The Laws Of Thought

8 min readJul 14, 2024

With Contributing Writer CW Van Buren

NEW!/2024

Listen Anytime, Anywhere: Enhanced Audio on Medium

Click the ▶️‘Listen’ button at the top right to hear any story read aloud by Speechify®. Choose your favourite voice-over artist: Erica, Michael, Henry, Kristy, Oliver, Kyle (one of my favourites).

“Immerse yourself in diverse narratives without missing a beat!”

Lady of Justice Blinded while Balancing the Scales of Justice. **Image Source:** G.C.

The foundational principles of rational thinking, known as the Laws of Thought, are integral to logical reasoning. These include the Law of Identity, the Law of Non-Contradiction, the Law of Excluded Middle, and the Law of Detachment (Modus Ponens).

These (04)-four seminal laws, attributed to the ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle, form the bedrock of classical logic and continue to underpin modern intellectual discourse.

These laws are categorized under classical logic and are foundational rules for rational thinking and reasoning. The primary laws of thought include:

01. The Law of Identity:

This law states that an object is the same as itself (A is A). It is the principle that everything is identical to itself.

Let’s break down the Law of Identity in a way that’s relatable to everyday life.

A young boy is delighting himself in a jar of gooey chocolate, fully enjoying the sweet mess. **Image Source:** Cottonbro Studio

The Law of Identity: Real-Life Application

The Law of Identity states that an object is the same as itself (A is A). In simpler terms, it means that everything is exactly what it is, and not something else.

This principle may sound abstract, but it’s something we rely on in our daily lives.

Everyday Example:

Consider your mobile phone. When you look at your phone, you know it’s your phone because it has specific characteristics — its shape, colour, and the apps installed on it.

You don’t confuse your phone with your notebook/laptop because your phone is identifiably and unequivocally your phone (A is A).

Practical Scenario:

Imagine you’re in a grocery store, and you need to buy a bottle of water. You identify the bottle of water by its label, shape, and the clear liquid inside.

You don’t mistake it for a bottle of pop/soda, because the water bottle is what it is — a bottle of water (A is A). This clarity helps you make the correct choice effortlessly.

Personal Reflection:

In relationships, the Law of Identity reminds us to accept people for who they are.

Just as you wouldn’t expect an apple to taste like an orange, you shouldn’t expect people to behave contrary to their nature.
Recognizing and respecting the identity of others fosters better understanding and harmony.

This principle is a fundamental aspect of clear thinking and effective decision-making in everyday situations.

02. The Law of Non-Contradiction:

This law asserts that contradictory statements cannot both be true in the same sense at the same time (A cannot be both A and not A).

The Law of Non-Contradiction: Real-Life Application

The Law of Non-Contradiction asserts that contradictory statements cannot both be true in the same sense at the same time (A cannot be both A and not A). This principle is essential for clear and logical thinking.

Everyday Example:

Imagine you’re planning a picnic. You look outside and see that it’s sunny. If someone then tells you, “It’s raining right now,” you know that it cannot be both sunny and raining in the exact same place and time.

The weather cannot be simultaneously sunny and rainy because that would be a contradiction (A cannot be both A and not A).

Practical Scenario:

Think about a recipe that calls for sugar. If the recipe says, “Add one cup of sugar,” but someone else says, “Don’t add any sugar,” you know these two instructions cannot both be correct in the same context.

You must decide which instruction to follow because adding sugar and not adding sugar are contradictory actions (A cannot be both A and not A).

Personal Reflection:

In personal integrity, the Law of Non-Contradiction helps us maintain consistency. For example, if you value honesty, you cannot claim to be honest while also engaging in deceitful behaviour.

Your actions and values must align because you cannot be both honest and dishonest in the same context (A cannot be both A and not A).

This principle is vital for making coherent decisions and understanding reality clearly.

03. The Law of Excluded Middle:

According to this law, for any proposition, either that proposition is true or its negation is true (either A or not A).

