Top 12 Shelley Shepard Gray Books

Joshua Johnson
11 min readOct 1, 2024

Dive into the captivating world of Shelley Shepard Gray with our book roundup article. Discover the enchanting stories that she weaves through her unique blend of romance and mystery. Stay tuned as we share our top picks from her latest collection of novels, promising to keep you engaged from start to finish.

As an Amazon Associate, we may earn through qualified purchases

1. Grace

grace-439632–1

A Christmas Sisters of the Heart Novel

In the heartwarming Christmas novel "Grace, " join the Brenneman family at their cozy Bed and Breakfast as they prepare to close for the holiday season. Just as they embrace the festive cheer, two mysterious strangers unexpectedly arrive, testing their hospitality. As Levi and Melody settle in, the family tries their best to make the situation comfortable- except for Katie, who senses there's more to these guests' stories than meets the eye.

As a snowstorm traps everyone at the inn, secrets begin to unfold, revealing the true reasons behind these two strangers' arrival. Experience the magic of forgiveness, love, and redemption in Shelley Shepard Gray's captivating tale.

  • Authors: Shelley Shepard Gray
  • Publisher: Zondervan
  • Published Date: October 26, 2010
  • Page Count: 306.0
  • Print Type: BOOK
  • Categories: Fiction
  • Maturity Rating: NOT\_MATURE
  • Language: en

Enjoy Free with Amazon Audible

Enjoy Free at Kindle Unlimited

2. The Caregiver

the-caregiver-439635–1

"In 'The Caregiver, ' Amish couple Lucy and Calvin Weaver experience the intermingling of grief and hope. When Lucy's cousin is diagnosed with breast cancer, she takes on the role of caregiver despite the heart-wrenching grief over losing her own husband. Her journey becomes a metaphor for growth and inner strength, a testament to the healing power of love.

On their way to Jacob's Crossing, Lucy and Calvin encounter each other on a train stalled in Cleveland. With Calvin's little sister in tow, they find solace in their common Amish faith amidst the unfamiliar English world. But their time together is not without struggle. The weight of their shared losses threatens to drive a wedge between them, leaving both feeling vulnerable.

Once they reach Jacob's Crossing, Lucy and Calvin are pulled into a whirlwind of familial obligations. The burden of their shared experiences proves to be too much for them to ignore, and they struggle to move past the emotional barriers that separate them. It takes a miracle for them to find the resilience needed to heal their hearts and forge a new path, hand-in-hand.

New York Times bestselling author Shelley Shepard Gray paints a picture of hope amidst despair and love in the face of adversity. 'The Caregiver' is a testament to the enduring strength of the human spirit and the power of love to overcome even the most challenging of circumstances. "

  • Authors: Shelley Shepard Gray
  • Publisher: Harper Collins
  • Published Date: March 08, 2011
  • Page Count: 251.0
  • Print Type: BOOK
  • Categories: Fiction
  • Maturity Rating: NOT\_MATURE
  • Language: en

Listen for Free on Amazon Audible

Explore Free at Kindle Unlimited

3. The Caregiver

the-caregiver-439631–1

Embark on an unforgettable journey with The Caregiver, the mesmerizing first installment in a new series by the esteemed Shelley Shepard Gray, renowned for her heartwarming Amish inspirational romances.

On a stormy night, two lives collide on a train headed to Cleveland. Driven by destiny and the need for redemption, their paths converge, and an unexpected bond begins to form as they navigate the challenges and joys of caregiving.

As the storm outside rages on, the characters within discover their own inner strength and the power of love to heal. The Caregiver is a captivating and heart-wrenching tale that will leave you pondering the intricacies of life and the transformative power of compassion.

Step aboard the train and embark on a journey filled with love, forgiveness, and the unbreakable bond of caregiving. The Caregiver, published by Large Print Press, is a must-read for fans of Shelley Shepard Gray's Amish series and those seeking an uplifting and unforgettable literary experience.

