Most Loyal Footballers Pt1

Most Loyal Footballers: Which Players Have Only Played for One Team?

In the modern era of football, the “one-club man” seems to be a bit of a dying breed. Due to the enormous amount of money in the sport, and the constant transfer merry-go-round that occurs every summer and every January, it is becoming increasingly rare to find a player who manages to stick it out at just one football club for their entire professional career. With the pressure from agents, managers, perhaps the enticing prospect of a high-profile move to a big club, or even just the fact that one day a club’s ownership could decide that a player is no longer needed, some of the most loyal footballers end up moving on. However, in this article, we will take a look at some modern one-club men, as well as some of the game’s most loyal legends who never left their boyhood club.

Francesco Totti

Club: Roma

Appearances (all comps): 786

Goals: 307

Nickname(s): Er Bimbo de Oro (The Golden Boy), L’Ottavo Re di Roma (The Eighth King of Rome), Il Capitano (The Captain), Er Pupone (The Big Baby)

Is there a man on the planet who epitomises loyalty more than Francesco Totti? Born and raised in Rome, the city where he spent his entire football career, the forward is regularly classed as Roma’s greatest ever player and played an astounding 25 seasons for i Lupi. Not only is Totti Roma’s top goal scorer of all time, but he also holds the record for the most Serie A goals scored for a single club. L’Ottavo Re di Roma is the second top-scorer in Italian football league history, behind Silvio Piola, with an exceptional 250 league goals to his name. However, this could all have been so different, if it hadn’t been for the loyalty of his mother. When Totti was a youth player, and showing great potential, the family received a lucrative offer from AC Milan, yet his mum turned it down to allow the young lad to stay in his native Rome, a decision that set the precedent for the fierce loyalty to his city and club that characterised the forward’s illustrious career.

This was, however, not the only time another club attempted to prise Totti away from his beloved Roma. The striker also revealed recently, in an interview with the Guardian, that he had been “on the cusp” of leaving his boyhood club to join Real Madrid in the summer of 2004. Los Blancos had reportedly been pursuing Roma’s “Golden Boy” since 2001, but the prospect of bringing him to Madrid hadn’t seemed realistic up to this point. Now 27, Totti was hot property, having scored 68 goals in 138 appearances over the last four seasons, establishing himself as one of Europe’s most prolific attacking talents. The Italian international, who played 58 times for his country, had had to often carry Roma on his back for much of the last few seasons, as they seemed to be in decline following their success in winning the 2000/01 Scudetto. It therefore seemed a natural step for the forward to take, considering that, after what he had done for the club, its hard to believe that any of Roma’s fanbase would blame him for making such a move, yet the Golden Boy remained. His heart was in Rome, and in Rome he remained for the rest of his career, where he gave everything for his boyhood team until his eventual retirement in 2017, aged 40.

Mark Noble

Club: West Ham

Appearances: 550

Goals: 62

Nickname(s): Mr West Ham

A man whose middle name is loyalty, Mark Noble is perhaps the most prominent recent example of a Premier League one-club man. A boyhood West Ham fan who grew up in East London, just a mile away from Upton Park, the midfielder absolutely lives and breathes the Hammers, spending eighteen seasons at his club, showing fearsome loyalty that is very unique within the modern game. Noble joined West Ham as a youth player in 2000, and stayed there until his retirement in 2022, bar two short loan spells to Hull City and Ipswich Town in 2006. If you need any more proof of the man’s loyalty, he has been with his wife, Carly since they were only 14 years old! The former England Youth international, who is regularly named as one of the best players never to win a senior England cap, was a penalty specialist; his conversion rate of 90.5% from the spot is the second-best in the world in the past 20 years, behind a certain Robert Lewandowski.

Noble has been praised for his unwavering loyalty to his club; after West Ham were relegated to the Championship in the 2010/11 season, there were several Premier League sides vying for his signature. However, the Hammers captain decided to say and help the club fight their way straight back to the Premier League. In recognition of the loyalty and commitment shown by the midfielder throughout his career, West Ham announced in 2022 that they would rename the Young Hammer of the Year Award to the “Mark Noble Award.” The club’s iconic number 16 was one of a dying breed, a player that would die for the badge, even in the darkest times, and he is, to many, considered as West Ham’s greatest ever player.