Let’s break down the Law of Excluded Middle with a relatable everyday application.

At Home When the new family pet comes out to play. **Image Source:** MART PRODUCTION

The Law of Excluded Middle: Real-Life Application

The Law of Excluded Middle states that for any proposition, either that proposition is true or its negation is true (either A or not A). There is no middle ground between a statement and its opposite.

Everyday Example:

Consider the simple statement, “The light is on.” According to the Law of Excluded Middle, this statement is either true or false — either the light is on, or it is not on (A or not A). There is no third option where the light is somehow partially on or off at the same time.

Practical Scenario:

Imagine you’re at a crossroads deciding whether to go to a movie or stay home. The proposition is, “I will go to the movie.” According to the Law of Excluded Middle, you either go to the movie (true) or you do not go to the movie (false). There’s no middle ground where you both go and do not go to the movie.

Personal Reflection:

In decision-making, the Law of Excluded Middle helps clarify choices. For instance, if you are deciding whether to apply for a job, the proposition “I will apply for the job” must be either true or false.

You either decide to apply (true) or you do not apply (false). This clarity can help you make firm and decisive actions without wavering.

Breathtaking view of Lake Bled with its picturesque island and the surrounding mountains in Slovenia. **Image Source:** Pixabay

This principle helps eliminate ambiguity and ensures that decisions and statements are clear-cut and definitive.

04. And Finally The Law of Detachment (Modus Ponens):

This rule states that if a conditional statement (“If A, then B”) is accepted, and the antecedent (A) holds, then the consequent (B) can be inferred.

Applying the Principle of Detachment in Everyday Life

Imagine you’re preparing for a job interview. You’ve studied diligently and prepared thoroughly for the interview process (A). However, instead of receiving the job offer as you hoped (B), you find out that another candidate was chosen.

Initial Disappointment:

Initially, you might feel disappointed because you put in a lot of effort and had hoped for a positive outcome (If A, then B). According to the Law of Detachment, however, you maintain a mindset of detachment from specific outcomes.

Adaptation and New Opportunities:

Despite not getting the job (B), you decide to stay open-minded and continue applying for other opportunities without dwelling on the disappointment. This detachment allows you to remain focused on doing your best (A) without being overly affected by the outcome.

Unexpected Turn:

Later on, you receive a call from another company that noticed your application and invites you for an interview for a position that better aligns with your long-term career goals ©. This opportunity turns out to be even better than the first one you applied for (B).

Reflection:

In this scenario, the Law of Detachment (Modus Ponens) applies because you focused on putting in your best effort (A) without being fixated on a specific outcome (B). This detachment from expectations allowed you to adapt to new opportunities © which ultimately led to a more favourable outcome than you initially anticipated.

Conclusion:

The Law of Detachment teaches us the importance of focusing on our efforts and actions (A) Without being overly attached to specific outcomes (B) By maintaining this mindset, we can navigate setbacks and unexpected changes more gracefully, often leading to unforeseen and positive outcomes ©.

These laws are crucial for logical reasoning and critical thinking, forming the backbone of logical discourse and argumentation.

Quotes,

The following Quotes are from the original Authors themselves. To learn more about the Authors see my Story “Quotes!”.

Aristotle

“The more you know, the more you realize you don’t know.”

“Knowing yourself is the beginning of all wisdom.”

“It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it.”

“The whole is greater than the sum of its parts.”

Albert Einstein

“The important thing is not to stop questioning. Curiosity has its own reason for existence.”

“Imagination is more important than knowledge. For knowledge is limited, whereas imagination embraces the entire world.”

“Look deep into nature, and then you will understand everything better.”

Leonardo da Vinci

“Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication.”

“Learning never exhausts the mind.”

“Where there is shouting, there is no true knowledge.”

Stephen Hawking

“Intelligence is the ability to adapt to change.”

“The greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it is the illusion of knowledge.”

“We are just an advanced breed of monkeys on a minor planet of a very average star. But we can understand the universe. That makes us something very special.”