular and reliable choice for those looking for a versatile and long-lasting eyeliner.

So, whether you're hitting the town for a night of glam or taming your eyes for a high-intensity workout, the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil is designed to meet your needs. It's time to unleash your creativity and embrace the bold, stunning looks you deserve!

ELF Retractable eyeliner for mature eyes - No Budge, Black 0.006 oz

ELF Retractable eyeliner for mature eyes — No Budge, Black 0.006 oz | Image

The ELF Retractable Liner is a versatile and smudge-proof eyeliner that ticks all the boxes for an all-day wear. Its rich, creamy texture delivers intense pigmentation that glides on effortlessly, and it dries to a budge-proof finish in just 30 seconds. What sets this liner apart is its waterproof formula, which ensures it stays put on your lash line, waterline, or all over your lid. It's perfect for creating bold, dramatic eye looks that last the whole day.

The liner is cruelty-free, vegan, and free from a host of harsh chemicals, making it an ethical choice for conscious shoppers. Those with sensitive skin will appreciate its gentle formula, which doesn't irritate and is easy to remove at the end of the day. However, some users have reported that the eyeliner can flake and needs sharpening. It's also important to note that the liner may not be as effective for waterline use due to its waterproofing, which could make it run instead of staying put.

Overall, the ELF Retractable Liner is an impressive product that delivers on its promise of long-lasting, smudge-proof performance. It's a great choice for those seeking a high-quality eyeliner at an affordable price point. Just be mindful of its flaws, such as the need for sharpening and potential flaking.

Tarte Easy On The Eyes Clay Eyeliner - Bronze, Perfect for Mature Eyes

Tarte Easy On The Eyes Clay Eyeliner — Bronze, Perfect for Mature Eyes | Image

The Tarte Easy On The Eyes Clay Liner in Bronze has been a lifesaver for my daily makeup routine. The creamy consistency glides onto my lids easily, and the color payoff is impressive, giving me an effortless smokey eye look every time. What truly sets this product apart is its waterproof formula; I can now enjoy swimming or getting caught in the rain without worrying about my eyeliner smudging!

The liner does tend to flake a bit, but I find the pros far outweigh the cons. The only thing that could improve this product in my opinion is if it sharpened better, but overall, I'm quite happy with my purchase.

Laura Mercier Caviar Tightline Smoke Eyeliner - Oily Lid Solution

Laura Mercier Caviar Tightline Smoke Eyeliner — Oily Lid Solution | Image

The Laura Mercier Caviar Tightline Eyeliner in Smoke is a versatile, long-lasting eyeliner that offers an effortless application and intense, buildable color. The creamy formula is enriched with conditioning and moisturizing ingredients, providing a comfortable wear for up to 12 hours. With a variety of shades available in different finishes, the eyeliner allows you to create various makeup looks, from subtle to bold. Whether you're looking for a smudge-proof liner or a sharp winged look, this versatile eyeliner is sure to meet your needs, making it a must-have for any makeup enthusiast.

Mesmerizing Laura Geller Marble Eyeliner for Mature Eyes

Mesmerizing Laura Geller Marble Eyeliner for Mature Eyes | Image

I recently tried the Laura Geller Marble Eyes Liner, and I have to say, it's been a game-changer for me. As someone who loves experimenting with makeup, this eyeliner really stood out with its unique twist on the traditional eyeliner pencil.

The first thing I noticed about this product was the packaging. It's sleek, modern, and minimal, with just the right amount of information about the product itself. The eyeliner pencil comes in various shades with a marbled finish, which is a beautiful touch.

Using the eyeliner was a breeze. It applied smoothly and evenly on my lids, creating a multi-dimensional effect that was both subtle and striking. The rich pigments blended seamlessly, giving me a look that was perfect for day or night. I particularly loved the Ocean Deep shade, which added a touch of glamour to my everyday makeup routine.

However, there were a couple of downsides to this product. Firstly, it wasn't the most durable when it came to sharpening. I found that it would break quite easily, which was a bit frustrating. Secondly, the applicator quality left something to be desired. While the eyeliner itself performed well, the applicator felt a bit rough and didn't glide over my skin as smoothly as I would have liked.

Overall, I would say the Laura Geller Marble Eyes Liner is definitely worth a try. It's a unique and versatile product that adds a touch of luxury to any makeup routine. While there were a few minor drawbacks, the pros definitely outweighed the cons for me.

Perfect Age Satin Eyeliner for Mature Eyes

Perfect Age Satin Eyeliner for Mature Eyes | Image

Transform your eyes with the L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect Satin Glide Eyeliner, a gentle and waterproof formula that's suitable for sensitive eyes. Its ergonomic rubber grip allows for precise application, while the pencil design ensures smooth glide without tugging at the delicate skin under your eyes.

The eyeliner features a comfortable, non-drying feel and is perfect for mature skin. It's also long-lasting and won't smudge or flake, making it an ideal choice for those looking for a high-quality eyeliner.