  • Authors: Shelley Shepard Gray
  • Publisher: Large Print Press
  • Published Date: April 15, 2011
  • Print Type: BOOK
  • Categories: Amish
  • Maturity Rating: NOT\_MATURE
  • Language: en

Hear Free with Audible

Enjoy Free on Kindle Unlimited

4. A Sister's Wish

a-sisters-wish-430268–1

The Charmed Amish Life, Book Three

A Sister's Wish is the third installment in Shelley Shepard Gray's beloved Charmed Amish Life series, where traditions clash with unexpected desires. Amelia Kinsinger, the epitome of the perfect Amish woman, harbors a secret affection for Simon Hochstetler, a man from the wrong side of the tracks. Having endured a troubled past, Simon returns to Charm and finds himself drawn to Amelia, a woman who represents his only hope for redemption.

As the two embark on a forbidden love affair, they must confront their pasts and navigate the challenges of their present. Will Amelia accept the man who has come to know her heart best, even with his dark past?

A Sister's Wish delves into the world of Amish love, revealing the power of forgiveness, trust, and the resilience of the human spirit.

  • Authors: Shelley Shepard Gray
  • Publisher: HarperCollins
  • Published Date: September 27, 2016
  • Page Count: 272.0
  • Print Type: BOOK
  • Categories: Fiction
  • Maturity Rating: NOT\_MATURE
  • Language: en

Enjoy Free via Amazon Audible

Explore for Free at Kindle Unlimited

5. Her Secret

her-secret-439636–1

The Amish of Hart County

Acclaimed by both New York Times and USA Today, bestselling author Shelley Shepard Gray launches an exhilarating new series, The Amish of Hart County, showcasing a stirring Amish romance novel revolving around a young woman's struggle against a harrowing stalker who is relentless in pursuing her. Embodying the life of a determined Amish woman named Hannah Hilty, she is compelled to relocate to escape the sinister shadows of her pursuer.

In the rural Amish town of Hart County, Kentucky, Hannah finds herself in a battle between her fears and the new life that awaits her. Her introduction to her close-knit neighbors, such as the elusive and affable Isaac Troyer, sets the stage for a profound journey of trust, faith, and heartfelt devotion. However, when hidden truths emerge and a cataclysmic event occurs, Hannah is confronted with the ultimate choice: face her demons from the past or flee once again. This gripping narrative of faith, love, and the will power of an individual will resonate with readers across all cultures and backgrounds by proving the strength of the human spirit in overcoming adversity.

  • Authors: Shelley Shepard Gray
  • Publisher: HarperCollins
  • Published Date: March 14, 2017
  • Page Count: 272.0
  • Print Type: BOOK
  • Categories: Fiction
  • Maturity Rating: NOT\_MATURE
  • Language: en

Listen Free from Amazon Audible

Enjoy for Free at Amazon Kindle

6. The Patient One

the-patient-one-439637–1

"The Patient One" by Shelley Shepard Gray is a captivating and emotionally resonant novel that explores the depths of friendship and the price of forgiveness. Seven former best friends, once inseparable, are brought back together by the tragic loss of one of their own.

As they navigate the challenges of their late twenties and the complexities of their separate lives, they must confront the unthinkable—the suicide of their friend, Andy Warner. Set against the backdrop of Walnut Creek, Ohio, this New York Times bestselling author delves into the raw, uncharted territories of grief and guilt, intertwining the lives of Amish, Mennonite, and English individuals in a heartrending tale of healing and redemption.

With her evocative storytelling and unforgettable characters, Gray weaves a tale of unwavering loyalty, understanding, and the power of unity in the face of adversity. Don't miss this enthralling journey through the human experience, bound by the threads of friendship that endure even the seemingly unendurable.

