The Great Indian Gharanas: A Journey Through Music Lineages

Explore the historical significance and modern relevance of Indian Gharanas in shaping the Indian classical music landscape.

-By Shambhavi

History & Origin

Within the intricate fabric of Indian classical music, a significant divergence occurred during the 12th century, giving rise to two distinct but interconnected systems: Hindustani classical music and Carnatic classical music. Central to both systems are the melodic musical modes called ragas, accompanied by rhythmic cycles known as talas. Hindustani music, in particular, introduced several key elements that would pave the way for the emergence of gharanas. It embraced the Shudha Swara Saptaka or the Octave of Natural Notes, emphasizing melodic intricacies and eschewing the concept of harmony, a distinctive characteristic setting it apart from Western music. These foundational principles of melody and rhythm were documented in ancient Indian texts, including the Natya Shastra by Bharata (2nd–3rd century CE) and Dattilam, likely to have been composed in the 3rd to 4th century CE.

Did You Know: Amir Khusrau (1253–1325) is celebrated for his contributions to Hindustani music. He not only introduced several ragas like Yaman Kalyan, Zeelaf, and Sarpada but also created vital musical genres like Tarana, Naqsh, Gul, Qaul, and Qalbana.

The landscape of Indian classical music witnessed a significant transformation with the arrival of Islamic rule under the Delhi Sultanate and later the Mughal Empire in northern India. This era fostered a rich cultural exchange, where musicians began receiving patronage in the courts of the new rulers, who, in turn, developed a growing interest in local musical forms. Following the decline of the Mughal Empire, music patronage persisted in smaller princely realms such as Awadh, Patiala, and Banaras. This patronage nurtured a flourishing diversity of musical styles, now recognized as gharanas. Concurrently, the Bhakti and Sufi traditions continued to evolve and intertwine with various gharanas and groups, enriching India’s musical heritage.

Around 1900, Vishnu Narayan Bhatkhande played a pivotal role in structuring the complex framework of Hindustani classical music, particularly by classifying ragas based on their note structures, leading to the concept of thaats. These are Bilawal, Kalyan, Khamaj, Bhairav, Poorvi, Marwa, Kafi, Asavari, Bhairavi, and Todi.

At the heart of the musical heritage is the Guru-Shishya Parampara, an ancient tradition that ensured the transmission of this intricate knowledge from one generation to the next, preserving gharana-specific styles and wisdom.

Did You Know: Within Hindustani music, there are ten principal singing styles, including Dhrupad, Khayal, Tappa, Chaturanga, Tarana, Sargam, Thumri, Ragasagar, Hori, and Dhamar, each contributing to the captivating diversity of gharana music.

About Gharanas

In Hindustani music, a ‘gharana’ is more than just a terminology; it represents a profound cultural and musical legacy. The term ‘gharana’ finds its roots in the Hindi word ghar, meaning ‘house.’ Essentially, it refers to a musical community or lineage where performers share a distinctive musical style that can be traced back to a particular instructor or region. The concept of gharanas began to take shape in the 19th century, but it wasn’t until the 20th century that it evolved into a structured system for the mediation of classical music.

This system was born out of the need for musicians to maintain their artistic identity and authority, particularly at a time when the patronage from princely courts was in decline. It served as a means by which musicians could emphasize their lineage and preserve their unique musical traditions. Even in the 21st century, the gharana system continues to play a pivotal role in validating North Indian classical musicians.

A ‘distinctive musical style’ in the context of Hindustani classical music encompasses not only the nuances of performance and repertoire but also a broader set of ideals, including music, aesthetics, and pedagogy. To be officially recognized as a gharana, this unique style must be passed down through three generations, ensuring its continuity and authenticity.

Traditionally, the transmission of musical knowledge involved students, or disciples, moving into the homes of their teachers, creating an environment conducive to the faithful transfer of musical traditions. Gharanas are not limited to vocal music alone; they also exist in instrumental traditions. For example, the Gwalior vocal gharana, named after its city of origin in what is now the state of Madhya Pradesh, is widely acknowledged as one of the oldest gharanas, with its roots dating back to the first half of the 19th century.

Guru Shishya Parampara

The Guru-Shishya Parampara is a revered tradition in Indian classical music, emphasizing the transmission of knowledge, artistic techniques, and cultural legacies from one generation to the next. This sacred tradition goes beyond mere education; it fosters a profound spiritual and personal connection between the guru (teacher) and the shishya (student), where parampara represents an unbroken succession.

Roles in the Tradition:

• The Guru: The guru serves as both a teacher and a guide, imparting not only musical knowledge but also life wisdom and values. Gurus are held in high esteem, and their teachings are considered almost sacred.
• The Shishya: The shishya is the dedicated student who seeks to learn and internalize the knowledge and skills passed down by the guru. Humility and receptivity are paramount as shishyas absorb the guru’s wisdom and expertise.

