Why a Landmark Experiment Into Dimming the Sun Got Canceled

Who gets to decide whether we study solar geoengineering?

Grist
8 min readApr 13, 2021
A balloon launch at the Esrange Space Center near Kiruna, where the first SCoPEx flight would have taken place. Photo: Copyright SSC

By Shannon Osaka

The experiment sounded innocuous. Early this summer, a group of researchers from Harvard University would fly to Kiruna, a small town of 22,000 in the northern reaches of Sweden. There, with the help of a Swedish space company, they would launch a balloon carrying an instrument-laden gondola into the stratosphere, some 12.5 miles above the Earth’s surface. They would run a few tests, pack up the instruments, and then return home.

That, at least, was the plan. But some saw the project — known as the Stratospheric Controlled Perturbation Experiment, or SCoPEx for short — as something less innocent. It was poised to be one of the first outdoor experiments into what is known as “solar geoengineering”: the process of spraying particles into the upper atmosphere to reflect sunlight and, ideally, counter the skyrocketing temperatures caused by climate change. It’s a technology so controversial that even the prospect of researching it can provoke anxiety — and backlash.

SCoPEx was no exception. The team didn’t plan to release any particles over Kiruna; the first flight was simply a dry-run for the instruments and the balloon’s propellor-powered gondola. But in…

--

--

Grist

Using the power of storytelling to show that a just and sustainable future is within reach.