  • Authors: Shelley Shepard Gray
  • Publisher: Simon and Schuster
  • Published Date: April 09, 2019
  • Page Count: 304.0
  • Print Type: BOOK
  • Categories: Fiction
  • Maturity Rating: NOT\_MATURE
  • Language: en

Hear for Free from Audible

Read for Free from Amazon Kindle

7. The Loyal One

the-loyal-one-253765–1

From the New York Times bestselling author of the Walnut Creek series comes a heartwarming tale of friendship, secrets, and second chances in "The Loyal One. " When Katie Steury asks her old friend Harley Lambright to remodel her rundown old house, they must navigate their tumultuous past to create something beautiful in their present. As they both come to terms with their secrets, they work together to renovate the house — and their lives.

"The Loyal One" is the perfect read for fans of Kathleen Fuller and Beth Wiseman, exploring the power of new beginnings and the enduring strength of loyalty.

  • Authors: Shelley Shepard Gray
  • Publisher: Simon and Schuster
  • Published Date: August 13, 2019
  • Page Count: 304.0
  • Print Type: BOOK
  • Categories: Fiction
  • Maturity Rating: NOT\_MATURE
  • Language: en

Listen for Free at Audible

Enjoy Free on Amazon Kindle Unlimited

8. Save the Last Dance

save-the-last-dance-439633–1

In the thrilling conclusion of the Dance with Me series, Shelley Shepard Gray takes us to Bridgeport, Ohio, where life seems simple, and love takes you by surprise. Kimber Klein, who traded her modeling life for peace and self-discovery, finds herself entangled in a world of mystery with a suspicious stalker lurking in her past.

Meanwhile, single dad Gunnar Law is eager to adopt his foster son, Jeremy, but his life takes an unexpected turn when he comes across a beautiful woman in dire need of help. In this heartwarming tale filled with second chances and unforeseen romance, love blossoms when least expected.

With a cast of characters that remind us family isn't just about bloodlines, Save the Last Dance offers a captivating and emotional journey that will linger long after the final chapter.

  • Authors: Shelley Shepard Gray
  • Publisher: Blackstone Publishing
  • Published Date: November 17, 2020
  • Page Count: 221.0
  • Print Type: BOOK
  • Categories: Fiction
  • Maturity Rating: MATURE
  • Language: en

Enjoy Free at Audible

Enjoy for Free via Amazon Kindle

9. A Perfect Amish Romance

a-perfect-amish-romance-192747–1

Delve into the magical world of faith, romance, and secret desires in Shelley Shepard Gray's captivating new novel, A Perfect Amish Romance. As a bookmobile driver-turned-matchmaker, Sarah Anne Miller is passionate about helping her Amish community find love and connection. However, she soon learns that her patrons require more than just books to mend their broken hearts. Aaron Coblentz, a man with a well-hidden desire to climb the professional ladder, finds himself drawn to Sarah Anne's bookmobile for study guides. Little did he know that he would also fall prey to the magic of love.

Joining him on this heartwarming journey is Kayla Kaufman, a hardworking girl who has faced immense grief and loss. Desperate for an escape, she turns to the romance novels provided by Sarah Anne, seeking solace in the embrace of fictional love stories. However, as fate would have it, Aaron and Kayla soon realize that they too can find their happy ever after.

As Shelley Shepard Gray brings us the tale of faith, love, and the unexpected beauty found in life's most unpredictable twists, be prepared to be charmed and inspired by the exquisite storytelling of a "skilled storyteller who reminds the reader that faith can help us survive the ups and downs in life" (RT Book Reviews). A Perfect Amish Romance is a mesmerizing and heartfelt read, perfect for those seeking to rediscover the power of true love in all its forms. This 320-page masterpiece is truly a must-read for all lovers of fiction.

  • Authors: Shelley Shepard Gray
  • Publisher: Gallery Books
  • Published Date: January 19, 2021
  • Page Count: 320.0
  • Print Type: BOOK
  • Categories: Fiction
  • Maturity Rating: NOT\_MATURE
  • Language: en

Hear Free via Audible

Explore Free with Amazon Kindle

10. An Amish Schoolroom

an-amish-schoolroom-416777–1

Three Stories

Embrace the warmth and charm of an Amish Schoolroom as three heartwarming stories unfold, each celebrating new beginnings, love, and community. In "A Class for Laurel" by Amy Clipston, adventurous Laurel Weaver finds herself torn between love and duty, while Glen Troyer awaits her decision.