Residential Learning:

Students would reside with their guru, immersing themselves in the guru’s teachings, lifestyle, and musical environment. This intimate learning experience extended beyond formal lessons to everyday life. This system was also associated with the Gurukul system, where students lived in their guru’s home, serving and learning in return.

Transmission of Knowledge:

• The Guru-Shishya Parampara involves oral and experiential transmission, emphasizing practical lessons, listening, and imitation of the guru’s performances.
• Shishyas closely observe their gurus, emulating their musical expressions and nuances.

Key Aspects:

a. Establishment of Teacher-Student Bond:

• Initiation into a teacher-student relationship forms its core.

b. Diksha (Formal Initiation):

• This marks the formal recognition of the relationship, often in a structured initiation ceremony.
• During Diksha, the guru acknowledges the initiate as a shishya and assumes responsibility for their spiritual growth.

c. Shiksha (Knowledge Transmission):

• The initiation process frequently includes the imparting of esoteric wisdom and meditation techniques.

d. Gurudakshina (Token of Gratitude):

• As an expression of gratitude, the shishya gives a gift to the guru.
• This gift can range from a simple offering like a piece of fruit to more significant tokens.

e. Guru Gotra (Surname Adoption):

• Some disciples adopt the name of their guru or parampara as their gotra (surname) instead of their birth gotra.
• Students who share the same guru are often referred to as guru bhrata (brothers) or guru bhagini (sisters).

f. One or Multiple Gurus:

• The presence of one or multiple active masters at the same time within a guruparamaparya (lineage) varies among different paramparas.

Some other aspects are:

• Dedication: Shishyas wholeheartedly dedicated themselves to their guru’s guidance.
• Tolerance: They tolerated tantrums and challenges posed by the guru.
• Household Duties: Shishyas willingly performed household chores for their guru.

Early gharana stalwarts closely guarded their musical ideologies and styles. The skillset was selectively passed down to their own offspring or exceptionally deserving students, not widely disseminated but carefully nurtured within the gharana.

Modern Adaptations and Challenges of Guru-Shishya Parampara

In adapting to the modern era, the Guru-Shishya Parampara faces both opportunities and hurdles. Changing lifestyles and the influence of technology have prompted gurus and students to reconsider the traditional residency model in favor of flexible and virtual training. Balancing the preservation of gharana-specific styles with contemporary musical trends remains a delicate endeavor. Gurus seek to accommodate more students while maintaining the personal touch that defines the tradition. Financial sustainability, cultural preservation, and making classical music accessible to a wider audience are ongoing concerns. These adaptations, while dynamic, reflect the tradition’s resilience in the face of modern complexities.

Famous Gharanas

Let’s briefly explore a handful of illustrious Hindustani classical music gharanas, highlighting their distinctive styles and notable founders.

Gwalior Gharana:

Founded in the mid-16th century by Ustad Nathan Pir Baksh and Ustad Nathu Khan, the Gwalior Gharana in Hindustani classical music is known for its significant exponents such as Vishnu Digambar Paluskar, Pt Raja Bhaiya Poochwale, and Malini Rajurkar. Distinct features of this gharana include a strong focus on gamaks in taans, the use of bol-baant and bol-taan, absence of sargam, a wide range in taans, and a preference for simple ragas. Equally emphasizing melody and rhythm, it boasts a rich repertoire of bandishes and a diverse array of taans.

Qawwal Bacchon ka Gharana:

Dating back to the 13th century, the Qawwal Bacchon ka Gharana was founded by Ustad Abu’l Hasan Yamīn ud-Dīn Khusrau and his 12 students, including Amir Khusrau and Mir Hassan Sawant. As the most ancient khayal gharana, it distinguishes itself with a greater sense of freedom in approaching raagdari. Notably, this gharana places a strong emphasis on emotional expression (bhav) and has a rich tradition of exposition.

Benares Tabla Gharana:

Founded in the late 19th century by Pandit Ram Sahai, the Benares Tabla Gharana is recognized for its powerful sound and finesse. Belonging to the Purbi baaj category, it utilizes resonant tabla strokes like Na and Din. Noteworthy exponents include Anokhelal Mishra, Samta Prasad, and Kumar Bose. The gharana, part of the eastern baaj, shares its category with Farukhabad and Lucknow gharanas.

Jaipur-Atrauli Gharana:

Established in the late 19th century by Ustad Alladiya Khan, the Jaipur-Atrauli Gharana is known for its Dagar-bani, Gauhar-bani, and Khandar-bani styles. Proponents such as Alladiya Khan and Kesarbai Kerkar showcase extended open-throated aakaar singing across three octaves. The style seamlessly blends swara and laya within a steady tempo, featuring intricate note patterns executed spontaneously.

