Playing Mr. Mom Versus Being a Dad

My son and I

I originally wrote this back in 2010, but am sharing it today for Father’s Day.

When my wife went back to work half-time after our first son was born, I rearranged my schedule so that I could spend a few mornings a week at home. My wife stayed home with our baby for the first year of his life, and I was excited about the idea of having more time him. It was a chance for me to be an even greater part of raising him in these early years, and came with the added benefit of saving us some daycare costs.

One day I packed my son into the car first thing in the morning and headed out to a state park to spend the morning hiking the trails and splashing in the lake. For an hour or so, we were the only people there and I enjoyed sharing the solitude of that place with him as he explored shoreline of the lake.

Inevitably he got soaked playing in the water, and so, it was about mid morning, just as other people started to arrive at the park, that I propped him up on a nearby picnic table to change him into dry clothes. As I put on a new diaper a woman walked by and said, “Are you playing Mr. Mom today?”

“Are you playing Mr. Mom today?”

I hear this all the time.

Why is it that, for so many people, seeing a man caring for his child is still a surprise? Why is it treated like a game, as though I’m just “playing house?” And why is it that people can only understand a father nurturing his son through the frame of “Mr. Mom?”

The term “Mr. Mom,” even when used in a joke or with a wink, perpetuates a whole range of stereotypes about men, fathers, and families that continue to haunt American culture in powerful ways. It reinforces the notion of women as the nurturer and men as the breadwinner, and suggests that for men to be caring and nurturing they have to put on a persona other than just simply being a dad. As if by caring for your child or being nurturing you are not being a father, you are being a surrogate mother. In addition, it constructs the ideal family unit with men at the margins, suggesting their relationships with their kids is not as important and the relationship between mother and children. Not to mention, the ways it reinforces heterosexual family structures.

This isn’t just limited to one or two passers-by at state parks and on street corners. The “Mr. Mom” meme is pervasive — sitcoms, commercials, pop songs, movies. Even in the “progressive” parenting magazines we get at home, instances of stay at home dads or fathers acting as an equal part of the parenting effort are treated as special cases, worthy of extra praise and attention.

We can’t define good fatherhood as simply a mimicry of motherhood.

Don’t get me wrong, it’s vital to celebrate and highlight men who are embracing their roles as caring fathers. We need to promote new images of masculinity and new ideas about families and parenting, but we need to do so in a ways that breakdown old roles, not ways that reinforce stubborn stereotypes. We can’t just redefine good fatherhood as simply a mimicry of motherhood — that’s not fair to either parents. We need to talk about fatherhood in new ways and honor men, not for being mother-like, but just for being good dads.

As the American family changes, we are seeing single parent households, same-sex house holds, extended family homes, homelessness, adoptive families and more. Irregardless of the shape, size, and scope of the family — our children need mentors and role models, love and attention, support and guidance, tenderness and firmness, laughter and encouragement, and more. None of this is the sole province of a mother or a father.

I’m not playing Mr. Mom. I’m just being a dad.


Originally published at stearns.wordpress.com on August 14, 2010, revised June, 21, 2015.

One clap, two clap, three clap, forty?

By clapping more or less, you can signal to us which stories really stand out.