Paolo Maldini

Club: AC Milan

Appearances: 902

Goals: 33

Nickname(s): Il Capitano (The Captain)

Following on from Totti in the ranks of legendary Italian one-club men, we have arguably the greatest defender of all time, Paolo Maldini. Born in Milan, the city where he spent his entire career, he joined AC Milan’s youth setup as a teenager, and stayed at the club until his eventual retirement in 2009, aged 41. The left-back played a remarkable 25 seasons for I Rossoneri, making a record 902 appearances for the club in all competitions. Now that’s loyalty. The legendary defender also served as captain of both Milan and Italy for a number of years, and made a total of 126 appearances for his country, scoring seven goals. Although fiercely loyal to his beloved Milan, Maldini has revealed, in a recent interview with RMC Sport, that the only club in the world that he would have considered leaving Milan for would have been Real Madrid, as they were “the club who were most similar to Milan”. However, it does not appear that this was a move that was ever on the cards.

In fairness to Maldini, who would want to leave their boyhood club where they were captain, had arguably the best team in the world, and were winning basically every trophy possible? During his career, Il Capitano won seven Serie A titles, five Champions leagues, including being named man of the match in the 2003 final, and numerous other trophies. A calm, composed defender, Maldini was an incredibly difficult opponent for any attacker and a true leader of men, renowned for his discipline throughout his career: he only ever picked up three red cards in over 1,000 competitive matches. A true icon and gentleman of the game.

Iker Munian

Club: Athletic Bilbao

Appearances: 543(as of October 2023)

Goals: 74

Nickname(s): “The Spanish Messi”

Perhaps a rather underrated one-club man, Iker Munian is already into his 14th season at Athletic Bilbao, at the tender age of 29. The winger joined the Basque club aged just 12 years old, having been born in nearby Pamplona, and made his first team debut in 2009, aged just 16 years and 7 months, making him their youngest ever first-team player. Since his debut, the Spaniard has been a key part of his club’s starting XI, and now serves as club captain, testament to both his loyalty and leadership ability. In 2022, the 30-year old became just the sixth player to make 500 appearances for Athletic Club, and he’s showing no signs of slowing down; he is very likely to become the club’s record appearance-maker.

As is customary for a player who bursts onto the scene at such a young age (not you, Micah Richards), Munian’s breakout into the Bilbao first team led to interest from some of Europe’s most prestigious clubs. Throughout his career, there have been numerous transfer approaches made for the winger, who has been linked to the likes of Manchester United, Juventus, and Liverpool. As recently as 2018, there was vast speculation that the Bilbao captain would be on his way to Anfield, as his contract was due to expire in the summer, and at age 25, it would have been the perfect time for him to get his big move. However, the “Spanish Messi” instead decided to remain at his beloved club, signing a 6-year deal that would both keep him tied down until 2024, and shut down Jurgen Klopp’s interest. There were similar episodes in 2012, when Manchester United were interested, or in 2014 when Manchester City were reportedly linked with Munian, yet through this sea of speculation, the winger has remained commendably loyal to his club, where he seems likely to remain for the rest of his career.

Paul Scholes

Club: Manchester United

Appearances: 718

Goals: 155

Nickname: Scholesy, Sat Nav, The Ginger Ninja

Following on from Mark Noble in the ranks of great, diminutive, English midfield one-club men, although more of a technically gifted player, we have Paul Scholes, one of the greatest midfielders of all time. Scholes spent his entire career with Manchester United, for whom he played 19 consecutive seasons, although he very briefly retired at the end of the 2010/11 season. A supremely talented, technically brilliant midfielder who could “do everything”, Scholes was described by Thierry Henry as “without any doubt the best player in the Premiership”. The red-haired midfielder was renowned for his shooting ability from range, and regularly scored for the Red Devils; his goals were usually spectacular. His most prolific season came in 2002/03, in which he scored 20 goals in all competitions, including 14 in the Premier League, as United lifted the league title. Scholes was born in Salford, Greater Manchester, and joined the Red Devils’ youth academy aged 14, remaining at the club until his eventual retirement aged 38, and lifting 25 trophies on the way. Nicknamed “Sat Nav” for his unerring ability to find teammates with his pinpoint passing, the midfielder is one of the greatest English players of all time and is regularly ranked amongst legends of the game such as Xavi and Iniesta.

Despite showing immense loyalty to his club, where he spent his entire career under a single manager, Sir Alex Ferguson, there were a couple of occasions where the midfield maestro was close to leaving. Firstly, in 1996, when United were desperate to sign a certain Alan Shearer from Blackburn Rovers, the Riversides demanded that any deal for Shearer would include an exchange for Scholes, who was valued by the Red Devils at £5 million. However, this move never materialised, and the striker instead joined Newcastle. Wonder if he was any good there? The second occasion in which Scholesy came close to leaving his beloved United came much later, in 2011/12, following his brief retirement. Although he had retired, the midfielder was training with Manchester United’s reserve team, whilst also working as a coach, and this seems to have brought back his desire to put his boots back on, and he very rapidly came out of retirement. Scholes approached Ferguson, saying that he wished to play again, but would understand and look for another club if he was no longer wanted at Old Trafford, considering that he was 36 at the time. However, due to an injury crisis in midfield, Scholes was immediately whisked back into the first team, where he continued to dazzle, playing 2 more seasons before hanging up his boots for good in 2013.