Darbhanga Gharana:

Originating in the 18th century, the Darbhanga Gharana, founded by Radhakrishna and Kartaram in the court of the Maharaja of Darbhanga, draws its foundation from the Gauhar Vani of dhrupad. Notable exponents include Ram Chatur Mallick and Prem Kumar Mallik. Distinguishing itself, this gharana maintains equal emphasis on both the alap and the bandish, a departure from the typical focus on alap in other dhrupad gharanas.

However, these represent just a fraction of the diverse and intricate musical traditions, with Kirana, Delhi, and Indore gharanas standing as additional examples among the myriad glorious musical traditions that have flourished within this captivating realm.

Elements of a Gharana

Listed below are some of the most important characteristic features of a Gharana that give one its exclusivity:

1. Distinctive Style: Each gharana has its unique style of rendering ragas, including variations in note emphasis, ornamentation, and improvisational techniques.
2. Specific Repertoire: Gharanas often have their own set of compositions (bandishes) that are passed down through generations and contribute to their distinct identity.
3. Emphasis on Particular Aspects: Some gharanas place a stronger emphasis on specific elements like laya (rhythm), taans (fast melodic patterns), or alap (the opening, slow-tempo section of a raga).
4. Innovative Techniques: Gharanas may introduce innovative techniques, ornaments, or note combinations that distinguish their rendition of ragas.
5. Teaching Methodology: Gharanas often have their own teaching methodologies, including the Guru-Shishya Parampara, where knowledge is passed down through generations.
6. Influence of Guru’s Ideology: The guru’s musical philosophy and values can heavily influence a gharana’s style, particularly when it’s named after the guru.
7. Emphasis on Bhav (Emotion): Some gharanas are known for their strong emphasis on the emotional expression (bhav) within the music.
8. Incorporation of Regional Styles: Gharanas often reflect regional influences, which can be traced back to their geographic origins.
9. Influence on Gharana Successors: The lineage of disciples can play a significant role in shaping and preserving the gharana’s distinctive elements.
10. Inclusiveness or Exclusiveness: Some gharanas may be more open to integrating external influences, while others remain exclusive and true to their traditional style.
11. Preference for Vocal or Instrumental Music: While vocal music gharanas focus on singing, instrumental gharanas are specific to instruments like the sitar or tabla.

Is the Gharana System still relevant?

In today’s globalized world, the gharana system does face challenges. Musicians now often train in multiple gharanas, blurring the once-pure lines of tradition. The modern landscape, shaped by technology, offers easy access to diverse musical styles, challenging the notion of regional boundaries. However, the gharana system remains profoundly relevant. It stands as a guardian of an extensive artistic heritage, preserving a treasure trove of compositions, improvisations, and techniques. The gharanas offer depth and nuance, enabling musicians to delve into the intricate facets of raga and rhythm, all while providing a unique sense of identity and continuity.

In adapting to the modern era, some artists blend gharana elements with contemporary influences, resulting in fusion music. Others choose to innovate within the gharana framework, gracefully adapting to the changing times. While the gharana system may have evolved from its once-rigid form, its essence endures.

As musicians navigate this modern world, they masterfully balance tradition and innovation, ensuring that the gharana system remains a vibrant and integral part of India’s rich cultural fabric.

Way Forward

The gharana system in Indian classical music, with its prosperous history, holds the potential to shape a vibrant future. It maintains the tradition and lineage while embracing innovation. Encouraging individual expression within the framework of tradition and exploring fusion and collaboration open new horizons. Leveraging technology and reviving lesser-known gharanas democratizes access to classical music, and adapting to changing audiences ensures continued relevance.

To sum it all up, the gharana system is not a relic of the past but a living tradition with the resilience to thrive in the modern world. By nurturing creativity, embracing technology, and engaging with diverse audiences, it remains a beacon of India’s classical music heritage, inspiring generations to come.

Sources:

Indianclassicalmusic.com: https://www.indianclassicalmusic.com/benaras-gharana#:~:text=Benaras%20Gharana&text=It%20was%20established%20by%20Pandit,of%20Lucknow%20style%20of%20playing.

Britannica.com: https://www.britannica.com/art/gharana

Indianetzone.com: https://www.indianetzone.com/27/jaipuratrauli_gharana_khayal_indian_music.htm#google_vignette

Indianexpress.com: https://indianexpress.com/article/express-sunday-eye/indian-classical-music-guru-shishya-6584626/

Drishtiias.com: https://www.drishtiias.com/to-the-points/paper1/hindustani-music-1

Samiaclassicalmusic.com: https://samiaclassicalmusic.com/apprenticeship/

Academia.edu: https://www.academia.edu/37918212/guru_shishya_parampara