"A Lesson on Love" by Kathleen Fuller delves into the delicate balance of faith and love as Priscilla Helmuth discovers the true meaning of home. Finally, "Wendy's Twenty Reasons" by Shelley Shepard Gray takes readers on an unforgettable journey of resilience, love, and the power of community in the face of adversity. These delightful novellas will ignite your heart as you discover the joy of love and the beauty of life in the Amish community.

With discussion questions for book clubs, this 75,000-word collection is a touching and heartwarming read you won't want to miss.

  • Authors: Amy Clipston, Kathleen Fuller, Shelley Shepard Gray
  • Publisher: Zondervan
  • Published Date: August 03, 2021
  • Page Count: 337.0
  • Print Type: BOOK
  • Categories: Fiction
  • Average Rating: 4.0
  • Ratings Count: 1.0
  • Maturity Rating: NOT\_MATURE
  • Language: en

Stream for Free with Amazon Audible

Enjoy for Free with Amazon Kindle

11. An Amish Quilting Bee

an-amish-quilting-bee-416763–1

Three Stories

Embark on a cozy journey with three enchanting Amish quilting stories and budding romances. In Patchwork Promises by Amy Clipston, Colin Zook must overcome a heartbreaking loss and the responsibilities of his family farm.

As Joanne Lapp recreates a loved family quilt, will she see past Colin's commitments and embrace their blossoming love? In A Common Thread by Kathleen Fuller, Susie Glick and her quilting circle are taken by surprise as Alex Lehman returns to town, but can they trust in love despite his past?

Lastly, in Stitched Together by Shelley Shepard Gray, Rosie grapples with quilt-making chaos and the promise of love with Tim Christner, who is only in town for a short time. As these women navigate love and friendship, join them in crafting warm memories with your own quilted romance. With a length of 75,000 words, 336 pages, and included discussion questions for book clubs, immerse yourself in this delightful collection by authors Amy Clipston, Kathleen Fuller, and Shelley Shepard Gray.

  • Authors: Amy Clipston, Kathleen Fuller, Shelley Shepard Gray
  • Publisher: Zondervan
  • Published Date: December 07, 2021
  • Page Count: 336.0
  • Print Type: BOOK
  • Categories: Fiction
  • Average Rating: 5.0
  • Ratings Count: 1.0
  • Maturity Rating: NOT\_MATURE
  • Language: en

Hear Free from Audible

Explore for Free at Amazon Kindle Unlimited

12. Edgewater Road

edgewater-road-439634–1

When Jennifer Smiley inherits an old farmhouse from her grandmother on the quiet Edgewater Road in Ross County, Ohio, it feels like a much-needed fresh start. The house's charm quickly attracts a group of friendly men from her neighbor Lincoln Bennett's group, sparking her curiosity.

As Jennifer and Lincoln's relationship develops, so does the intriguing mystery surrounding her grandmother's past and Lincoln's troubled history. In the process of unraveling Edgewater Road's secrets, Jennifer discovers a network of friends, a picturesque town, and unexpected revelations about her own absent father. As their connection deepens, Jennifer and Lincoln must navigate both the unveiled secrets and the challenges that come with starting anew.

This compelling debut novel, penned by New York Times bestselling author Shelley Shepard Gray, combines engaging narratives, heartwarming friendships, and the exhilaration of small-town secrets waiting to unfold.

  • Authors: Shelley Shepard Gray
  • Publisher: Blackstone Publishing
  • Published Date: March 01, 2022
  • Page Count: 288.0
  • Print Type: BOOK
  • Categories: Fiction
  • Average Rating: 5.0
  • Ratings Count: 1.0
  • Maturity Rating: NOT\_MATURE
  • Language: en

Listen Free at Audible

Explore Free @ Amazon Kindle

--

--