Soft Eyeliner for Mature Eyes

Soft Eyeliner for Mature Eyes | Image

Embrace your flair for the bold with Look Fabulous Forever's soft eyeliner. I am absolutely in love with how it effortlessly blends across my aging skin, providing my eyes with definition they've long deserved. The soft texture is a life-saver, gliding on like a whisper without any harsh tugging. It gently defines my lashline, making my lashes appear thicker and fuller than ever.

Plus, the product's matte finish pairs perfectly with the eyeshadows, creating a soft, no-nonsense finish that I find incredibly flattering. It wears all day with nary a smudge or crease, making it my go-to choice for no-fuss makeup days. And with the twist-up pencil, it couldn't be easier to use.

However, let me be honest: while the product does boast a wide variety of shades, I've felt that some of the colors I've tried have been too similar to each other rather than being unique. The lack of user reviews also leaves me wanting to know more about how others are experiencing this product.

Nonetheless, for those over forty like myself, and who appreciate makeup that doesn't skimp on quality, Look Fabulous Forever's soft eyeliner delivers on all fronts.

Milani Stay Put 24HR Eyeliner - After Dark Black Enhancement For Blue Eyes

Milani Stay Put 24HR Eyeliner — After Dark Black Enhancement For Blue Eyes | Image

Eyeliner enthusiasts, listen up! I recently tried out this "Stay Put" eyeliner from Milani, and I must say, it's been a game-changer in my makeup routine. The first thing I noticed was the incredible pigmentation – one swipe and my eyes were instantly transformed with a bold, intense color. The texture is super smooth, making it a breeze to apply with zero dragging or tugging on my delicate skin.

But what really sets this eyeliner apart? It's all about the built-in sharpener and smudger! You know those times when your liner is about to die and you can't seem to find a sharpener anywhere? Well, this baby has one right on the barrel, saving you the trouble of having to find one elsewhere. And the smudger? It's perfect for creating that smoky, smudged-out look we all love.

Now, there are a couple of things I'd love to see improved. It would be nice if the tip were a bit thinner for those wanting more precision during application. And while the description claims it's waterproof, I've found some smudging and transfer happening around my eyes after a workout.

Overall, I'm really enjoying this eyeliner and would highly recommend it to anyone seeking a long-lasting, vibrant, and easy-to-work-with option. Just remember to give it a gentle tug on the sharpening cap before each use!

Bobbi Brown Long-Lasting Gel Eyeliner for Mature Eyes

Bobbi Brown Long-Lasting Gel Eyeliner for Mature Eyes | Image

Experience the effortless convenience of Bobbi Brown's LongWear Gel Eyeliner. Crafted with a smooth gel formula, it glides onto your lashes for a hassle-free application. Known for its advanced formulation, this eyeliner provides a stay-put finish that lasts up to 12 hours. Its highly-pigmented color ensures an enchanting look for your eyes, making it perfect for both subtle and dramatic looks.

Clinique Oily-Friendly Eyeliner for Long-Lasting Results

Clinique Oily-Friendly Eyeliner for Long-Lasting Results | Image

The Clinique Black/Brown Quickliner for Eyes is a reliable and easy-to-use product that provides long-lasting and smudge-resistant color to your eyes. The silky formula glides smoothly onto your eyelids, creating a range of bold and subtle looks. The smudging tip on the opposite end allows you to achieve the desired effect, while the secure recap ensures that the product stays fresh and ready to use.

One of the most notable features of this eyeliner is its versatility - it can be used alone or over eyeshadow, making it a perfect addition to your makeup routine. The product is also water-resistant, providing peace of mind during rainy days. Despite being a bit pricey, the Quickliner for Eyes has a loyal fan base who appreciate its performance and ease of application.

However, the product is not without its drawbacks. Some users have commented that the volume seems to be decreasing with each purchase, while others have experienced difficulty in finding an appropriate sharpener for the eyeliner.

Overall, the Clinique Black/Brown Quickliner for Eyes is a quality product that delivers on its promises of color intensity and smudge resistance. Whether you're a makeup enthusiast looking to elevate your eye makeup game or someone who needs a reliable liner for everyday use, this eyeliner is definitely worth considering.

Buyer's Guide

Eyeliner can enhance your makeup look and define your eyes, whether you are a beginner or a pro. However, as you age, your eyes may change, and certain types of eyeliner might not work as well for mature eyes. This buyer's guide will help you find the best eyeliner for mature eyes, focusing on important features, considerations, and general advice for choosing the right eyeliner.

Eyeliner Types

When choosing eyeliner for mature eyes, it is essential to consider the type of eyeliner that will work best for you. There are different kinds available, such as pencil, liquid, gel, and powder eyeliners. Pencil eyeliners are great for smudging and blending, while liquid and gel eyeliners provide more precise lines and long-lasting wear. Powder eyeliners are less common but can work well for those who prefer a softer look.

Formula

The formula of the eyeliner is crucial for mature eyes, as it can affect ease of application, blendability, and wear time. Look for eyeliners with ingredients that are gentle on your skin and eyes, such as vitamin E, which helps moisturize the skin and prevent irritation. Waterproof formulas are also essential for mature eyes, as they are less likely to smudge or wear off throughout the day.

