What Does It Mean When a Child Consistently Chooses to Draw in Black?

Kate Chered
4 min readDec 26, 2023

--

How Drawing in Black Can Be a Normal Aspect of Child Development

Drawing with paints, pencils, and markers is a beloved activity for many children. Yet, sometimes, the choice of colors in children’s artwork, particularly black or predominantly dark tones, can cause worry rather than wonder in parents. Understanding the implications of these color choices is crucial before jumping to conclusions.

For young children, distinguishing primary colors becomes clear around the age of three. However, even beyond this age, the choice of color in their drawings isn’t always significant. Children under four often prefer black due to its high contrast and visibility, an attribute not necessarily indicative of psychological issues. Anastasia Paschenko, a child psychologist, explains that young children select black for its stark contrast to the drawing surface, making it easier for them to see their work. At this stage, drawing is more about expressing their fantasies in graphic form, irrespective of color realism. Thus, a black snowman or bluegrass in their drawings is more about creativity than color accuracy.

For children aged 5 to 10 years, the conscious choice of colors begins to play a more significant role. However, a preference for black in drawings can still be normal. It might reflect a simple liking for the boldness and expressiveness of black, a shortage of other colors, or an interest in graphic art, which often relies heavily on black for line work and shading.

When Should Parents Be Concerned About Their Child’s Preference for Black in Drawings?

As children grow and develop, their drawings become more than just playful expressions; they can be reflections of their inner world and emotions. A child’s use of dark colors, especially in certain contexts or themes, might warrant a closer look. This persistent use of black might express negative feelings or psychological distress, but it’s important to consider the context and frequency of such usage.

Parents should observe whether the child’s preference for black or dark colors is consistent across all artistic expressions or limited to specific themes or moods. Additionally, the child’s overall behavior and emotional state should be considered. If a child seems withdrawn or anxious or displays significant changes in behavior or mood, using dark colors in drawings might be part of a larger picture that needs addressing.

What Actions Can Parents Take if Concerned About Their Child’s Drawings?

If parents are concerned about their child’s frequent use of black in drawings, the first step is to communicate openly with the child. Engaging in a non-judgmental, curious conversation about their artwork can provide insights into their thoughts and feelings. Parents need to avoid leading questions or assumptions that might influence the child’s responses.

Seeking the guidance of a child psychologist or counselor can be beneficial, especially if there are other signs of distress or behavioral changes in the child. A professional can help interpret the drawings in the context of the child’s overall development and emotional state, offering a more comprehensive understanding.

In conclusion. In contrast, the frequent use of black in a child’s drawings can sometimes cause concern; it’s often a normal part of their developmental and artistic exploration. Understanding the child’s context, themes, and overall behavior is crucial in determining whether this preference signifies deeper issues. Open communication and, if necessary, professional guidance can help parents support their child’s emotional and artistic growth.

FAQs

How Can Parents Interpret a Child’s Frequent Use of Black in Their Drawings?

Parents should understand that the use of black in a child’s drawings can vary in meaning based on age and context. For younger children, it often signifies a preference for contrast and visibility rather than an emotional state. In older children, consistent use of black, especially if coupled with dark themes, might indicate deeper emotional issues or a strong preference for the boldness of the color. It’s important to consider the child’s overall behavior and emotional well-being alongside their artistic choices.

What Are the Normal Reasons for Children to Choose Black When Drawing?

Children may choose black for various non-concerning reasons. Younger children often find black appealing due to its high contrast, making their drawings more visible. In children between 5 and 10 years, black might be preferred for its boldness and expressiveness or due to a lack of other available colors. An interest in graphic art predominantly using black can also lead to this preference.

When Should Parents Worry About Their Child’s Preference for Dark Colors in Art?

Parents should be observant if a child consistently uses dark colors like black in a manner that seems reflective of their mood or themes of distress. If this preference for dark colors is accompanied by behavior, mood, or social interaction changes, it might suggest underlying emotional or psychological issues. In such cases, talking to the child and seeking professional advice is advisable.

How Can Parents Approach a Conversation About Their Child’s Dark-Colored Drawings?

Parents should adopt a curious and non-judgmental tone when discussing drawings with children. Ask open-ended questions about the artwork, encouraging the child to express their thoughts and feelings about their creations. It’s crucial to avoid leading questions that might prompt the child to give expected answers rather than their true feelings.

Where Can Parents Seek Help if Concerned About Their Child’s Artistic Choices?

If parents are concerned about their child’s persistent use of black or dark colors in drawings, especially if other signs of distress are present, consulting a child psychologist or counselor can be beneficial. These professionals can provide a more nuanced understanding of the child’s emotional state and offer guidance on supporting their development.

Originally published at https://beingmotherhood.com on December 26, 2023.

--

--