Carles Puyol

Club: Barcelona

Appearances: 593

Goals: 18

Nickname: El Tiburon (The Shark), The Wall

It is a common theme for great one-club men to be natural leaders, to give their heart and soul for their club, and Carles Puyol perhaps embodies these characteristics more than any other player. Born in a small town in Catalonia, the defender joined Barcelona’s prestigious La Masia academy as a teenager, initially playing as a defensive midfielder, then a right-back, before he was eventually converted into a central defender. Puyol went on to become one the greatest centre-halves of all time, appearing 593 times for Barcelona in his 15 seasons at the club. Described by Xavi as the “key” to the Catalan club’s immense success throughout the 2000s and 2010s, El Tiburon won six La Liga titles, three Champions Leagues, and lifted the World Cup with Spain in 2010. The defender was regularly praised for his commitment and work ethic, not just on the pitch, but off it: he would often stay behind after training to put in extra work, and regularly spent his days off at the training ground, perfecting his craft. The Spaniard was a committed, aggressive yet composed defender who was a fearsome opponent for any striker. Puyol lived and breathed Barca, and formed a hugely successful partnership with Gerard Pique, whose ball-playing prowess made him an ideal partner to Puyol’s no-nonsense style of play, and the two were Spain’s centre-back pairing in their victory in the 2010 World Cup final.

Despite being one of the club’s greatest ever players, there were several occasions in which Puyol came close to leaving Camp Nou, although these were never driven by the defender himself. In 1998, Barcelona accepted a transfer offer for Puyol from Malaga, who was seen as the club’s third choice right-back at the time, yet “The Wall” refused to leave, as he wanted to stay and fight for his place. Having seen his best mate Xavi, who he had come through the academy with, make his first team debut, Puyol believed that he could stay and make the same step. Safe to say this worked out for him! Another moment of doubt came in the 2003 off-season, when Manchester United reportedly came in for the shaggy-haired centre-half. Barcelona were knee-deep in financial problems, and were looking to offload players from the wage bill, and it seemed as if United could snap him up at a discounted price. However, this move never materialised, as Puyol’s unwavering loyalty kept him at Barca by any means necessary; he was named club captain for the next season, showing his leadership ability and his importance to the team.

Franco Baresi

Club: AC Milan

Appearances: 719

Goals: 33

Nickname(s): Piscinin (Little One), Kaiser Franz (a reference to his similarity to Franz Beckenbauer)

Finally, we have another of the greatest centre-backs of all time, and an incredibly loyal one-club man, Franco Baresi. The AC Milan stalwart, who spent the entirety of his 20-year career with i Rosseneri, played largely as a sweeper, and was highly effective in his position. Despite only standing at 5 ft 9, the defender was both supremely powerful and elegant, blessed with great pace, strength and stamina, as well as a fantastic leap that made him a fearsome aerial presence. A product of Milan’s youth academy, Baresi made his first team debut aged just 17, and quickly established himself as one of the club’s top players. The centre-back was a fantastic leader: he captained his club for 15 seasons and was also named as Italy’s captain for the 1994 World Cup. In the latter stages of his career, Baresi formed an unbelievably successful partnership with Paolo Maldini: of the 196 games that the two played together, they only conceded 23 goals! The defender was incredibly loyal to Milan, and his commitment and outstanding contributions to the club led them to retire his iconic shirt number six.

Although he went on to become one of AC Milan’s greatest ever players, Baresi actually had trials at Inter as a youth, but they rejected him in favour of his brother, Giuseppe, who went on to become Inter’s captain. Milan then came in for Franco, and the love story began. However, the defender’s first years at Milan coincided with a dark period in the club’s history: in the early 1980s, they were relegated to Serie B on two occasions. Having just won the World Cup with Italy in 1982, it seemed illogical for the hugely talented centre-half to remain at a team who weren’t even competing in the country’s top division, but Baresi was not the kind to give up, and he elected to stay at his beloved Milan. Aged just 22, the defender was appointed first-team captain, and retained this role for the majority of his career, as he helped the club rebuild and embark on a golden era. In the late 80s and 90s, Milan were incredibly successful, and when Baresi retired in 1997, aged 37, he had accumulated six Serie A titles, three Champions Leagues, a World Cup, and numerous other trophies.