Application Tips

When applying eyeliner for mature eyes, it is essential to consider the shape of your eyes, the position of your eyelashes, and the thickness of the line. Start by applying a light layer of eyeliner to your upper lash line and gradually build up the intensity. Use a thin, angled brush to create a winged look or a slightly blurred effect for a more natural look. Avoid applying eyeliner too close to your lash line, as this can make your eyes appear smaller.

Considerations for Mature Eyes

As you age, the skin around your eyes may become thinner and more sensitive. Therefore, it is essential to choose eyeliners that are gentle on your skin and do not irritate your eyes. Avoid using sharp, hard-to-control pencil eyeliners, as they can cause irritation and tug at your skin. Opt for soft, smudgable pencils or easy-to-apply liquid and gel eyeliners.

FAQ

Why are eyeliners for mature eyes different from regular eyeliners?

Eyeliners for mature eyes are designed to cater to the needs of individuals who have experienced changes in their skin around the eye area such as fine lines, wrinkles, and dryness. These eyeliners often come with formulations that are gentler and more moisturizing to avoid irritation and maintain the skin's natural elasticity.

Additionally, they can have colors that are more suitable for older skin or may offer a more subtle, natural look to enhance the eyes without appearing too harsh or heavy. These eyeliners also tend to have easier application methods, such as pencils, gels, or kohl-based formulas, to ensure precision and smudge-free wear.

What are the best eyeliners for mature eyes?

The best eyeliners for mature eyes are formulated to address the unique concerns that come with aging skin. These eyeliners offer a blend of moisturizing and anti-aging ingredients while providing a long-lasting and smudge-free application. Some of the top brands for eyeliners for mature eyes include Benefit Cosmetics, Dior, and Lancôme.

As for specific products, the article recommends trying the Benefit Cosmetics They're Real! Push-Up Liner and the Dior Diorshow On Stage Liner. These eyeliners deliver a fine point for precise application and provide long-lasting wear without irritating the skin around the eyes. The Lancôme Écriture de Couture Waterproof Liner is another great option, offering a blend of moisture and durability for a smudge-free look that lasts all day.

How do I apply eyeliner for mature eyes?

When applying eyeliner for mature eyes, it's essential to be gentle and precise in your application. Begin by choosing a shade that complements your skin tone and eye color, and ensure that the formula is suitable for your age and skin type. Start with a light hand and apply the eyeliner close to the lashes, following the natural curve of your eye.

If you prefer a winged look, angle the eyeliner brush or pencil at a 30- to 45-degree angle, creating a "V" shape above your natural lash line. Apply a thin line of eyeliner, gradually building up the intensity. Finish by smoothing any lines and blending the product into your skin for a natural and seamless look. If you're new to using eyeliner or have sensitive skin, consider using a gentle eyeshadow brush to apply the eyeliner, which can help minimize irritation and provide a more controlled application.

Are waterproof eyeliners better for mature eyes?

Waterproof eyeliners can be a good choice for mature eyes, as they tend to last longer and resist smudging or melting away. However, they can also be more challenging to remove, which may be a concern for individuals with sensitive skin or dry eyes. If you choose a waterproof eyeliner, look for one that is gentle on your skin and has a nourishing formulation with moisturizing ingredients.

Whether a waterproof or non-waterproof eyeliner is better depends on your personal preferences and concerns. If you live in a humid area or are prone to tears or sweating, a waterproof eyeliner may be a better choice. If you have sensitive skin or worry about irritation, consider a non-waterproof formula or one with a gentler formulation that is suitable for mature skin and eyes.

Can I mix different types of eyeliner for mature eyes?

Absolutely! Mixing different types of eyeliner for mature eyes can help you achieve the desired look while addressing your unique concerns. For example, you may use a moisturizing pencil for the waterline and a smudge-proof liquid or gel liner for the lash line. Alternatively, you could combine a waterproof pencil with a long-lasting eyeshadow for a blend of moisture and durability.

When mixing eyeliners, ensure that the products you choose are compatible and have similar formulations. Read the product labels and reviews, and consider consulting with a makeup artist or beauty professional for guidance on the best combination for your needs. Remember to clean your makeup brushes or applicator tools regularly to avoid contamination or the spread of bacteria.

How do I remove eyeliner for mature eyes without causing irritation?

Removing eyeliner for mature eyes requires a gentle approach to avoid irritation and maintain healthy skin around the eye area. Choose a makeup remover or cleanser that is suitable for your skin type and is specifically designed for the delicate skin around the eyes. Look for products that are free from harsh chemicals, fragrances, or alcohol, which can strip the skin of its natural moisture and cause irritation.

To remove eyeliner, gently press a cotton pad or makeup remover pad soaked in the appropriate cleanser or remover onto your eyelid and lash line for a few seconds. Gently swipe the pad in a downward motion, taking care not to irritate the skin or pull on your eyelashes. Rinse your eyes with water, then repeat the process if necessary. When you're done, apply a hydrating eye cream or serum to help moisturize and protect the skin around your eyes.

As an Amazon Affiliate™ I receive compensation from qualifying purchases at no cost to you

--

--